Showing posts with label PP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PP. Show all posts

Thursday, August 21, 2014

Nkandlagate - Pay back the Money

Parliament - President Jacob Zuma did not return to the National Assembly to complete Thursday afternoon’s questions session after the Economic Freedom Fighters brought the House to a standstill with shouts of “Where is the money?” related to the taxpayer-funded security upgrades at his Nkandla homestead.

“Honourable members, we are faced with a situation we are unable to continue with the sitting and have allowed the president to proceed with the work of his office,” National Assembly Speaker Baleka Mbete announced after MPs were allowed to return to the chamber after more than an hour.

Chaos broke out when EFF MPs insisted Zuma respond to their follow-up question on when he would repay the money spent on the Nkandla security upgrades, shouting “Where is the money?”.



EFF parliamentary leader Julius Malema had asked the question when the president would respond to the public protector’s report - she found he had to repay at least some of the costs of the non-security upgrades like the swimming pool, cattle kraal and visitors’ centre. Zuma earlier simply said he had responded to the public protector findings and other reports in his response to Parliament last Thursday.

After an acrimonious exchange on points of order - the EFF insisted Zuma had to answer, the Speaker said he had and must move on - Mbete suspended the House.

All MPs stayed in their seats until she returned to say security staff had ask everyone to vacate. Parliamentary staff and police initially tried to evict the media from the press gallery. However, agreement was eventually reached with the Parliamentary Press Gallery Association (PGA), for journalists to stay on.

During the break unfolded various negotiations involving Police Minister Nkosinathi Nhleko, State Security Minister David Mahlobo and - surprisingly -Telecommunications and Postal Services Minister Siyabonga Cwele, the former state security minister. Western Cape police commissioner General Arno Lamoer was also in the House. The Presidency was also consulted.

At one stage Nhleko and Mahlobo talked with Malema, EFF chief whip Floyd Shivambu and another EFF MP.

However the 25 EFF MPs stayed put and sung struggle songs, vowed to sleep in the Chamber and sung “iSono sethu yile Nkandla [Our only sin is Nkandla]”.

Shortly after 4pm MPs were allowed back into the House, and Mbete made her announcement that proceedings would not resume, leaving three presidential questions unanswered.

Zuma’s question time in the House was the first this year. Parliament and the presidency cited diary challenges for not having secured slots in either the first term of this Parliament or the last term of the past Parliament before the May 7 elections. Under the current custom, the president is supposed to answer questions in the House at least once a term.

It is unclear when he will do so.

- Political Bureau

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Nkandla report rips into Zuma's Cabinet

In her report on President Zuma's homestead, Thuli Madonsela has documented a damning trail of maladministration by state ministers and officials.

Public protector Thuli Madonsela's report uncovered a trail of maladministration, from ministers to officials, starting with a lack of basic knowledge about the laws and policies governing security upgrades for projects such as President Jacob Zuma's Nkandla homestead. 

Madonsela said on Wednesday, during a media briefing of her office's findings, that "systemic" policy gaps and "administrative deficiencies" had led to the inflation of costs.

"Key among these being the absence of a cap and an integrated instrument such as the ministerial handbook, where all permissible measures can be found."

The Cabinet policy of 2003 is problematic because it applies to presidents, former presidents, deputy presidents and former deputy presidents.

"The risk of unbridled expenditure in the future is very real and needs immediate curbing."

What constitutes maladministration?
Madonsela instructed Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa to urgently institute a review of the National Key Points Act and to stop any further spending on Nkandla.

The minister of public works at the time, Geoff Doidge, gave Zuma the wrong information about the legal prescripts governing the Nkandla upgrades. The minister of police was no better, she said.

"The minister of police failed to properly apply his mind when signing the declaration of President Jacob Zuma's private residence as a national key point, directing the president to implement security measures at [his] own cost or to properly modify the declaration. This constitutes maladministration."

She said Doidge and Mthethwa "could have provided better executive leadership, especially with regard to speedily assessing the extent and cost of the Nkandla project, particularly when the media broke the story in 2009, and taking decisive measures to curb excessive expenditure."

This also amounted to maladministration, she said.

Supply chain management errors
Officials at the department of public works officials also did not know the basic legal framework surrounding the Nkandla upgrades, Madonsela said.

