Tuesday, June 13, 2006

Cape council kicked off Gateway project

The City of Cape Town, accused of using the N2 Gateway as a “political football”, has been stripped by national government of all responsibilities relating to the housing project.

Housing Minister Lindiwe Sisulu declared a dispute against the City on Monday and instructed Mayor Helen Zille to recuse herself and the DA-led multiparty government from future involvement in the project.

But Zille said: “There is little new in today’s announcement. Province and (Sisulu) have already taken this project away from the City of Cape Town. This happened the day before the March 1 elections when an agreement was signed with Thubelisha Homes.”

‘The City’s remaining role in the N2 Gateway is to hand over all relevant information’

This agreement placed the next phase of the project in the hands of provincial and national government.

“The City’s remaining role in the N2 Gateway is to hand over all relevant information to Thubelisha, and to provide services to the flats,” she said.

Sisulu met with housing MECs and representatives of the South African Local Government Association (SALGA) on Monday in Gordon’s Bay to discuss the progress of government’s implementation of housing projects.

Their decision to freeze the City’s participation in the inter-governmental management of the government’s flagship project was announced at a hastily convened briefing late on Monday night.

While it was impossible for most media representatives to attend the briefing, the Cape Times learned later that while project management was transferred from the City to the province and Thubelisha Homes in February, the City was still part of the M3 group comprising representatives of the three tiers of government.

‘The auditor general’s involvement is a welcome development’

The City has now been dropped from this inter-governmental oversight group, “in the context that housing is a national and provincial competency”.

The N2 Gateway project has been dogged by controversy since its launch last year.

Zille said last week that the City refused to pick up the tab of more than R200-million for overrun costs and claims by contractors against the City for payment delays.

It is still unclear how the first 705 completed units will be allocated. Building costs of the units have increased significantly since the project started, resulting in a R35-million budget overrun for the first phase.

Delegates attending the two-day meeting, which ends on Monday, reportedly welcomed Sisulu’s decision to wait until she could respond with the housing MECs to reports about the status of the pilot housing project.

The City was accused of contravening the Intergovernmental Relations Bill that regulates interaction between the three spheres of government.

Zille’s absence from a recent M3 meeting about the project was highlighted as a lack of willingness by the City to participate in formal discussions with the government and province.

The delegates supported Sisulu’s decision, announced last month, to place Auditor-General Shauket Fakie in control of financial aspects of the project.

Zille has welcomed this, saying: “The auditor general’s involvement is a welcome development. We are also committed to continuing our forensic audit into the matter.”

The City has referred one of the tenders for the management of the project’s first phase, awarded by the former ANC-led administration to Cyberia Technologies, for forensic audit.

Although Cyberia were awarded a R5m tender for project management, they were paid altogether R12m before their contract was terminated shortly before the local government election.

The question of the overruns remains unanswered, although it was suggested that the auditor-general would decide how much of this would be paid by the City.

Zille said she “welcomed the admission” by Sisulu that province and national government should “share in covering the outstanding costs of this project”. The City is still responsible for the funding and provision of bulk infrastructure for the development.

Local Government and Housing MEC Richard Dyantyi could not be reached for comment late on Monday night. Neither could Sisulu’s spokesperson, who did not return several messages.

* This article was originally published on page 1 of The Cape Times on June 13, 2006

Thursday, June 8, 2006

Western Cape can’t keep it’s house/ing in order

The Western Cape department of local government and housing in Cape Town has had its electricity and water supply cut by the city council. The department is now running on emergency power.

The City says the department won’t be reconnected until the Province pays it R700 000 owing by this department alone. The city says it’s owed a total of R3.2 billion in outstanding water and lights, and has now started a name and shame campaign to recover this debt.

The City said it followed standard protocol, gave the Department repeated notification and a 48-hour final warning. It says it cut the water and electricity supply as a last resort.

Officials dispute amounts
Lynne Brown, the Western Cape finance minister,disputes the amount owed to the Cape Town Unicity for unpaid electricity, rates and water bills. Brown says the Provincial Government owes the Cape Town Unicity R6 million, while the City says the figure is R80 million. Brown’s response follows the city’s cutting of electricity and water to the provincial department of Local Government and Housing.

