Friday, July 5, 2013

Nkandla: Number One emerges a clear winner

Jacob Zuma's share of the 'security-related' costs has been whittled down steadily – at the state's expense.

President Jacob Zuma's contribution to the Nkandla bonanza was massaged downwards and he is now expected to pay for just 5% of the security-related improvements at his private residence.

A top-secret March 2011 memo split the bill by allocating ­R203-million to the public purse and R10.5-million for Zuma.

The document frets that "it may be necessary for these issues to be discussed with the principal [Zuma] as the financial implication directly affects him".

A "preliminary cost estimate" that was not included in the Nkandla files obtained by amaBhungane but was leaked to the media last year indicates that at one stage Zuma's "private" costs stood at R22.5-million.

The "apportionment of costs" was a touchy subject throughout the Nkandla upgrade project and many documents appear to have been omitted from the files obtained by amaBhungane.

The department allocated non-security related expenses – such as sewerage installations, a cattle ­culvert, a rubbish compaction unit and two-thirds of the landscaping – to the state.


Justification
A security contractor also motivated that costs such as air conditioning in areas that "preclude the opening of windows", elevators and fire-fighting equipment were security-related, and, therefore, not Zuma's problem.

A decision was later taken by the department to find millions more for air conditioning even in "low … security areas" and to fund the entire landscaping budget.

The landscaping contractor had quoted R14.3-million for the work, which included R840 000 for a "level terrace created for a function marquee".

The justification offered was that "functions are normally for heads of state and managed by DPW [department of public works]".

Presidential spokesperson Mac Maharaj failed to respond to ­questions about whether any such functions have been held at Nkandla and whether Zuma has made any contribution to the costs at all.

The contractor quoted a further R1-million for a new livestock kraal.

Variation order 
"This kraal is of a higher quality than what was previously on site; however, the new kraal brings the project [into] line with prestige projects [the department of public work's categorisation of the Nkandla project]," the contractor said.

Also included in the landscaping was a tree nursery.

A quantity surveyor, who watched his cost estimates go up in smoke, wrote: "Given the nature of the project, I honestly don't think that spending this amount of money on landscaping is justifiable but, having said that, the decision still rests with the client."

In the months that followed, the question of how to split the bill went all the way "to top management", was "revised several times" and a committee was appointed "to make the final decision on this matter".

Their decision? A further ­R3.84-million to be added to the taxpayer's already astronomical financial commitment.

The official who approved the variation order (an appeal for money after unexpected costs overrun planned costs) scribbled underneath that "funds should be spent strictly on security measures at the private residence of the principal".

But the horse had already bolted, out the kraal, via the nursery, and away through the verdant rolling landscaping.

- M&G

Long battle to get hold of redacted Nkandla documents

The release of over 12 000 pages of documents marks a victory in the long battle between amaBhungane and the department of public works.

This has been a battle for access to information on its Nkandla-related expenditure.

In July 2012, amaBhungane requested information under the Promotion of Access to Information Act regarding public expenditure on upgrades to President Jacob Zuma’s private residence in Nkandla, KwaZulu-Natal.

The request highlighted ­amaBhungane’s interest exclusively in information that was not ­security sensitive. The request pointed out that the Act obliged the department to redact parts of the requested information that was related to security, while ­making the rest available.

In its initial response, the department rejected the request on the basis of apartheid-era legislation, including the National Key Points Act, the Protection of Information Act and a Cabinet policy called Minimum Information Security Standards.

No mention was made of any grounds for refusal under the Promotion of Access to Information Act itself.

An internal appeal against this decision was ignored by the department, forcing amaBhungane to launch a legal application to compel the department to release the information.

Irregularities in expenditure
In its replying affidavit, the department claimed that all documents requested were so replete with security-sensitive information that it would be impossible to comply with the request without revealing any of it. AmaBhungane rejected this claim.


Together with expert testimony, amaBhungane submitted various documents marked “top secret” that had been leaked to the press revealing irregularities in expenditure, with no reference at all to security-sensitive details. On this basis, amaBhungane argued that it was simply impossible that all of the documents sought could not be released, at least in redacted form, without endangering the security of the president.

The department subsequently capitulated. In a supplementary affidavit received on June 13, it acknowledged that it was possible to sever security-sensitive information from requested documents.

