Tuesday, July 16, 2013

Fire breaks out in home after mom leaves

Cape Town - Authorities are investigating allegations that a Macassar mother locked her daughter, who has a mental condition, and granddaughter in their home, where a fire later broke out.

Sally Williams, who shares the house with her daughter, Tammelin Williams, 17, and granddaughter Cherice, five, denied the allegations on Monday.

No one was injured in the fire.

The city’s Disaster Risk Management Centre spokesman, Wilfred Solomons-Johannes, said rescue personnel were alerted to a fire in Ring Avenue after 10am on Sunday.

“When the volunteers interviewed (Tammelin)… she said they were locked in the house while her mother went to the shebeen,” he said.

Solomons-Johannes said residents alleged it was not the first time the children had been locked in the house.

“The Department of Social Development was notified and will be investigating the incident.”

A social worker was expected to visit the home as Williams could face charges of child neglect under the Children’s Act, Solomons-Johannes said.

An investigation was under way to establish the cause of the fire.

On Monday, Williams told the Cape Times she had gone to a nearby shop, and when she returned, her house was on fire.

“I just went to the shop to get groceries when one of the boys came running to tell me the house was burning. When I came home there were already so many people. I don’t like that people made their own stories about me and what happened. It’s not true,” she said.

Tammelin said she managed to unlock the door and left before the fire started. “I was next door when I heard one of the boys shouting there was smoke coming out of my windows. People came and started throwing water. It happened so quickly, but all my things burnt.”

* Early on Monday, an unidentified man was burned to death after his shack caught alight in Du Noon near Milnerton.

In Langa, eight people were left homeless by a fire that gutted two council houses.

On Sunday, an unidentified man died and 15 people were left homeless when their shacks in Gugulethu burned down.

Police are investigating a case of arson in Delft, where a fire was started after a domestic dispute on Sunday.

Monday, July 15, 2013

Two dead in Cape Town fires

Cape Town - Two people died and several others were left homeless, because of fires in Cape Town a city official said on Monday.

A man was burned beyond recognition on Mnandi road around 1am said disaster risk management centre spokesman Wilfred Solomons-Johannes said.

A second man died at the Europe informal settlement in Gugulethu around 11pm on Sunday.

Fires in Gugelethu, Langa and Du Noon in the past 2 days had left at least 24 people homeless.

The cause if the fire is being investigated.

- Sapa

Saturday, July 13, 2013

Tokyo Sexwale – Minister of Human Settlements - cio

Minister since: 2009 - 2013

Problems inherited: His predecessor, Lindiwe Sisulu, launched the N2 Gateway project, which she termed the “biggest housing project ever undertaken by any government”, in 2005. It became Sexwale’s responsibility. Still incomplete after eight years, it will now be passed on to new Human Settlements Minister Connie September.

Failures: 

Sexwale has previously termed his portfolio a “daunting challenge”, with a housing backlog of more than 2 million units, affecting about 8 million people. With a 2030 deadline to remove the backlog, the department had to provide 200 000 houses a year, a target it could not meet. Sexwale admitted that the bill to fix the problems was R50 billion – nearly twice his annual budget.

Sanitation has proved to be a major political point scorer ahead of next year’s election, and Sexwale earlier this year admitted that his department, with a sanitation backlog of more than 2 million households, was unlikely to meet the December 2014 deadline to eradicate the bucket system. He attributed this to poor performance by municipalities, and growing numbers of migrant workers...

- IOL

Friday, July 12, 2013

South Africa: our state of corruption

Cape Town - Almost half of South Africans who came into contact with government officials (47 percent) paid a bribe to them in the past year, a high-profile international survey of state corruption has found.

The figure is significantly higher than the 31 percent global average.

The annual Transparency International Global Corruption Barometer released on Wednesday showed that of the South Africans in the survey, 74 percent had come into contact with police in the past 12 months, and 36 percent of these had paid a bribe to a policeman.

