The possible extension has emerged after Richard Dyantyi, Western Cape housing and local government minister, addressed hundreds of residents at a public meeting at Langa last night. Dyantyi says the allocation of residents to the double-storied flats will be done on an affordability basis. ~ SABC
InternAfrica aims to educate and ensure Africans the right to dignity and adequate housing through secure ecologically sustainable development and use of natural resources, while promoting justifiable economic and social development. Cape Human Settlement NEWS is carried on this website to aid in this education.
Friday, June 23, 2006
Allocation of Gateway units extended
The possible extension has emerged after Richard Dyantyi, Western Cape housing and local government minister, addressed hundreds of residents at a public meeting at Langa last night. Dyantyi says the allocation of residents to the double-storied flats will be done on an affordability basis. ~ SABC
Thursday, June 22, 2006
NO Development without open transparent public participation and consultation!
This has become a sideshow of note: Restraining our severe urge to comment harshly:
Gateway not supposed to follow rules - MEC
Housing and Local Government MEC Richard Dyantyi has shrugged off investigations by the DA-led City of Cape Town administration into N2 Gateway tenders, saying it was not intended that they would “follow normal bureaucracy”.
The need for houses was so urgent that the project had to be “fast-tracked”.
When the city council stopped playing “games”, the provincial and national governments’ doors would be “open for them to come back”, Dyantyi said during a debate in the National Council of Provinces.
“So what if work began before contracts were signed? This is a pilot project that we are testing in this province. So, if it happened that we put the first brick down before the contract was signed, so what?
“The houses are standing.”…
“The N2 project is not funds-driven, it is needs-driven,” Dyantyi said.
Idea: 5.2 Visionary Design: Circular Cities and Biomimicry
William McDonough, an architect and author of the landmark book Cradle to Cradle, contends that every material used in the manufacturing process should ultimately either biodegrade harmlessly or be reusable with no loss of quality.

Wednesday, June 21, 2006
N2 Gateway audit ‘to continue’
Robinson, a former city councillor, said this would happen in spite of Housing Minister Lindiwe Sisulu’s decision to kick the city - which in March voted the African National Congress out of the local government - off the project.
The project adjacent to the Joe Slovo informal settlement is not far from the city’s international airport.
Robinson said the new city government had, nevertheless, committed itself to finishing the N2 Gateway but only “as and when the national government made funds available”.
She noted that the project - expected to house 22 000 families - had cost nearly R135m more than originally intended.
As of June this year only 705 housing units were ready - 3% of the target.
The units, which were all rental units, would not be owned by their intended occupants “as they are completely unaffordable to the people most in need of homes”.
In addition the project was being built on a 50-year floodplain “adding to the city’s costs”, while contractors were still owed millions of rands. - FIN24
Lawyers warned city about N2 project firm
As the row over the controversial and costly N2 Gateway project flares again on Wednesday with renewed debate in the city and in parliament, the spotlight falls on a top-level hazard warning by lawyers more than a year ago.
It has emerged that in a confidential memorandum to Housing Minister Lindiwe Sisulu, provincial Housing MEC Richard Dyantyi and former mayor Nomaindia Mfeketo, Cape Town law firm Cheadle, Thompson & Haysom highlighted concerns about the appointment of Johannesburg firm Cyberia Technologies - an IT company - as project managers for the N2 Gateway scheme.
The lawyers’ investigation, in March 2005, was apparently commissioned by the political threesome, known as “M3″.
It is understood that the report found that while the tender adjudicators in the city rated Cyberia the least favourite of six rivals for the job, the council’s Goods and Services Property Advisory Board placed it first.
| They lost millions as a result of the bungled handling of the development |
The contract, which was eventually increased to more than R12m from R5m, was approved in a closed tender process.
More than R4m was injected into the project a month before Cyberia’s contract was terminated in January this year.
The city law firm’s memorandum concluded that while the appointment process may have been flawed, there was “no conclusive evidence of direct political interference in the process” or of “improper behaviour by the project managers”.
The memorandum does advise that “concerns about the competencies of the project managers” be dealt with.
It also highlights “possible problems in the procurement process” and the “lack of integration” between the three spheres of government involved.
It is apparent from the multimillion-rand cost overruns, and claims by developers who say they lost millions as a result of the bungled handling of the development that last year’s warnings were not heeded or acted on.
The row over the project escalated last week when Sisulu cut the city out of the project in the wake of Mayco’s pointed questioning of officials about who approved funding or issued instructions on the project.