The department released 42 files – over 12 000 pages – relating to bid evaluations, needs assessments, contracts awarded and their values, as well as documents indicating whether costs were allocated for public or private accounts.

The documents released to amaBhungane can be assumed to form the basis of the task team report commissioned by Public Works Minister Thulas Nxesi.

This report has subsequently been declared top secret and thus closed to public scrutiny.

The files also make numerous references to documents, pages or annexures that have not been disclosed. For many of these, there appears to be no security-related basis for their redaction.

AmaBhungane has until the end of July to decide whether to continue with its court challenge to secure the outstanding material. AmaBhungane has been represented by Webber Wentzel’s media law team and advocates Nasreen Rajab-Budlender and Wim Trengove SC. – Vinayak Bhardwaj is the advocacy co-ordinator for amaBhungane - M&G

Nkandla: An orgy of kowtowing

Documents obtained by amaBhungane on Nkandla show how costs ballooned tenfold as officials scrambled to please President Jacob Zuma.

Documents obtained by amaBhungane lay bare how Jacob Zuma's accession to the presidency set off an orgy of official grovelling that allowed the security upgrade at his private Nkandla homestead to balloon from a modest R27.8-million plan in 2009 to a projected total of about R270-million in October 2012.

The official expenditure as of June 2013 is R210 505 255 – but this does not appear to include bills still to be paid, including maintenance.

About 12 000 pages of public works department  documents relating to Nkandla, known internally as Project A, were released to amaBhungane two weeks ago. They were disclosed in response to an access to information request launched a year ago under the Promotion of Access to Information Act, apparently in a bid to head off a court hearing on the department's initial refusal of the request. (See "Long battle to get hold of redacted documents".)

The documents represent the best approximation so far of the evidence available to the special public works task team appointed by Public Works Minister Thulas Nxesi last year to investigate the scandal.

The disclosures in the documents appear to make a mockery of the government's attempt to keep its own investigation under wraps by classifying the team's report top secret and referring it for discussion behind closed doors by the joint standing committee on intelligence.

In a letter to the National Assembly speaker, Max Sisulu, last month, Nxesi said the report on the Nkandla security upgrades had been classified top secret in terms of the minimum information security standards, making it exempt from disclosure.

The documents released by the department include a number that are marked "top secret", but the classification appears to be designed more to protect the government and the president from embarrassment than to ensure security.

They include a remarkable March 2012 secret letter from Durban regional manager Kenneth Khanyile to his public works department bosses in Pretoria in which he calls for special tendering and auditing procedures for so-called "prestige projects", which would shield them from public knowledge. This was not only for security reasons, but also "because these projects are further targeted by journalists in an attempt to discredit the government in general".

The documents also include fairly detailed, but unexceptional, information about the security measures at the Nkandla compound, despite amaBhungane excluding this data in the terms of its request.

In short, there is nothing in the Nkandla files that could not have been publicly disclosed, except that they paint an unedifying picture of how senior officials and politicians:
  • Scrambled to meet deadlines set by Zuma, taking short cuts on tendering processes;
  • Shifted money from other programmes to accommodate the unbudgeted spending;
  • Implemented the Nkandla project with few proper cost controls and no allocated budget or limit on spending;
  • Were mainly concerned with delivering to Zuma (referred to as "the principal") at a speed and level of quality befitting a "prestige project";
  • Were reluctant to allocate costs to Zuma, including for the building of a new cattle kraal, a plant nursery, a road network and other improvements that will benefit Zuma's family long after he ceases to be president  and
  • Paid out an underperforming contractor at least partly because threatened court action could cause "political fallout that could possibly influence the principal's political position very negatively".
Although the documents provide evidence that in some cases the contracts were poorly managed, there is not a great deal to support the allegations of "overcharging" apparently raised in the task team report.

But there are significant gaps – notably in relation to communication with directors general, ministers and deputy ministers and, crucially, Zuma – though the documents provide intriguing pointers that cast doubt on the president's attempts to distance himself from the project and suggest that he played an important role in how the process unfolded.

A definitive answer to this question will probably depend on the disclosure of more high-level, sensitive documentation. To this end, ama-Bhungane is likely to proceed to court as scheduled on November 5.