Most bribes in South Africa were paid for permit services (39 percent), while 30 percent said that they had paid bribes to officials in the judicial system.

The survey asked respondents if they had bribed officials in eight categories - police, registry or permit services, the judiciary, education, medical or health services, utilities, tax or customs, and land services.

Forty-seven percent said they had bribed at least one official in the previous 12 months.

Asked why they had done so, 41 percent said they had hoped “to speed things up” and 36 percent said a bribe was the only way they could get the service they needed.

The survey polled 114 000 people in 107 countries. In South Africa, it entailed face to face interviews with a demographically weighted sample of 1 000 urban residents.

In addition to asking respondents whether they had resorted to bribery, it tested perceptions of corruption in each of the countries.

In South Africa, 83 percent viewed the police force as the most corrupt institution in the public sector.

South Africa was among 36 countries in which the police force was seen as the most corrupt institution.

The South African public also has a dim view of political parties, with 77 percent believing them to be corrupt. The survey found 74 percent believed civil servants were corrupt, while 70 percent said Parliament or the legislature is corrupt.

More than half of the people interviewed (54 percent) thought that the business sector was corrupt, 40 percent that the media were corrupt, 43 percent that NGOs were corrupt, and 50 percent that the judiciary was corrupt.

Corruption Watch executive director David Lewis said the findings confirmed that the increase in corruption was “not a mere perception”.

“We solicit public experiences of corruption and we are getting a significant number of reports of bribery and other acts of corruption, especially from poor communities,” Lewis said.

He said Corruption Watch had received more than 4 200 complaints about corruption and related matters since its launch in January last year. He said half of these focused on the abuse of public power and resources by the private and public sectors.

Nearly nine out of 10 people surveyed said they would act against corruption. Two thirds of those who had been asked to pay a bribe had refused.

In 20 of the 107 countries, respondents viewed the judiciary as the most corrupt. In these countries, on average 30 percent of the people who had come into contact with the judicial system had been asked to pay a bribe.

About 54 percent of the people surveyed globally considered their government to be ineffective in fighting corruption. In the 2010/11 survey, 47 percent of people had thought their government was ineffective in fighting corruption.

Almost two thirds (64 percent) of the people around the world thought personal contacts were important in getting things done in the public sector. This went up to 80 percent in Israel, Italy, Lebanon, Malawi, Morocco and Russia.

Nkandla's money mine

As Jacob Zuma's hand-picked private contractor, Moneymine was set to land public works contracts on the project for several years.

In mid-November 2009, when the public works department was already in a flurry over the increasingly complicated security upgrades at President Jacob Zuma's Nkandla homestead, the director of one of its main contractors was rubbing shoulders with ANC top brass in Guangzhou, China.

Pamela Mfeka, the sole director of Moneymine Enterprises, which was already on site at Nkandla in 2009 doing private work for Zuma, was accompanied by her husband, Michael Mfeka, on the five-day trip.

Pamela, who also owns Igugu Training and Investments and Igugu Functions Venue, was a member of the delegation, organised by the ANC's Progressive Business Forum.

The trip was led by the ANC's former treasurer general, Mathews Phosa.

Michael, who is not listed as a director of his wife's companies, worked as Moneymine's project manager at Nkandla.

Towards the end of 2009, the department was already spending money it had not secured – it was following instructions from the police and the defence department for security upgrades to Zuma's private residence.

The estimated cost at that stage was R27.8-million; the projected cost by October 2012 was R270-million.

Handsome profit
But on their China trip the Mfekas, from Pinetown in Durban, would have rested easy in the knowledge that Moneymine was guaranteed several multimillion-rand government contracts for work at Nkandla.

As Zuma's hand-picked private contractor, Moneymine had profited handsomely from its initial association with him and was set to land public works contracts on the project for several years.

Moneymine, which worked on Nkandla's high-security core area in phase one of the development, has been paid R56.3-million so far, according to the public works department's latest figures.