The City says this department owes it R700 000. Brown says it’s unfortunate that the municipality did not deal with the Provincial Cabinet about the outstanding debt or within inter-governmental structures. SABC

Tuesday, June 6, 2006

City cannot carry Gateway costs alone

The city of Cape Town should not be expected to carry on its own the N2 Gateway’s overrun costs and contractors’ claims of close to R200-million as the project was undertaken as an “unfunded mandate at the directive” of the national department of housing, says executive mayor Helen Zille.

In a letter sent to Housing Minister Lindiwe Sisulu on Monday, Zille said she would ask senior counsel to determine “how much of ratepayers’ money the city would have to pay” for a flagship project that had exceeded its budget and gone beyond its deadline for completion.

“While we concur with the broad objectives of Breaking New Ground (the national housing policy), we note that this statement of intent has not been costed or funded and therefore cannot be implemented.”

‘The project thus far is shocking to say the least’

Zille said that, “without prejudice”, the city would support the N2 Gateway only if it was tackled in accordance with established national policies and the city’s integrated development plan.

Sisulu said that, as the minister, she did not conduct relations with other spheres of government through the media. She said she “understood that Zille was new, but by now she should have familiarised herself with government protocol”.

The matter would be referred to the MEC for Local Government and Housing, Richard Dyantyi, to “whom Ms Zille accounts”, said Sisulu.

Dyantyi said he “respected the platforms of communication that had been created” and would comment on Zille’s letter only after a meeting of the three levels of government involved in the project.

Zille said the allocation of the units was the “most complex” aspect of the development and had to be shared by the city and the province.

“I am not passing the buck, but it should not just be the city’s responsibility.”

Dyantyi was on record as having said the N2 Gateway was not the city’s responsibility, Zille said.

Seth Maqetuka, city director of human settlements, said at the weekend that only 11 families had qualified for accommodation in the first phase of 705 units.

The ambitious 22 000-unit development has been mired in controversy since its launch last year as an intergovernmental initiative involving the city, province and national department of housing.

Responsibility for the project management of the development was transferred from the city to the province in February, shortly before the March 1 elections.

DA councillor Neil Ross, of the housing portfolio committee, told the council last week that overrun costs of more than R35-million would have to picked up by the city.

Zille said there were indications that each unit would cost R160 000, double the R80 000 initially estimated.

Ross said claims by contractors who had not been paid could cost the city a further R160-million.

Sisulu announced in her housing budget speech that the project would be finished within three years, but Ross said Thubelisha Homes estimated that it would take at least six years to complete.

Zille’s letter said: “What has emerged about the project thus far is shocking to say the least.

“The city was required to implement this unfunded mandate at the directive of your administration and the city now faces huge claims from various companies involved in the undertaking. This we cannot accept.”

She said many contractors had worked without contracts, allowing them to charge up to three times more for building structures.

Zille referred to the forensic audit of the Cyberia contract which was tendered at R5-million but eventually cost the city a total of R12-million.

Zille said the city could not be solely responsible for any part of a project that was pushed through by national government “without a proper policy framework”.

“Before we embark on any further aspect of this project, it is absolutely essential to establish the project’s protocols,” she said.

Funding and policy needed to be established by the national housing department so that province and the city could apply these guidelines.

ANC provincial secretary Mcebisi Skwatsha said there should have been better communication with the constituencies to warn them that houses would be available for specific groups of people.

Backyard dweller organisations have already warned that there could be chaos over allocation.

o This article was originally published on page 1 of Cape Times on June 06, 2006

Monday, June 5, 2006

705 N2 units ready, Only 11 families told

The first 705 units of the N2 Gateway project may be ready for occupation, but only 11 families have apparently been told by the City that they qualify to move in.

Seth Maqetuka, the City’s human settlement director, said that of the 200 candidates who had applied for accommodation, only 11 families would be able to afford the R300 to R500 monthly rental.