- M&G

What did Zuma know about the Nkandla project?

Despite gaps, files suggest that President Jacob Zuma made an input on Nkandla project decisions.

Despite gaps, files suggest that President Jacob Zuma made an input on Nkandla project decisions.
 
In a rowdy debate in the National Assembly on November 15, President Jacob Zuma distanced himself from the process that resulted in the state spending huge amounts on upgrading security at his Nkandla home.

Expressing anger at being portrayed as corrupt for security expenses foisted on him by the state, Zuma said: "There are two different things: my homes that are built by me and my family, and the security features that the government wanted ... to satisfy their own requirements … These are matters that the government ... don't ask me, don't ask me."

But documents obtained by amaBhungane cast some doubt on the president's reply – though there are significant gaps in the material released. What is there suggests Zuma – referred to as "the Principal" – played an important role in how the process unfolded and had an input in some of the decisions:

  • An October 2009 letter from police divisional commissioner for supply chain management states: "By instruction of ... President Zuma, the existing house at Nkandla, currently accommodate [sic] SAPS members must be converted as part of the president's household."
  • It appears Zuma was key to setting deadlines – and it was at least partially this urgency that led officials to adopt "emergency" procurement procedures. For instance, in one memo the public works project manager, Jean Rindel, states: "Minister [Geoff] Doidge and [deputy director general Rachaad] Samuels … instructed this office to continue with immediate effect, as he was given a deadline by the principal to have the site operational by December 1 2010."
  • A June 3 2011 memo asking for permission not to go out on tender for electronic security features notes: "The project must be completed by October 30 2011 as per instruction from the principal. A negotiated procurement process would be faster."
  • The project was divided into two phases, with phase one including "emergency" work to ensure the basic security of the site. When contemplating phase two, officials were again influenced to abandon more open tender procedures and negotiate with the same contractors who had been appointed for phase one.
  • A memo dated January 10 2010 states: "A meeting was held with [then public works] deputy minister [Hendrietta] Bogopane-Zulu ... on December 21 2010 in which she confirmed that the principal indicated that he does not want other contractors on site in phase two."
  • It appears there was some detailed consultation with Zuma. Minutes of an emergency progress meeting on November 30 2010 state: "Bogopane-Zulu said she had a discussion with the principal on the relocation (of families). [She] mentioned she will conclude with the principal on the close off (fencing) of the relocation and report at the next meeting."
  • At a progress meeting on June22 2011 in was agreed that "[Minenhle] Makhanya (the architect) would meet with the principal and present the fire pool".
A high-level document dated March 18 2011 relating to the allocation of costs between the state and the president noted: "It may be necessary for these issues to be discussed with the principal as the financial implication directly affects him."

Records of these discussions with "the principal" are not included in the documents released by public works.

Zuma's spokesperson, Mac Maharaj, did not respond to questions about the president's involvement in the process.

- M&G

Thursday, July 4, 2013

Report on Nkandla ‘will not be leaked’

THE wrangle around the Department of Public Works task team report on the R200m upgrade of President Jacob Zuma’s Nkandla property has taken another turn, with Public Protector Thuli Madonsela promising that the report will not be leaked from her office.

This follows Public Works Minister Thulas Nxesi handing over the report to her.

There has also been increased confusion over which minister classified the report top secret and under which law. Mr Nxesi has said State Security Minister Siyabonga Cwele classified the report, but he has denied this.

Yesterday, Ms Madonsela confirmed being in possession of the report. She gave the assurance that it would not be leaked from her office and that it would be handled in such a way as not to compromise the security of the president. Ms Madonsela reportedly said that elements of the report were helping her investigation into the spending of taxpayers’ money on Nkandla.

Earlier this week, Mr Cwele moved to distance himself from the classification of the report as top secret.

"The ministry has noted with concern various media reports relating to the classification of the Inkandla upgrade task team report and the role of the minister of state security. The report in question emanates from the work done by a JCPS (Justice, Crime Prevention and Security) task team appointed by the minister of public works.… We wish to indicate that it is factually incorrect that the Minister of State Security, Dr Siyabonga Cwele, has ‘classified the report top secret’ or issued an instruction to this effect, as claimed in some media reports.