Its first contract at Nkandla for the department began in November 2009, according to documents obtained by the Mail & Guardian following a Promotion of Access to Information Act application.

Mfeka refers to her company's phase one work in a document listing its previous projects. Referring to "Durban Project A – Construction of a Homestead in Nkandla", she records the start of this project as November 2009, giving the following November as the completion date. The total cost was R19.4-million.

Moneymine's continued role at Nkandla was largely guaranteed by Zuma's insistence that he did not want another company on site.

Procurement procedures
In March 2010, a few months after the China trip, the department's Jean Rindel, who was overseeing the Nkandla upgrades, explained why Moneymine had been appointed as a phase one contractor despite the deviation from normal procurement procedures.

Rindel noted: "The owner of the property had appointed a contractor, Moneymine Investments, to construct new accommodation at the site. The current status of that project is that the contractor is on site and construction is 15% completed. The state has the obligation to include the security measures in the existing and the new accommodation."

Rindel noted that, as no other contractor could do the job, the work could not go out on open tender.

"It is essential that Moneymine construction be appointed under the negotiated procedure to eliminate … risks. The contractor is security cleared by the National Intelligence Agency and is trusted by the owner of the property.

"It is thus essential that the same contractor, Moneymine Investments, be appointed to complete the works," he wrote.

Shortly after the memorandum, Rindel's pleas were answered in the affirmative, despite the fact that Moneymine had in effect been appointed to do the security installations and other works in the initial phase of the project.

In January 2011, Moneymine was again guaranteed work – for phase two.

Security surveillance
Another department document suggests that the decision to go with a "negotiated bid" at that stage was also indirectly prompted by Zuma: "A meeting was held with Deputy Minister [of Public Works] Hendrietta Bogopane-Zulu (and other senior officials) on 21 December 2010 in which she confirmed that the principal [Zuma] indicated that he does not want other contractors on site in phase two."

Phase two related mostly to the installation of additional "security measures", including 31 new buildings, police accommodation, bullet-proof glass and a security surveillance system.

Rindel and other public works department officials consistently motivated for Moneymine's appointments to be rolled over to ensure the "integration" of Zuma's private upgrades with the department's.

The company was also handed the remainder of work left by Bone­lena, which the department fired in April during phase three, for which Moneymine received an extra R3.47-million.

Moneymine has a number of other lucrative contracts from public works.

Michael Mfeka said neither he nor his wife could comment on Moneymine's involvement at Nkandla. He said that they were "not allowed to talk to the press" and that the department "has all the information". 

- M&G

Nkandla: How IDC splashed R10m on bailout

When Bonelena, a firm nominated to do the major work at Jacob Zuma's Nkandla homestead, was liquidated the IDC intervened to keep the firm going.

ust who is Thandeka Nene – and what is her hold over state institutions?

Nene was the sole member of Bonelena Construction CC, one of two building firms nominated by the public works department to do the major work on the security upgrade at President Jacob Zuma's Nkandla homestead.

Documents regarding the controversial development obtained by amaBhungane show:
  • When Bonelena was liquidated, the state-owned Industrial Development Corporation (IDC) intervened to keep the firm going, providing extra funding when the prospect of recovering its loans appeared doubtful;
  • When Bonelena's failure to meet deadlines led public works to cancel the contract, exposure in court of Project A – the department's code name for Nkandla – was a large concern for the department. Public Works Minister Thulas Nxesi also intervened, leading the department to backtrack and reach a compromise with Nene; and
  • She had such high-level access that when part of the work was awarded – supposedly erroneously – to the other main contractor (See "Nkandla's money mine", Page 4), the public works' deputy minister intervened and the architects were obliged to write her a grovelling apology for their error.
IDC to the rescue

Documents obtained by amaBhungane relating to the June 2012 liquidation of Bonelena suggest the IDC went to extraordinary lengths to rescue Nene, who at that stage owed the corporation nearly R20-million.