When contacted on Sunday for confirmation, Maqetuka said: “Yes, those are the facts.”

‘We must remember that everything on the N2 Gateway is a pilot project’

But ANC councillor Xolile Gophe said this figure of 11 families sounded “ridiculous”.

Gophe said the City had already sent out 200 letters to candidates drawn from various housing lists and that 150 had responded.


“We must remember that everything on the N2 Gateway is a pilot project and things are bound to change.”

He said the allocation split of 70 percent for shack dwellers and 30 percent for backyarders “was not set in stone”.

Backyard dweller organisations warned last week that there would be potential chaos when people did eventually move into the units.

They had appealed for a 50/50 allocation split that would give more backyarders an opportunity to qualify for housing.

Gophe said government stakeholders would meet today about the allocation policy.

“This is the first time we will know about the allocation. We have not yet received the report (that refers to the 11 families who qualified).”

Local government and housing MEC Richard Dyantyi confirmed that a consultative allocation process was taking place in the form of workshops.

“We are also acknowledging the fact that the process is not as fast as we would like it to be. We might not be talking numbers for now, as we still have the majority of families to be taken through the process, but we are committed to speeding up the process in the next two weeks so that we can come to the final stages of allocation.”

Dyantyi said a consortium of independent auditors was working on the City’s housing list.

Gophe said it was a “given” that not everyone on the waiting lists would be able to move into the settlement.

“In Joe Slovo there are more than 6 000 families. The 705 units are just a drop in the ocean and not everyone will benefit.”

An estimated 250 000 families are currently affected by the housing backlog.

The national housing department announced last week that the second phase of the development, which has already started, will be run entirely by Thubelisha Homes.

Existing Joe Slovo residents will be relocated to 1 400 temporary units at Delft during the construction of the next set of units.

o This article was originally published on page 4 of Cape Times on June 05, 2006


Friday, June 2, 2006

N2 Gateway claims threatens housing project

Contractors have threatened to bring claims amounting to more than R100-million against the city for mismanagement of the N2 Gateway housing project, says Democratic Alliance councillor Neil Ross.

“And the R35-million overrun in building the top structures are costs that council will also have to pick up.”

These revelations emerged during Thursday’s heated debate in full council about a recommendation to slash the N2 Gateway’s capital budget from R317-million to R86-million.

The city could still be liable for claims and overrun costs

While the management of the N2 Gateway was transferred from the city to the province and Thubelisha Homes in February, the city is still responsible for the funding and monitoring of bulk infrastructure.

Ross said that while this transfer was done shortly before the March 1 local government elections, the city could still be liable for claims and overrun costs of more than R35-million.

“We were given R80 000 per unit for the top structures, but they cost between R125 000 and R140 000. Who is responsible for this?” Tozama Bevu of the African National Congress (ANC) said the project was handed to the province “because they were the best to run it”.

Housing Minister Lindiwe Sisulu said in parliament last week that 22 000 houses would be built within the next three years. Housing MEC Richard Dyantyi said earlier that construction of the next phases was already under way.

But Ross said Thubelisha Homes indicated at a recent presentation that the N2 Gateway project would take at least six years to complete.

National government wanted to change the facade of the N2

“It should have been done by December 2006, but only 10 percent has been completed,” said Ross.

Ross said tender irregularities for the N2 Gateway project had cost the city more than R12-million. “Cyberia Technologies tendered for R5-million but were paid R12-million. Where did the extra R7-million come from?”

Vincent Bergh of the African Christian Democratic Party accused the ANC of shrouding the N2 Gateway project in secrecy.

“The real reason for the N2 is because national government wanted to change the facade of the N2 between Cape Town and the airport before 2010.”

He said the ANC ignored the City’s “competent in-house staff” and opted instead to appoint consultants.

But Bevu said the former ANC administration terminated Cyberia’s contract.

“It is nonsense that the N2 was done in secret.”