"In terms of the prevailing classification regime, the author of the report is the one who classifies it. As the report is authored by the task team and owned by the commissioning minister of public works, the minister of state security cannot classify or declassify it or issue instructions to this effect."

Mr Nxesi had said in his letter to National Assembly speaker Max Sisulu that he was sending the report to Parliament on behalf of the state security minister and asking for it to be dealt with behind closed doors in the joint standing committee on intelligence.

Democratic Alliance (DA) parliamentary leader Lindiwe Mazibuko welcomed the fact that the report had been made available to Ms Madonsela.

"The DA has been calling for this report to be handed over to the public protector, the auditor-general and to be presented to the appropriate open public works portfolio committee in Parliament. We have maintained that the ‘classification’ of this report is invalid because neither the Minimum Information Security Standards (MISS) Cabinet policy nor the Protection of Information Act of 1982, which have been used, allow for classification of the report in law.

"The fact that the Minister of Public Works, Thulas Nxesi, has now handed this report to the public protector further proves that the report was never classified. Had it been, Adv Thuli Madonsela would have needed security clearance to even look at the report."

She said she would write to Mr Nxesi to determine whether Ms Madonsela had an appropriate security clearance and if so how it had been gained.

"I will also write to the public protector to seek clarity on whether her report will be made public. It will prove futile if the public protector is unable to make her report public because of the limitations provided under an invalid classification.

"We cannot allow for this abuse of public money to build President Zuma a palace in Nkandla to be swept under the carpet, nor can we can we allow for investigations by important public institutions to be withheld from the public. This report needs to be tabled in Parliament so that it may be scrutinised effectively," Ms Mazibuko said.

SAHRC highlights sanitation woes

Cape Town - A teenage girl in a wheelchair is one of more than 2 000 people who share the five taps and 11 flush toilets that are available in the YAB informal settlement in Khayelitsha.

To relieve herself, she must wheel across a busy road to reach one of the communal toilets. Once there, she has to roll out of her wheelchair and crawl along the floor to get inside the toilet cubicle, which is not large enough to accommodate her chair.

This was a “complete infringement of her right to dignity”, said South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) deputy chairwoman Pregs Govender, who is doing a three-day inspection in the Western Cape where communities have lodged complaints about their living conditions. “There are the same rights, protected in the constitution, for everybody regardless of whether you are black or white, able or disabled, male or female.”

Govender said socio-economic issues such as sanitation, water, education and housing were about human rights, not politics.

“It’s a countrywide concern. (We say) government, whoever you are, the poorer people don’t care. They just want to see that you are doing your job.”

To support the government’s efforts to improve its services, the SAHRC was talking to relevant departments about the problems it encountered and possible solutions. But Govender said there was often a discrepancy between what government officials reported and what the commissioners saw during their site inspections.

Bulelwa Baleni, a member of the YAB residents’ committee who had complained to the SAHRC, said that there were not enough taps for the 261 households that lived along Pama Road. Also, many of the taps were not working.

There was no lighting, which made the toilets unsafe to visit at night. Baleni said many families opted to use buckets in their shacks after dark, rather than risk being attacked during a visit to the outside toilet.

She also pointed out that the shacks were so close together that there was no access for emergency vehicles or police. Being so close to a busy road, with no protective wall or barrier, also meant there was a risk residents, such as the teenage girl in the wheelchair, may be hit by speeding cars.

SAHRC provincial manager Melanie Dugmore said the commission, and the government, could not deal with sanitation as an isolated issue. In this part of Khayelitsha, access to sanitation was linked to housing, crime and other socio-economic factors.

In other communities, such as Europe and Barcelona, residents were unhappy with the types of toilets they were forced to use. “This is a very complex issue, and we need to involve all spheres of government.”

The SAHRC is visiting problem areas around the country, after hearings last year found huge problems, particularly with sanitation and water.

R5m earmarked for N2 safety fence

Cape Town - A multimillion-rand fence separating the N2 freeway from informal settlements will be up by the end of the year - but Gugulethu residents say it’s a waste and won’t deter people from crossing the road.

The residents have dismissed the project and want the government to build more footbridges to cross the road safely.

The provincial government is set to erect a mesh wire fence lining the N2 on the Nyanga side from Robert Sobukwe to Baden Powell drives.