Mayco decided it could not foot the bill for overruns or contractors’ claims until these questions were answered.
At the last Mayco meeting, councillors were told that some of the problems were “to a degree a result of poor project management and a lack of capacity in oversight on what those managers were doing at that time”.
The N2 Gateway controversy is a hot topic again today with a fresh round of debate in Mayco and also in the National Council of Provinces.
Several other housing matters account for a significant portion of Mayco’s 1 008-page agenda for its last meeting on Wednesday before the holiday recess starts.
Councillors are being asked to approve a key shift from delivering “full package” (a completed house) to “incremental” (site and service, or informal settlement upgrades) solutions, and also to find an extra R120m to push up the total delivery for the year from 8 000 to 20 000 “housing opportunities”.
A report notes “the present housing delivery approach is not denting the housing backlog significantly” and that “the demand of housing is more than the available resources” and needs accelerated delivery.
Mayco is being asked to enter into urgent discussions with the SA National Defence Force over the city’s plan to use Wingfield land to build about 4 200 houses. - Cape ArgusW Cape lags badly in low-cost housing
According to these figures, only 2 040 low-cost houses were built in the province in this period. This compares with 16 874 built in the Eastern Cape, 17 635 in the Free State, 21 603 in KwaZulu-Natal, 23 409 in Gauteng and 21 973 in Limpopo. These houses all cost just under R26 000.
However, the provision of low-cost housing in the Western Cape province has been on a downward path for some years. In 2002 a total of 19 534 houses were built. This number fell to 16 926 in 2003 and to 12 751 in 2004.
This does not seem sufficient to provide for the more than 30 000 people which Statistics South Africa reported migrate to the Western Cape every year.
In the private sector there are signs of some levelling off in new construction. In the four months ended April, local authorities approved the construction of new buildings worth R5.2 billion. This was 8.1% more than in the same period last year. However, when increases in costs are taken into account the physical volume of work is probably no more than last year.
There was a big increase in the first four months of this year in the number of small houses (less than 80m2) built. However, there was a marked falling off in the construction of new houses, flats and apartments. There was also a significant decline in cost increases and it seems possible that this and the reduced amount of business on offer could be connected.
Plans for 2 088 houses with a floor area of less than 80m2 were approved. The average cost was R67 562, which was only 1.6% above the 2005 price.
In contrast there was a distinct drop from last year in the number of houses planned with a floor area of 80m2 from 2 627 to 2 274.
But the average cost rose some 4% from R649 000 in the first four months of last year to R676 000 in the same period this year.
A little surprising was the decline in the number of flats and townhouses planned.
In the four months ended April this year only 1 603 were approved, which was sharply down from 1 941 last year. However, the 12% increase in average prices from R345 000 last year to R386 000 this year is possibly constraining developers.
But a development that should gladden the local construction industry is the big increase in the number of commercial buildings in the pipeline.
Plans for office and banking space costing R277 million were approved, which was 144% higher than last year. The amount of money to be spent on new industrial and warehousing space was also substantially higher, jumping 82% from R408m to R742m.
The strong increase in the cost of new buildings over the years has made it more effective for house owners to improve their existing houses.
This resulted in plans for additions and alterations to dwelling houses costing R1.24bn to be submitted to local authorities in the Western Cape for their approval this year.
Alterations and additions to non-residential buildings costing R444.5m were also approved. This was 16% more than last year.
The half-a-percent increase earlier this month in the interest rate is not likely to have much effect on the building industry.
The increase is seen as extremely modest and not likely to push up building costs.
Only if it is regarded as the start of a trend towards dearer money will the increase in rates begin to have an impact on building plans. - Cape Argus
Tuesday, June 20, 2006
Inspired by Rose & WUF3
If you want to meet the Cities without slums and MDG by 2020 do it yourself.
Following the SABC 3 Special Assignment on the N2 Gateway Project - Housed in Controversy. It is clear that government members are very well dressed, and unable to deliver. Thus being FEDUP is quite understandable.
Monday, June 19, 2006
Fire fumes kill dad and 2 children
“It appears the man and his wife used the metal bin found in their bedroom to make a fire to warm the house but left it burning when they went to sleep,” Superintendent Billy Jones said on Sunday.