She said the N2 Gateway was proof the ANC was delivering. Ross said the allocation of units, “promised to every one and his wife”, had created unrealistic expectations that were compounded by the “political meddling of the former executive mayor (Nomaindia Mfeketo)”.

Dan Plato, mayoral committee member for housing, said: “There have been lots of problems with the funding of the N2 and lots of mistakes have been made.”

He said he would meet today with stakeholders for a status report on the project.

“The multi-party government is not happy with this project. It has cost the City at this point millions of rands already.”

Xolile Gophe of the ANC rebutted these allegations, saying: “There is no problem whatsoever as far as the N2 Gateway is concerned.”

“We must learn from the N2 that we can build houses in a year,” said Bevu.

* This article was originally published on page 3 of The Cape Times on June 02, 2006


Thursday, June 1, 2006

Backyarders warn of ‘chaos’ in Cape

As D-day for the occupation of homes in the N2 Gateway Project nears, backyard dweller organisations from Gugulethu and other areas are raising concerns about the allocation criteria, and are warning of potential “chaos” when people start moving in.

Mncedisi Twalo, head of the Gugulethu Backyarder’s Association said the backyarders from Nyanga, Philippi and Langa had met with Cape Town mayor Helen Zille, director for human settlements Seth Maqethuka, mayoral committee member for housing Dan Plato and city housing official Basil Davidson on Monday.

“We demanded an explanation about the allocation,” said Twalo.

“Province is in charge, but our questions are related to the criteria.

‘The backlog increases because of the influx of people and young people are also growing up’

They are talking about giving the houses to people earning R3 000. People being interviewed don’t qualify because they earn less than R3 000.

“And this 70 percent shack dwellers and 30 percent backyarders criteria, where does it come from? It’s painful for backyarders.

“We’re not happy, we want 50-50. The people being given 70 percent only arrived in Cape Town now and we have been living in backyards for years.

“Now we have to tell this news to the masses. It’s going to be chaos,” said Twalo.

He said the housing backlog was being politicised.

“There is also Zille’s pilot project for backyarders in Grassy Park. When they invaded land they were removed, but within 72 hours they had been given back their material and a parcel of land,” he said.

“Treatment is not the same. It’s excluding us. They tell us about other projects like the Mau Mau Project, but they are not getting implemented. It’s still in the pipeline.

“Bear in mind the backlog increases because of the influx of people and young people are also growing up.”

The housing department’s response was that the allocation stays. - Cape Times

Wednesday, May 24, 2006

Cape coffers bulging as R1bn lies unspent

Against a backdrop of a transport crisis, a need for more housing and services, and greater job-creation and poverty relief efforts, it emerged at Monday’s Mayco meeting that by the end of April, city departments had spent just R928,7-million, leaving R992,1m-unspent.

Excluding the R408,6-million spending shortfall on the N2 Gateway project, the major shortfalls occur in roads and stormwater (R106-million), transport (R93.3-million), housing (R81-million), electricity (R78.3-million), water (R69.5-million) and social development (R44-million). - Cape Times

Politics not enough to tackle the challenges we face

Yesterday morning, in what we sincerely hope becomes a watershed moment for the city, premier Rasool addressed some 100 prominent business, religious, academic, media, sports, community and labour leaders.

He did so flanked by Zille and Richard Dyantyi, MEC for local government and housing, in the context of a frank admission that “political leadership may not be enough to tackle the challenges we face”. - Cape Times

Sunday, May 21, 2006

Housing project slow says Cape shack dwellers

Residents and backyard dwellers of Langa on the Cape Flats have voiced their dissatisfaction with the slow pace of the allocation of houses at the N2 Gateway housing project.

The would-be beneficiaries are part of thousands of residents of the Joe Slovo informal settlement whose shacks were destroyed by devastating fires two years ago. Initially, the victims were scheduled to move in by the beginning of this month.

Xolile Gophe, the area’s ward councillor, says the contractors will have completed the construction of phase one of the project by the end of this month. He says the developers would be moving out of the site soon, and the first batch of people should be taking occupation by the end of June. - SABC

Friday, May 19, 2006

Relief for slum dwellers after R181 million pledge

Slum dwellers received a golden handshake today when government pledged R181 million towards housing. This was announced at the start of a three-day International Slum Dwellers Conference in Cape Town. About 22 countries are discussing strategies to eradicate slums through partnerships.