Many supply chain management errors were therefore allowed to occur: tenders were not advertised, contractors were not properly vetted and costs continued to escalate.

Madonsela also found that funds were transferred from two programmes to build Nkandla – an inner city regeneration programme and "dolomite risk management programme" at the department of public works. This constituted maladministration.

- M&G

Final Nkandla report expected today

The report relating to upgrades at President Jacob Zuma's Nkandla homestead will be released by Public Protector Thuli Madonsela on Wednesday.

This comes as political pressure mounts on Madonsela, over some of her other recent investigations.

Agriculture minister Tina Joemat-Pettersson, for one, is legally challenging adverse findings against her, by the public protector.

“I believe that her office has disrespected the office of the president by not sending him an official version of her report three months after the report is due,” Joemat-Pettersson has said.

Madonsela responded with: “She has a right of course not to be satisfied with any part of my report. The right procedure would have been for her to refer the matter to the President and wait for him to apply his mind.”

All of this is largely seen as part of a wider campaign to discredit Thuli Madonsela, as she prepares to release her much-anticipated report into the more than R206-million upgrade at President Zuma’s private residence in Nkandla.

A cloud of controversy has surrounded what has been described as security upgrades at the homestead in KwaZulu-Natal.

In November, the Mail&Guardian reported that Madonsela had found in her preliminary report that Zuma had misled Parliament and benefited substantially from the upgrade.

An inter-ministerial task team report on the Nkandla expenditure was released in December, after it was declassified, confirming that a total of R206,420,644 was spent on the upgrade.

Public Works Minister Thulas Nxesi, who initially classified the report, said at its release that allegations that Zuma had used state resources to build and upgrade the residence were unfounded.

If the president is deemed to have benefitted personally from any of the renovations, he could be held financially liable.

And if he’s found to have misled Parliament over his knowledge of the upgrade, DA Parliamentary leader Lindiwe Mazibuko says her party will demand Parliament be reconvened, to debate a motion to impeach Zuma.

The ANC has deemed the report political, and feels the timing and neutrality of an investigation involving the president so close to an election should be questioned.

This report is close on two years in the making.

Its release date was expected to be around February 9, a few days before President Jacob Zuma's state-of-the-nation address, but Madonsela extended the deadline for responses at the request of one of the parties.

Madonsela has been criticised by the African National Congress for her handling of the probe, with the party's secretary general Gwede Mantashe accusing her of trying to "muddy the waters in the election campaign".

Madonsela has dismissed this claim.

Nonetheless, the outcome of her report and the reaction of political parties are likely to affect the psyches of many South Africans, come Election Day on May 7th.

* Watch a special feature "Impoverished Nkandla residents ‘forgotten’ by Zuma" in the gallery above, along with eNCA reporter, Nickolaus Bauer's video report into the political pressure mounting against Public Protector, Thuli Madonsela.

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

Nkandla report: clock is ticking

Cape Town - The clock is ticking towards Wednesday’s release of the public protector’s probe into Nkandla. But whether it will lead to an easing of the political pressure on Thuli Madonsela remains to be seen.

At the weekend, the ANC downplayed the possible impact of the report, months after the governing party issued crib sheets to its electioneering volunteers on how to answer any prickly questions about the R208 million taxpayer-funded security upgrades at President Jacob Zuma’s rural homestead.

On the campaign trail in Sasolburg, Public Service and Administration Minister Lindiwe Sisulu said: “I hope she has completed her investigation because for an investigation of this magnitude, I don’t think she has given herself enough time.”

Meanwhile, City Press cited unnamed sources, saying the ANC and allies such as the SACP would downplay the findings and instead focus on discrediting the report.

Commenting on remarks by outgoing National Planning Minister Trevor Manuel that attacks on institutions like the public protector would damage South Africa’s constitutional democracy, Sapa quotes ANC secretary-general Gwede Mantashe as saying “we do not attack the public protector, but criticise her when we feel we should”.

These comments follow days after a group of bishops representing independent African churches last week criticised the public protector for “poisoning the atmosphere”. Earlier this month, the ANC in eThekwini marched against the public protector, accusing her of withholding her Nkandla report.