She had concluded a loan agreement with the IDC in February 2011.

In April 2012, the public works project manager cancelled the Nkandla contract with Bonelena, citing repeated failures to reach agreed construction milestones.

Nene and her lawyers refused to accept the cancellation, arguing it was unlawful and unfair, as she had completed 95% of the work.

In May 2012, a Durban car-hire firm, Reebib Rentals, applied to liquidate Bonelena over R190000 it was allegedly owed. A final winding-up order was granted in the High Court in Pietermaritzburg on July 18.

Lobbying

Meanwhile, Nene was lobbying vigorously to overturn the contract cancellation. Her lawyers wrote to the department threatening legal action and she refused to hand over the keys to the Nkandla site so that another contractor could take over.

She also wrote to the new minister, Thulas Nxesi, on June 15 2012, noting: "I have great respect of the president … and take cognizance of the security measures of the project."

She wrote to him again on July 20, noting: "We have received phone calls and text messages from creditors threatening to approach the media. We have also received phone calls from the media inquiring as to the nature of the project and the payment delays. We have not commented and will not be held liable for any resultant reports that may surface as a result of the media."

Earlier, the Durban public works regional office had written to the Pretoria head office warning about the possible fallout for Zuma – referred to as "the Principal".

"The severe implications of cancelling the contract is expected to end in court cases between the contractor and the department. This will result in all the project information being subjected to public scrutiny," the regional office said.

"This is an unacceptable risk to this office and could result in political fallout that could possibly influence the Principal's political position very negatively."

Nxesi pays up

The letters had the desired effect. On July 31 2012, a teleconference was held with Nene and her lawyer at one end and the minister and his senior department advisers at the other. An urgent agreement was reached to pay Bonelena about R7-million.

Neither Nene nor her lawyer disclosed that the company had already been placed in final liquidation.

Bad faith?

In September 2012, after the money had already been paid out, one senior official, Gerard Damsta, expressed outrage at discovering this.

In an email to the department's chief legal adviser, he wrote: "I have learnt today with great shock and disappointment … that Bonelena was provisionally liquidated on 4 June 2012 … This means that Bonelena negotiated with the employer [the minister and others from the department of public works] … when it was already not in a competent position to have done so …

"The conduct of Ms Nene in all of this is what I need your legal expertise for …

"Can it be labelled as fraudulent? Bad faith?? … What recourse does [the department] have under these circumstances?"

But, instead of fraud charges, Nene got a rescue package from the IDC to take her company out of liquidation.

Good money after bad?

According to a report by liquidator Eugene Nel, the IDC proposed and funded the rescue scheme.

On top of its R20-million, the corporation agreed to put up a further R10-million to pay the liquidators, fund the payout of preferred creditors (such as banks and the South African Revenue Service) and offer concurrent creditors – such as Reebib Rentals – 50c of every rand owed.

According to Nel, the offer was generous as the company's financial position was so dire that, if it was simply wound up, preferred creditors would have got a reduced payout and there would have been nothing at all for others.

The IDC insists that the decision to assist Bonelena to exit liquidation was "not influenced by politics whatsoever".

IDC public relations manager Mandla Mpangase told amaBhungane it viewed the liquidation as "erroneous" and that Bonelena had existing contracts "based on which the IDC will recover its money".

"Bonelena continues to honour its repayment arrangement with the IDC."

He declined to give details but the liquidation report suggests Bonelena will have to score some sweet new deals to be able to repay the loan.

Security?

At the date of the provisional liquidation, Bonelena owed about R32-million to creditors, of whom the IDC was the largest, with R20-million owed to it.

The liquidators judged two contracts – a prison upgrade and a school building project – were worth keeping the company solvent for.

However, the IDC's security was calculated at only R11.5-million – not a major comfort when its R20-million loan was pushed up to R30-million to secure Bonelena's release from liquidation.

In return for the cash injection, the IDC demanded that a quantity surveyor and an accountant appointed by the IDC should be given full access to help to manage the company.