A resident, Isaac Mdlatwa, 35, said the new fence won’t make a difference because criminals will cut it open to get to the N2.

“A wire fence will be easier for criminals to get through. We have a concrete fence and you literally have to break it to make a gap. It’s pointless taking the concrete out and putting in wire,” Mdlatwa said.

He said the government should build additional bridges for residents located far from the existing bridge.

“We need more bridges in Europe (informal settlement). There is only one bridge in Barcelona and people that live there (Europe) have to walk far to cross the road safely,” he said.

Another resident, Simphiwe Ngwenduna, said the fence is a waste of money that could have been used to improve basic services.

“The only people that cross the N2 are criminals. The rest of us use the bridge because it is safe. I don’t think there is much that can be done because the criminals will find a way to get to the N2,” he said.

Spokesman for the provincial Department of Transport and Public Works Siphesihle Dube said R5-million has been set aside for the project and tenders will be invited in August. “The primary purpose of the fence along the N2 is to create a more attractive appearance and to keep pedestrians off the freeway. If we are able to keep pedestrians off the freeway we should also be able to keep protesters from blocking the N2,” Dube said.

He said the first phase of the fencing project will be 3.4km long and it will start from Borcherds Quarry.

Mayco member for safety and security JP Smith said the project is part of the city and province’s strategy to “secure the N2”.

“Our statistics indicate that 20 pedestrians have been killed on the N2 between Khayelitsha and Gugulethu during last year. This cannot continue,” Smith said.

Smith said the new fencing is more durable than the existing “easy-to-destroy concrete”.

“The fence has the highest security rating, it is much easier to repair when damaged and it is far more attractive,” he said.

Asked about protest on the N2, Smith said they have plans to buy a new water cannon for crowd control, and a specially customised vehicle that can quickly remove debris or any other substances.

“We’re anticipating that in the run-up to the elections protests in the city will escalate,” Smith said. 

District Six family offered Blikkiesdorp home

Cape Town - The city has told the remaining family living illegally in a District Six apartment complex that they will be provided with a new home in Blikkiesdorp “on humanitarian grounds”.

This follows a ruling, made by Western Cape High Court Judge Robert Henney on June 20, that the city must help find the family of Galeema Stoffels, 70, accommodation because she has grandchildren with her.

Stoffels was part of the Khoi group that on June 15 occupied 11 units in a housing development meant for Group Areas Act returnees, but their action was condemned by the Khoi-san Council, officially recognised by the government.

She is living in one of the units with her daughter Isa Isaacs, who is in her 40s, and Isaacs’s two children, aged 9 and 11.

The rest of the 40-strong group was evicted on June 21.

On June 20, Judge Henney said Stoffels and her family could not be evicted like other group members, and the city should find alternate accommodation for the family.

The trust that manages the apartment complex said “legitimate” claimants had been waiting to move into the units, when they were occupied.

On Monday, Stoffels received a legal letter from the city, informing her that she could move into a “unit” in Delft Symphony Temporary Relocation Area, commonly called Blikkiesdorp on “humanitarian grounds”.

“The city does not believe that it is obliged to provide you with formal housing outside of its normal housing policy and allocations ahead of those lawfully awaiting same,” read the letter.

“(The city) is also not obliged to provide you with emergency accommodation in view of the fact that you broke into the unit at District Six which you occupy. If, however, you and your family are to be genuinely rendered homeless should you be evicted, our client is prepared, on humanitarian grounds, to offer you a unit at (Blikkiesdorp).”

The unit in Blikkiesdorp will be on its own plot, have access to electricity and share flush toilets and water with four other families.

Stoffels said she would refuse to be “relocated” to Blikkiesdorp, but might consider moving elsewhere.

Tania Kleinhans, a spokeswoman for the group that occupied the units, said they were unhappy with the city’s offer.

“(The family of Galeema Stoffels) are aborigines who are being removed from the place of their birth,” she said.

She said the group’s occupation of units in the complex three weeks ago was not about housing, but about bringing attention to the rights of aborigines who should be allowed to live on “ancestral Khoi land”.

Stoffels has been given until Tuesday to accept the offer. This is the date the court will decide if its earlier interim eviction against the group should be finalised.