This week, Pubic Works Minister Thulas Nxesi confirmed in a parliamentary reply that the auditor-general and the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) were also conducting probes into the spending at Nkandla. This matter first arose in the security ministers’ court papers filed in December, when it emerged that during a series of meetings between Madonsela and the security ministers there had been a push to have her probe stand aside for investigations by the auditor-general and the SIU.

Friday, November 8, 2013

Nkandla: Did Thuli Madonsela fall for public works’ spin?

Court affidavits suggest the public protector was not given all the documents that would allow for a comprehensive investigation.

Did Public Protector Thuli Madonsela rely on a set of records carefully circumscribed by the department of public works in reaching her conclusion that reportedly exonerates President Jacob Zuma of blame for ­Nkandlagate?

When the scandal first exploded into public view last year, the department and its minister, Thulas Nxesi, claimed absolute secrecy was necessary to maintain Zuma’s safety. Not even the cost of the upgrade could be revealed.

However, on November 5 last year Madonsela demanded that the department hand over documents. Within a week the task team that Nxesi had, in the meantime, appointed to do an internal investigation arrived at the department’s Durban office, which was directly responsible for the upgrade.

There, according to an affidavit filed by the department resisting amaBhungane’s court application heard in the Pretoria high court this week, it made arrangements to “collect all the documents related to the Nkandla security upgrade”.

The resultant trove, 42 files of over 12 000 pages, according to the affidavit and the department’s arguments in court this week, was what was copied for both the task team and Madonsela’s use in their respective investigations.

AmaBhungane, formally the M&G Centre for Investigative Journalism, had already demanded records under the Promotion of Access to Information Act (PAIA) in July last year.

It was met by circles of defence by the department, which raised barrier after barrier as it was forced to give ground, retreating to an ever-more limited but all the more fiercely defended core. It appears that Madonsela never breached it.

Through its court application, amaBhungane hopes to go where her office appears not to have.

Road to court


The process began with the department refusing point blank, on August 27 last year, to comply with amaBhungane’s PAIA request. “Please be advised,” it wrote, “that Nkandla presidential residence, like all other presidential residences in South Africa, is a national key point …”

As the department’s lawyers were later forced to concede, this response failed to satisfy – or even address – any of the provisions of PAIA. It appears to have been a bluff, presumably in the hope of shrugging off the request by invoking apartheid security legislation.

As PAIA allows, amaBhungane appealed to the minister. He obtained legal advice from senior counsel. But rather than use this advice to grapple with the merits of the appeal, Nxesi chose not to respond, suggesting the advice was not to his liking.

AmaBhungane’s advocate, Wim Trengove SC, this week submitted in court that Nxesi had “decided not to discharge his statutory duty” and “breached his of oath of office”. This left amaBhungane with no option but to file a high court application last November, forcing the department to defend its position on the affidavit.

The new director general, Mzi­wonke Dlabantu, elaborated on the security defence, claiming under oath that “the documents sought are so replete with security related information that they cannot be disclosed without disclosing security sensitive information at the same time”.

This was so obvious, Dlabantu argued, that the department would seek a costs award as amaBhungane should have foreseen that the department was bound to silence by security considerations.

In March this year, amaBhungane filed what would normally have been a final round of affidavits before the matter went to court. In the interim its lawyers tracked down a civil engineer with extensive experience in public works projects. He confirmed under oath that such a project would generate many documents that had no security implications.

AmaBhungane also attached three internal documents about the Nkandla project that it had received anonymously. They betrayed no security secrets, but showed how key discussions – such as apportioning some of the costs to Zuma – had been referred to the ministry and “top management” in Pretoria.

Disclosures: the missing documents

Faced with the inevitable, the department conceded. It turned over 12,253 pages of evidence. Bar just three documents it now claimed contained actual security-sensitive information, it gave amaBhungane the same 42 files provided to Madonsela and the task team.

The about-face gave the lie to the director general’s earlier claim that the documents were “so replete” with security related information that nothing could be disclosed, and highlighted the habit of states to use sensitivity about security as a pretext for hiding embarrassment.

But on analysis, glaring omissions became apparent in the documents. Although comprehensive disclosures were made of records generated by the Durban project team and its contractors, there was almost no material from head office in Pretoria – almost nothing involving the minister, deputy minister and top officials, and certainly the president.