He said relatives who went to visit the family in Nyanga on Sunday had found the children - aged seven months and four years old - dead, and their parents unconscious. The two were rushed to hospital where the man later died. - Sapa
Africans struggling to prevent child burn injuries
Arrie Odendaal winced when he walked into Sikobongeli’s shack, which doubles as a shabeen, or local drinking spot. He started to reach out for her 2-year-old daughter, Sandra , as she skipped by the open flame. “I’m worried about that fire,” said Odendaal, a researcher on injury prevention for South Africa’s Medical Research Council .
“I know,” the mother replied. “But I don’t have anything else to keep us warm.”
Odendaal was working on a project studying safety attitudes and precautions among parents in South Africa’s townships. That work is part of a growing recognition around Africa of the extraordinary number of children who suffer from serious burns inside poor people’s homes and then receive almost no help afterward.
“It’s a pretty devastating injury, and it’s for life,” said Dr. Rene Albertyn, a pain specialist at Red Cross Children’s Hospital in Cape Town, the only hospital devoted solely to children south of the Sahara.
“There’s very little support for a burnt, disfigured child in Africa. If we push out 1,000 children after treating them each year, where are those children going? The answer is that they become hidden figures in society. It’s a desperate situation for them.”
…A household survey in Mozambique found that burns were the number one cause of injuries to children…
Everywhere in the world, young children are at a greater risk than adults of being burned. Their skin is much thinner than an adult’s. Their natural curiosity attracts them to many hot sources. Toddlers tip easily. - Boston Globe
Sunday, June 18, 2006
WE TOLD YOU SO!!!
The beleaguered N2 Gateway housing project in Cape Town has been dealt a further financial blow by the discovery that 705 units comprising the projects first phase have been built on a 50-year-flood plain.
The city has had to fork out a further R10m to build a culvert to divert possible flood waters, Democratic Alliance councillor, Niel Ross, chairperson of the city’s housing committee confirmed this week.
The floodplain setback was part of a triple whammy for the R1.2bn project this week, also including: The discovery that only 11 families of a sample of 200 waiting for houses in the city could afford rentals in phase one; and the disclosure in a council debate this week that the development had incurred a R35m overrun in building costs. SHF - M&G
Housed in Controversy
The politics of the Western Cape has in recent years been marked by uncertainty and inter-party squabbling. And it’s affecting the delivery of housing.
The N2 Gateway project probably has the highest profile of all housing projects undertaken since 1994. It aims to build houses for the poor along the N2, in line with government’s objective to eliminate the informal settlements that line the highway linking the airport to the city centre. But even this praiseworthy project has been bedevilled by politics. That the City Metro under Mayor Helen Zille has been “removed” from the project by the Minister of Housing is an indication of this political sensitivity.
On the ground, there is also tension. The first phase of the five-phase project is almost finished and has 705 units. Who gets to move in has become a source of conflict in the surrounding areas. Those living in informal settlements expect to be housed there first, especially the residents of the Joe Slovo settlement, who were originally re-located to make way for the construction.
Many would argue that one of the greatest challenges in post-apartheid South Africa is to integrate the poor into the life of the cities. So far the government has only paid lip service to the idea. The segregated landscape of the past is still intact and, in fact, has been perpetuated by the new government in its hurry to house the electorate.
In this investigation Special Assignment looks into other options available to house the poor in South Africa and assesses the effects of uncertainty and political in-fighting on delivery.
SABC Special Assignment Tuesday 19/6 SABC3 21:30
Cape Town’s great housing bungle
The insights provided to the mayoral committee (Mayco) reveal the fullest picture yet of a politically driven development in which millions of rands were squandered because basic contractual procedures were abandoned in the haste to get housing on the ground.
The city is now set to call for a forensic audit of all contracts in relation to the N2 Gateway project.
The extent of the bungles came to light in a tense grilling of senior city officials by Mayco on Friday.
The public servants of Cape Town were all but powerless.
At issue was a R28-million tab the city was being asked to pick up for overruns and for multi-million rand claims by disgruntled contractors.
Mayco decided that in the absence of a thorough forensic audit, it would not accept liability.
City, provincial and national officials were fingered for their role in the saga.
In an uncharacteristic move, Mayco initially decided to close the meeting to the public because of the sensitivity of the matters under discussion. The press had to leave.
However, mayor Helen Zille, who was resting in her office because of an illness, was alerted and insisted the debate be opened. By then, most of the journalists had gone.
The N2 Gateway project was the ‘right’ kind for Cape Town.
What ensued was akin at times to a grand jury as Mayco pressed officials to provide clear answers.
What is apparent is that the public servants of Cape Town were all but powerless as they were caught up in a politically driven development agenda that took on a mad-cap quality because of the haste with which it was being implemented.