Lindiwe Sisulu, the housing minister, pledged a whopping R145 million towards the non-profit organisation - “The Federation of Urban and Rural Poor”. The money will be used to build houses in five provinces, but that was not all. Another R36 million was promised to the Western Cape housing department.

Sisulu says they have five provinces that are collaborating because they have a very strong presence of global associations, and therefore have given each a thousand subsidies. A well-known international organisation attending is the NGO Slum Dwellers Initiative (SDI). They are actively working towards alleviating poverty and homelessness around the world.

Trying to change world govt mindsets
Jockin Arputham, the SDI president, says the conference it is not only a talk shop, but to do an overview of subsidies and delivery. Solutions reached here will be discussed at an international slum conference in Canada, later this year.

The objective of the three-day conference is to teach a new mindset so that world governments can help uplift poor communities, the poverty-stricken should still strive to change their own circumstances. - SABC

Housing horrors…

QUESTIONS asked by irate residents about housing in the Western Cape at a meeting last weekend, had the minister of local government and housing, Richard Dyantyi, casting around for answers.Dyantyi addressed residents from Guguletu, Nyanga and Philippi on certain matters, especially the many backyard dwellers in those areas.

From the outset he made it quite clear that the provincial government was aware of the lack of confidence because previous promises had not been met.

According to him the provincial government is doing everything in its power to relieve the shortage of housing.

“We have already referred ten projects to the special investigating unit after allegations of financial irregularities. One person has appeared in court in connection with alleged corruption and three others may follow soon.”

Dyantyi said he was aware before the meeting that residents would be upset, because many of them have been waiting for houses for years.

“The fact that they are upset is therefore understood and fair.”

In spite of expecting criticism he was still caught unawares by the strongly worded dissatisfaction of Galiema Messiah of Heinz Park.

“You will probably have noticed that those present have no respect for you. That is the result of the actions of the housing council that has treated us like rubbish.

“We see them today and then we never hear from them again. I have been hearing the same old stories for the past four years.

“Where were you last night (Saturday) when we had to run around to find buckets and dishes to keep water from flooding our leaking houses?”

Messiah said there are rumours that the contractor who had been appointed to build units in Heinz Park had disappeared with the money.

She was not the only person who was upset.

Desmond Ntlabati (36) who lives in a hostel in Guguletu, also had very little sympathy with the minister.

According to him, the hostel is not fit for human occupation. The drains are blocked and rubbish is piling up all over the place.

“Children and the elderly are becoming ill in the place. Even a frog will not live long in the water.”

At the end of the information session Dyantyi promised residents that houses and units that have not been completed, would be built and that those who qualify for a housing subsidy, would receive it. - City Vision

Govt, private sector commits to housing delivery

The Northern Cape housing department says the signing of the provincial housing social contract will commit it to effective housing delivery.

The social contract will be signed by the department, financial institutions and the construction industry in Kimberley later today.

Bronwyn Thomas, the department spokesperson, says the agreement will see stakeholders dedicating themselves to work to improve informal settlements and provide adequate shelter for the homeless.

Thomas says they are going to commit themselves by pledging in writing and by signing a contract that they are going to work towards repeatedly improving and speeding up the delivery of housing in the province. He says whilst the idea is to speed up housing delivery the emphasis will be quality delivery of houses in the province. - SABC

Wednesday, May 17, 2006

Home finance boost for ‘high risk’ group

People earning between R3 500 and R7 000 a month, long seen as a “high risk” group, will now be able to access housing finance after a “groundbreaking” agreement signed between the City of Cape Town and three major banks.

Mayor Helen Zille signed the deal with Absa, Nedbank and Standard Bank at Tafelsig, Mitchell’s Plain, making Cape Town the first city to have such an agreement in place.