Wednesday, July 3, 2013

‘Communities need more than houses’

Cape Town - Communities need to hold all levels of government accountable, irrespective of which party is in power, to ensure that they have basic services, says Pregs Govender, deputy chairwoman of the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC).

“And saying there are different competencies (local, provincial and national) does not absolve them of co-operative governance,” she said.

The SAHRC recently came under fire from Cape Town mayor Patricia de Lille, who was outraged that it was conducting site inspections in the informal settlements of Kanna, Barcelona and Europe without informing the city. In a letter to the commission, De Lille also had strong words for its spokesman, Isaac Mangena, whom she accused of acting for the ANC Youth League.

Govender was speaking during a visit to Blikkiesdorp, near Delft, where residents discussed their concerns about sanitation, water, housing and other issues with the commission.

She will also visit Khayelitsha and the farming community of Ashton this week, as part of the Western Cape leg of the SAHRC’s national inspection of basic services. “Whether it’s the ANC or the DA, national or provincial government, people are saying that government must fix (the problems). Government needs to come together.”

Referring to De Lille’s comments, Govender said “disparaging” remarks about the commission undermined its independence and impartiality. “The constitution explicitly protected Chapter Nine institutions, such as the SAHRC, from state interference.”

Mina Perry, 71, who was moved to Blikkiesdorp six years ago, told Govender conditions were unbearable. “I hate this place. Every night I ask God for his blood to wash over me and my house, so I can find a way out of here.”

Perry said crime was rampant. “We hear the men and women screaming (when they are robbed).”

Govender said the government needed to do more than just provide houses in informal settlements. It needed to encourage social cohesion, so that communities who were forced to live together could do so in peace.

“There is a lack of co-ordination between all levels and spheres of government. We need to explain to government how to respond,” she said.

Madonsela receives Nkandla report

The Public Works Ministry on Tuesday confirmed that Minister Thulas Nxesi had handed over the classified Nkandla report to Public Protector Thuli Madonsela.

The ministry also confirmed that it was Nxesi who classified the report as top secret on the advice of the task team that wrote it.

The ministry’s Philip Masilio said Nxesi met with Madonsela on Tuesday morning.

“The public protector had requested the minister to provide her with the Nkandla report and the minister made the report available to her.”

But he said this did not mean the report was now declassified and it still would not be made available to the public.

On Monday, DA Parliamentary leader Lindiwe Mazibuko questioned the constitutionality of the decision to keep the document under wraps.

“Nobody has the authority to classify anything. There is no law or statute in the books that enables any minister of state to classify a tender document. No task team of government, no minister, not even the President can simply put a stamp on a document and call it classified. It is legally invalid.”

The Department of Public Works is expected to explain why the document was classified.

In 2012, Nxesi commissioned a task team from the justice and security cluster to investigate claims of irregularities in the use of public funds.

The report investigated how more than R200 million was spent on President Jacob Zuma's Nkandla home.

Government’s decision to classify the report was made in June.

Meanwhile, Zuma maintains he has done nothing wrong...

- EWN

Nxesi and Cwele take us for fools on Nkandla report

THE news this week may be dominated in parts by the Democratic Alliance’s fight to get the Department of Public Works task team report into the R206m upgrade of President Jacob Zuma’s homestead in Nkandla unclassified and tabled before Parliament for debate.

According to the opposition, the name of State Security Minister Siyabonga Cwele was used to justify its referral to the closed joint standing committee on intelligence.

This follows a parliamentary reply by Public Works Minister Thulas Nxesi, in which he said the report had been classified according to the Minimum Information Security Standards policy and the Protection of Information Act of 1982.

Given that neither the Cabinet policy nor the act provide for the classification of the document in law, critics have dismissed the action as unlawful and a naked attempt to shield Zuma from scrutiny.

Cwele himself has rushed to clear his name. His spokesman Brian Dube said: "It is factually incorrect that the Minister of State Security, Dr Siyabonga Cwele, has ‘classified the report top secret’ or has issued an instruction to this effect, as claimed in some media reports."

The document could only be classified by its author, he said.

In this case, the document was written by a task team of justice and security officials who were commissioned by the Department of Public Works to investigate claims that public funds were wrongfully used in the upgrade of the president’s home. The state security ministry points to this team as the authors of the document and thus distances itself from the decision to classify it.