But there were many signs that such records must exist: references, inter alia, to other documents and interactions with “top management” and “the principal” (Zuma).

In a further exchange of letters and affidavits, amaBhungane demanded to know about the missing documents. The department’s response made it clear that this was the core that had to be defended. It claimed no further documents relevant to the request could be found.

In court this week, the department conceded it had made no attempt to locate the Nkandla files at head office in Pretoria, where the ministry and senior officials are housed. It argued amaBhungane’s request for information could be narrowly construed as relating purely to supply chain processes, which had been handled at the regional office.

What it did not say was that the evidence being sought might illuminate the actions and accountability of senior officials and the president. And it repeatedly confirmed that the records given to amaBhungane were the same as those given to Madonsela and the task team.

Media leaks about Madon­sela’s report suggest that she reached similar conclusions to the task team. One article quoted sources who had read her draft as saying it painted “a picture of senior government officials bending over backwards to please President Jacob Zuma without his instructions”.

But the jury remains out until it is known what was recorded in Pretoria and not just in the regional office in Durban.

Madonsela’s office said in response to inquiries: “We cannot confirm what documents we have obtained as part of the investigation. The public protector can only reveal that information in the final report.”

Disclosure: The authors are members of amaBhungane and party to the litigation

- M&G

Monday, August 26, 2013

Nkandla report coming soon: Madonsela

- SABC
Government has spent R200 million on security upgrades of President Jacob Zuma’s personal residence. (SABC)
Public Protector, Thuli Madonsela, says the provisional report of her investigation into President Jacob Zuma's house in Nkandla will be finalised soon. 

Madonsela is investigating whether state money was abused for security upgrades at the president's private residence.

Government spent over R200 million on upgrades and consultants.

Madonsela says the report has already been drafted and bound. “We're just waiting for a bit more information…when we get that we should be able to factor it in within about five days, depending on the nature of the investigation and we shall then share the provisional report with only the affected parties.”

Friday, July 26, 2013

Protector’s Nkandla report almost ready

PUBLIC Protector Thuli Madonsela says that making public her report on the R206m upgrade of President Jacob Zuma’s Nkandla residence will require further consideration as the information contained in the Department of Public Works report on Nkandla remains classified.

Speaking in Pretoria at the release of four final reports — including one titled "Pipes to Nowhere", on claims of poor sanitation and maladministration in a Free State municipality — Ms Madonsela said the Nkandla report was 99% complete, but "some things have to be tied up".

Her office has received a copy of a report by the Department of Public Works on the upgrades — a document that has been classified as top secret.

Ms Madonsela has previously given assurances that the report will not be leaked from her office, nor will any findings compromise Mr Zuma’s security.

She said on Thursday that an investigation into systemic service delivery failures and maladministration in the Nala municipality in the Free State had substantiated most of the complaints lodged in 2012 by a group of concerned citizens.

Residents of the municipality had approached the public protector over the non-implementation in the municipality of a KPMG forensic investigation dating back to 2010 and cited numerous service delivery failures, including around sanitation.

They complained, among other things, that the municipality’s sewerage plant was not operating, flush toilets built by the municipality were not connected to anything, and the bucket system put in place to manage sanitation problems was not operating regularly.

Ms Madonsela said on Thursday her investigation had confirmed that the company responsible for the toilet system was paid for work not done, resulting in irregular, fruitless and wasteful expenditure in the municipality.

Remedial action should be taken in the form of training of municipal officials, while those implicated should face disciplinary procedures, she said.

Nala community member Smanga Selemeni expressed satisfaction with the findings of the report. He said the community now expected further action from the province and that the KPMG investigation could not long be "pushed under the carpet".

Ms Madonsela also said her office had nearly concluded a "short-term" report on the controversial landing at Waterkloof Air Force Base of a private aircraft carrying wedding guests of the politically connected Gupta family earlier in 2013. She said her office had received a complaint from an individual expressing dissatisfaction with a report on the landing made by the justice, crime prevention and security cluster.