The agreement stems from the commitment made by the financial sector under the Financial Services Charter last March that they would invest at least R42-billion in this market by December 2008.

‘I hope we make it work’

Zille said the agreement meant banks would be involved in all housing subsidy developments across the city and would further help eradicate the province’s housing backlog.“If we make it work in five years, I hope we do not have to have a waiting list of 200 000 people. I hope we make it work,” she said.

In terms of the agreement, potential buyers will have to pay a deposit of up to 10 percent, and the government can give these buyers a 50 percent subsidy on the deposit. Monthly payments may be up to 25 percent of income for a period of up to 20 years.

The payment methods will be structured in accordance with personal financial commitments and affordability levels.

The launch venue in Tafelsig is expected to be one of the first housing projects to benefit under the scheme.

The project is expected to develop 1 800 units in three years.

Standard Bank’s Linda Sing said research showed a 625 000 shortfall in the Financial Services Charter target of housing for between two and four million South Africans.

Nedbank regional director Anthony Costa said they were acutely aware of the shortage, particularly in the low income market. - Cape Argus

Monday, May 15, 2006

Dyantyi & housing corruption

Tensions ran high at the Gugulethu Sports Complex on Sunday when Local Government and Housing MEC Richard Dyantyi addressed a public meeting on the scale of corruption in the Peoples Housing Process (PHP).

The meeting was also attended by provincial government and City of Cape Town housing officials.

Dyantyi spoke about corruption in the PHP projects after receiving numerous complaints from beneficiaries.

He also spoke on the “burning issue” of backyard dwellers, which was a contentious topic at the meeting.

Focus its investigation on the failure of service providers

Dyantyi made a request to the Special Investigation Unit and Directorate of Special Operations (Scorpions) in April, asking it to focus its investigation on the failure of service providers to comply with contractual requirements.

He also asked the Scorpions to investigate the unlawful and unauthorised payments, made by the accounts administrator, of state subsidies in the development of low cost housing.

Addressing the packed hall, Dyantyi said the problems in the PHP projects had been identified and were being investigated.

“It is clear that the problems (of corruption) are rooted here in government. That’s where everything begins,” said Dyantyi. “The money stolen runs to hundreds of thousands, it’s your money. But if you want to direct your weapons to someone, you must direct them to me.”

He said that at meetings held in a number of communities, people had protested about the slow pace of delivery.

They are all marching for the same reason

“Everyone is marching in Khayelitsha, Nyanga and Mfuleni and they are all marching for the same reason,” he said.

“At one meeting I was told by the people that we’re doing this for ourselves …, but then government comes and messes up everything.

“People have subsidies, but when they go to inquire at the housing offices, they are told that there are no more subsidies Why? Because ‘ooclever’ (swindlers) took it.”

The department is also to investigate allegations that a former ANC ward councillor took money from Mandela Park residents in return for houses.

The man, whose name is known to the Cape Times, allegedly took the money from more than 50 people and gave them receipts.

“Another problem is the constant changing of committees. Funds go missing. Where have you ever heard of loans in subsidy money? I’m talking about your leaders who march with you when you are marching,” said Dyantyi.

Gugulethu resident Ruby Twayi asked why beneficiaries had to account to committees.

“We’re living in pain. One has to be in good terms with these committees,” said Twayi.

Another affected PHP beneficiary, Nosiphiwo Matyeba, said: “Why do we join the PHP if we have to end up buying our own building material?”

On backyarders, Dyantyi said authorities had been biased toward shack dwellers.

“We also need to understand the anger of backyard dwellers. We must be balanced and not biased,” said Dyantyi.

Mncedisi Twalo, chairperson of the Gugulethu Backyard Dwellers, said there was “no truth” in what Dyantyi said.

“Dyantyi knows that, at the end of the month, people will be moving into the N2 Gateway but there are no criteria. The relevant people (to address these issues) are Helen Zille and Basil Davidson, not these puppets.”

Responding, Dyantyi said: “There is no Zille here. I called this meeting as housing MEC. You can’t go to a Zille meeting and call for Dyantyi.” - Cape Times