According to Dube, the Cabinet security cluster had intended for the report to be handed to parliament — presumably to be discussed in some open forum.

Parliamentary notes show that a letter was submitted to the speaker of Parliament on June 19 by Nxesi. It said that Nxesi "will submit, on behalf of the minister for state security, the task team report on the security upgrades at the private residence of the president of the republic at Nkandla to the chairperson of the joint standing committee on intelligence", and that the report was classified "top secret" and had not been made available to the Public Protector and Auditor-General to assist them in their investigations.

It is now apparently up to Nxesi to explain what is going on. In truth, however, there is hardly anything for him to explain. We can see that we are being taken for fools. The DA may not intend for the issue to become the protocol for classification, but the puppeteers behind this fiasco would very much like us to focus on this distraction at the expense of the real questions: did the president know that public funds were being misappropriated to upgrade his home?

In his reply to Parliament earlier this year, Zuma denied that former public works minister Gwen Mahlangu-Nkabinde told him about the extent of the upgrades to his home. He told Parliament that he was only aware of upgrades undertaken by his family of its own account.

"The nature and form of the improvements was decided upon by the relevant officials through their departments. As already indicated, such information would not include details on the specifics of what would be done, by whom and at what cost," his reply said.

He also said he had been "aware" that the security cluster would do upgrades of its own as part of his presidential security arrangements, but heavily suggested that he had not bothered to check what it was doing. It is improbable that he did not know that these were costly upgrades, if he had at all visited his own home in the past few years. He need only have looked around.

It is impossible to buy this false credulity. Nxesi’s difficulty in releasing the report for public dissemination seems motivated by the fact that there is just no explaining away the R206m expense.

This irritating passing-the-buck exercise is exactly the same kind of thing we saw with the Gupta/Waterkloof scandal. After the Guptas were allowed to use an air force base for private travel, the African National Congress was first out the block with condemnation. Things moved along swiftly after that, till we discovered that practically the only one to be blamed was state protocol chief Bruce Koloane. He was the only person who put this in motion, without the knowledge of any political bosses? We are not buying it, as they said to the man selling the one-legged dog.

Zuma is being shielded from scrutiny. It’s that simple.

Tuesday, July 2, 2013

a MISS is as good as... Spat over ‘top secret’ Nkandla report

State Security Minister Siyabonga Cwele has dismissed as “factually incorrect” suggestions by Public Works Minister Thulas Nxesi that he classified the Nkandlagate report “top secret”.

He said on Monday that only Nxesi, who commissioned the probe into the controversial R206 million upgrade to President Jacob Zuma’s private homestead, can classify or declassify the report.

This raises questions about whether Nxesi deliberately misled Parliament when he said last month that Cwele had classified the report in terms of the Minimum Information Security Standards.

Cwele’s statement has also led to the DA accusing Nxesi of using Cwele’s name to justify his decision to refer the report to the joint standing committee on intelligence.

DA parliamentary leader Lindiwe Mazibuko added that Nxesi was “clutching at straws” in his efforts to justify his decision not to make it public.

Nxesi’s legal adviser, Phillip Masilo, conceded on Monday that Cwele had never classified the Nkandla report.

However, he denied that Nxesi had attributed the decision to classify the report to the state security minister in the first place.

In his June 19 letter to National Assembly Speaker Max Sisulu, Nxesi had said he would rather submit the report – on Cwele’s behalf – to joint standing committee on intelligence chairman Cecil Burgess.

“The report on the security upgrades at Nkandla has been classified as ‘top secret’ in terms of the Minimum Information Security Standards, rendering it exempt from disclosure, and its classification can only be adjusted by the task team itself, and (I have) been unable to provide the Auditor-General and the Public Protector with copies of the report owing to its classification as ‘top secret’, but was attending to the challenge that it presented,” said Nxesi.

Sisulu, after getting legal opinion, subsequently said he would allow the Nkandla report to be considered behind closed doors by the intelligence committee only.

This decision prevented even Auditor-General Terence Nombembe and Public Protector Thuli Madonsela from accessing the report.

But Cwele hit back on Monday, saying he had nothing to do with the decision to classify the report.