A decision on whether the Gupta landing warranted further investigation would be taken next week, she said. - BDlive

Thursday, July 4, 2013

Report on Nkandla ‘will not be leaked’

THE wrangle around the Department of Public Works task team report on the R200m upgrade of President Jacob Zuma’s Nkandla property has taken another turn, with Public Protector Thuli Madonsela promising that the report will not be leaked from her office.

This follows Public Works Minister Thulas Nxesi handing over the report to her.

There has also been increased confusion over which minister classified the report top secret and under which law. Mr Nxesi has said State Security Minister Siyabonga Cwele classified the report, but he has denied this.

Yesterday, Ms Madonsela confirmed being in possession of the report. She gave the assurance that it would not be leaked from her office and that it would be handled in such a way as not to compromise the security of the president. Ms Madonsela reportedly said that elements of the report were helping her investigation into the spending of taxpayers’ money on Nkandla.

Earlier this week, Mr Cwele moved to distance himself from the classification of the report as top secret.

"The ministry has noted with concern various media reports relating to the classification of the Inkandla upgrade task team report and the role of the minister of state security. The report in question emanates from the work done by a JCPS (Justice, Crime Prevention and Security) task team appointed by the minister of public works.… We wish to indicate that it is factually incorrect that the Minister of State Security, Dr Siyabonga Cwele, has ‘classified the report top secret’ or issued an instruction to this effect, as claimed in some media reports.

"In terms of the prevailing classification regime, the author of the report is the one who classifies it. As the report is authored by the task team and owned by the commissioning minister of public works, the minister of state security cannot classify or declassify it or issue instructions to this effect."

Mr Nxesi had said in his letter to National Assembly speaker Max Sisulu that he was sending the report to Parliament on behalf of the state security minister and asking for it to be dealt with behind closed doors in the joint standing committee on intelligence.

Democratic Alliance (DA) parliamentary leader Lindiwe Mazibuko welcomed the fact that the report had been made available to Ms Madonsela.

"The DA has been calling for this report to be handed over to the public protector, the auditor-general and to be presented to the appropriate open public works portfolio committee in Parliament. We have maintained that the ‘classification’ of this report is invalid because neither the Minimum Information Security Standards (MISS) Cabinet policy nor the Protection of Information Act of 1982, which have been used, allow for classification of the report in law.

"The fact that the Minister of Public Works, Thulas Nxesi, has now handed this report to the public protector further proves that the report was never classified. Had it been, Adv Thuli Madonsela would have needed security clearance to even look at the report."

She said she would write to Mr Nxesi to determine whether Ms Madonsela had an appropriate security clearance and if so how it had been gained.

"I will also write to the public protector to seek clarity on whether her report will be made public. It will prove futile if the public protector is unable to make her report public because of the limitations provided under an invalid classification.

"We cannot allow for this abuse of public money to build President Zuma a palace in Nkandla to be swept under the carpet, nor can we can we allow for investigations by important public institutions to be withheld from the public. This report needs to be tabled in Parliament so that it may be scrutinised effectively," Ms Mazibuko said.

Wednesday, July 3, 2013

Madonsela receives Nkandla report

The Public Works Ministry on Tuesday confirmed that Minister Thulas Nxesi had handed over the classified Nkandla report to Public Protector Thuli Madonsela.

The ministry also confirmed that it was Nxesi who classified the report as top secret on the advice of the task team that wrote it.

The ministry’s Philip Masilio said Nxesi met with Madonsela on Tuesday morning.

“The public protector had requested the minister to provide her with the Nkandla report and the minister made the report available to her.”

But he said this did not mean the report was now declassified and it still would not be made available to the public.

On Monday, DA Parliamentary leader Lindiwe Mazibuko questioned the constitutionality of the decision to keep the document under wraps.

“Nobody has the authority to classify anything. There is no law or statute in the books that enables any minister of state to classify a tender document. No task team of government, no minister, not even the President can simply put a stamp on a document and call it classified. It is legally invalid.”

The Department of Public Works is expected to explain why the document was classified.

In 2012, Nxesi commissioned a task team from the justice and security cluster to investigate claims of irregularities in the use of public funds.

The report investigated how more than R200 million was spent on President Jacob Zuma's Nkandla home.

Government’s decision to classify the report was made in June.

Meanwhile, Zuma maintains he has done nothing wrong...

- EWN