It emerged that contractors were on site, building structures at vast cost, in the absence of duly signed contracts or clear instructions on what was to be built, and before there was even a project budget.
Letters of appointment issued to contractors in the first phase of the rushed exercise, to which were attached a host of specifications, restrictions and objectives, were withdrawn halfway through the process, and new letters issued without any conditions at all.
The spotlight falls on six people - three politicians and three senior officials - who formed two committees that drove the project.
The politicians are former mayor Nomaindia Mfeketo, provincial housing MEC Richard Dyantyi and national Housing Minister Lindiwe Sisulu. The officials are acting director-general of the national Housing Department Ahmedi Vawda, provincial housing department head Shanaaz Majiet and city executive director Rushj Lehutso.
It is apparent the three officials were acting under political instructions, but it is not known what the specific instructions were, or on what authority they were given.
Mfeketo, Dyantyi and Sisulu - referred to in reports as “M3″ - may hold the key to the unanswered questions.
The city’s most senior planner, Stephen Boshoff, said the N2 Gateway project was the “right” kind for Cape Town, offering a development model the city should use on a wider scale.
And, as Mayco member Dan Plato repeatedly stated, the DA-led multi-party forum “is committed to the N2 Gateway project and to building houses for the poorest of the poor”.
However the focus of Mayco’s questions on Friday was the costly departures from standard approvals processes.
The questioning began with Mayco member for finance Ian Neilson wanting to “understand how this project unfolded”, and to know who was responsible for setting standards, approving designs and issuing orders.
It fell to senior officials - director of human settlements Seth Maquetuka, city project co-ordinator for the N2 Gateway Peter Oscroft and manager of finance: housing Wayne Muller - to try to give clarity on these matters.
Among the revelations were that:
- There was “such haste” with the project that the design work and the initial construction work were effectively “parallel processes”, Oscroft said. This led to some of the cost overruns because it was found that the ground was poor and additional foundation construction was needed. Further cost overruns arose because greening and landscaping of the sites were not part of the initial calculations.
- “Pricing was not determined before work was started,” said Oscroft. “We were a long way down the track with Joe Slovo phase one before the final prices were assembled. To a degree, this was as a result of poor project management by consultants and a lack of capacity in oversight on what those managers were doing at that time.”
- Initial letters of appointment to contractors on April 18 last year, which “set strict terms of compliance” with the Municipal Financial Management Act and with subsidy and grant funding requirements, were withdrawn on instruction from Ikhwezi, and were replaced, according to a city report, by “revised letters with the original restrictive conditions removed”.Oscroft told Mayco: “I cannot answer who instructed Ikhwezi, but the project managers, Cyberia, were given the instruction to withdraw the original letters and substitute them with letters of appointment which had less strenuous requirements.”
- Maquetuka told Mayco that the fact that this was a pilot project was the key context.He said: “The steering committee was given a mandate (by the politicians) to drive the process. A project management unit was appointed to deal with the day-to-day management. Most of the decisions flowed in that fashion.”On the question of a political mandate, Maquetuka said: “In terms of mandates, from a policy point of view, the highest decision-making body was M3 (Mfeketo, Dyantyi and Sisulu). That’s where the authority came from.”
Neilson wrapped up the meeting by saying: “From what we have heard - and it seems fuzzy as to who made what decisions to do what - I am not in a position to know to what extent the city is liable to pay the R28m cost overrun.
“It is not clear if it was the city, the province or the national government that made decisions which led to the overrun. Until we know that, we cannot make that decision.
“And clearly, the whole process was not a way to proceed in getting houses built. We cannot replicate this process in the city again. And calling it a pilot project is not an excuse not to do the job properly.
He said a thorough forensic investigation was needed. - Cape Argus
Friday, June 16, 2006
The June 16 Generation - It Can
June 16 1976
* SA Student uprising - the begining of the end of apartheid
* The first Habitat Conference held in Vancouver - the begining of the end of slums
As the World Urban Forum3 Opens tonight - we step forward into the next 30 years.
Why do we still have these habitat problems? To build a home is a physical thing, far more achievable than a new political dispensation. We have accomplished that. We CAN resolve our habitat crisis.
Farm workers evicted for tourists
Farmers are planning to convert workers’ tied housing into tourist and student accommodation to generate extra income.
Western Cape premier Ebrahim Rasool last week called farm evictions the new “silent epidemic” in the Western Cape. “It has pushed the housing backlog to the rural towns,” he said. - M&G