His spokesman, Brian Dube, said: “We wish to indicate that it’s factually incorrect that the Minister of State Security, Dr Siyabonga Cwele, has classified the report top secret or issued an instruction to this effect as claimed by some media reports. In terms of the prevailing classification regime, the author of the report is the one who classifies it.

“As the report is authored by the task team and owned by the commissioning minister of public works, the minister of state security cannot classify or declassify it or issue instructions to this effect.”

Masilo denied that Nxesi said Cwele had classified the report. He accused the DA of distortion.

“I think that’s unfortunate. It’s actually incorrect. Minister Nxesi never said the report was classified by Minister Cwele.”

He added that Nxesi was asked two questions: What legislation did he rely on in classifying the task team report, and what classification grading was given to that report?

“And the minister answered that the classification was done in terms of the Protection of Information Act and also in terms of the Minimum Information Security Standards, which is an approved cabinet policy,” he added.

Mazibuko maintained that Nxesi had “serious questions” to answer regarding his “glaring inconsistencies” in the wake of Cwele’s decision to publicly distance himself from the classification of the Nkandla report.

“I will again write to Minister Nxesi and ask for urgent clarification on all of these glaring inconsistencies, as well as the omissions in his official correspondence with Parliament.

“Should he fail to provide satisfactory answers to these questions, I will table a motion in the National Assembly requesting that he be investigated for misleading the House,” Mazibuko said.

Chaotic start to poo-dumping case

Cape Town - More than 20 people protesting outside the Bellville Magistrate’s Court in support of the alleged Cape Town International Airport faeces-tossers were arrested on Monday for being too close to the court building without permission.

They were at court for the appearance of the nine people arrested at the airport last week - city councillor Luyiso Nkohla, expelled councillor Andile Lili, Yanga Njingwana, Ben Dyoni, Bantubakhe Ngobodiya, Wandesile Mkapa, Jaj Dimiso, Bongile Zamazo and Thembela Mabajwa.

Police spokesman FC van Wyk said 14 men and eight women, aged between 21 and 45, were arrested for protesting within 100m of a court without permission. They would appear in court soon.

Inside the court, magistrate Jannie Kotze heard that seven of the nine arrested for dumping human waste “had a propensity to commit similar crimes”.

Prosecutor Greg Wolmarans said the State opposed bail for the nine men because, based on their previous conduct, it was likely they would commit similar crimes if released.

Seven of the men, excluding Ngobodiya and Mkapa, were arrested early last month for dumping human waste on the steps of the Provincial Legislature or flinging faeces at Premier Helen Zille’s vehicle while she visited Khayelitsha.


The court heard that the seven had pending cases of public violence, and the Cape Town magistrate had issued an order that prohibited them from engaging in illegal protests.

The airport protest followed that order.

The men in court on Monday have been charged under the Civil Aviation Act.

If convicted they face a fine or 30 years in custody.

Advocate Thembalihle Sidaki, for the nine, read bail affidavits into the record.

The men all had fixed addresses, said they would not evade their trial, did not know any witnesses and would not interfere with them.

Nkohla said: “I was called on by the people to highlight the unhygienic and unbearable sanitation services by the City of Cape Town.”

He said residents who used the portable toilets felt their rights to dignity had been violated as the human waste had not been removed for two months.

Sidaki said that no flights or equipment had been affected or damaged, and he questioned the charge brought against the men.

But Wolmarans said that according to the Airports Company South Africa, faeces and tyre-burning protests on the N2 near the airport had caused a collective 10-hour flight delay recently, amounting to a loss of R500 000.

The men are due back in court on Tuesday, when Wolmarans is expected to argue why bail should be denied.

Monday, July 1, 2013

Poo protest closes N2

Cape Town - Protesters blocked a portion of the N2 highway in Khayelitsha on Monday with toilet pots full of faeces and burning tyres.

However, police soon cleared the road, said Lieutenant-Colonel Andre Traut. The protest started at about 5.30am.

 Traffic spokesman Kenny Africa said the protest started on the R300 and spread to Mew Way.

 The incident follows a spate of protests about sanitation in Cape Town that has resulted in numerous closures of the N2 and a number of arrests for dumping human waste. Some 184 people were arrested for public violence in Woodstock last month and nine men on Tuesday for dumping human waste at Cape Town International Airport.