AmaBhungane's attempts to communicate with Nene for clarity on the current state of the company were fruitless.

Other friends in high places

The public works documents obtained by amaBhungane provide other evidence of Nene's clout, despite officials and contractors complaining about the company's performance.

When Moneymine was allocated work that had been earmarked for Bonelena, Public Works Deputy Minister Hendrietta Bogopane-Zulu got involved and ordered that the decision be reversed.

The architects were obliged to write to the department and the deputy minister apologising for the error, saying: "We meant no disrespect."

- M&G

Inside Zuma's cow-a-bunker

President Jacob Zuma's Nkandla cattle are kept safe in their new enclosure, which cost taxpayers R1-million.

They spend the night safely ensconced behind multiple layers of high-tech security, and incidentally also safe from the prying eyes of passing gawkers who stop cars and buses on the nearby road for quick cellphone photographs of the now infamous presidential compound at Nkandla.

But just after 8am, as the sun starts to burn the early morning winter chill off the grass, President Jacob Zuma's cattle are led through a gate in a specially constructed underpass out of the main security zone, past the neat vegetable garden, up a paved security road, through an outer perimeter fence, past the newly constructed quarters for security personnel, and up the hill to their grazing grounds.

And as they pass over a public road in single file, you can inspect the herd that sleeps safely – and in apparent luxury – thanks to more than R1-million in tax money spent on their quarters (that is, their living – not hind – quarters).

As of late 2009, Zuma's cattle were kept like those of his neighbours: somewhat informally. But after he took the highest office in the land, a team of state officials determined that, along with a helipad, fire protection and bulletproof glass, the president's rural residence needed a "revamped" cattle kraal – for security reasons.

Though the final cost of the kraal is not known, documents released to the Mail & Guardian Centre for Investigative Journalism, ama-Bhungane, show a contractor quote for R1-million to bring it up to the standard required for a "prestige project", and that officials were loath in the extreme to make the president himself pay for it.

That would make the kraal worth double the value of the cattle kept in it. Though in good condition, the largely mature 115-head mixed herd, of Nguni and other breeds more suited for commercial beef farming, is worth about R500 000.

Value of the herd
That is substantial, especially in an area where much smaller family herds predominate, but the difference between the cost of the kraal and the value of the herd is enough to make experts choke.

"Sjoe, that's a lot of money to spend on just a kraal," said the head of a cattle-breeding association, who asked not be named for fear of political reprisal. "If you told me that was the cost of fencing a whole grazing area and laying water, yes. A million bucks for something everyone else does with tree branches? I couldn't run my business that way. It sounds like a vanity kraal."

Over-engineered though it may be, the kraal is clearly working as advertised. Zuma's cattle, a resource he could traditionally tap as a source of lobola, are fit and healthy and show no signs of the various diseases and ailments that can accrue from sleeping rough, even in the relatively mild winters of inland KwaZulu-Natal.

Compared with other animals in the area, Zuma's herd positively glows with health.

A cursory examination of the well-fortified compound shows that not everything is working as optimally. Certainly not trash collection, or maintenance, or all of the expensive and expansive security systems.

Perimeter lights, installed as part of a series of upgrades worth well over R200-million, seem to be suffering from a faulty light sensor system, with the result that they briefly flicker off and on again every two minutes throughout the night.

The envy of the neighbourhood
The vegetable garden – which, according to documents, was partly funded by taxpayers to ensure a secure food supply – is only partially cultivated, with a yield that will very quickly fall short of providing a minimum calorie intake to a full complement of inhabitants should the compound be cut off from supplies for any length of time.

But in such an event, the mean time to starvation will be extended by the availability of packs of frozen sausage rolls, which a mounting rubbish pile just across the road from Nkandla's main entrance shows to be a firm favourite within the walls.

General maintenance, too, is clearly falling well behind schedule as final construction is still under way on at least two major buildings in the complex.

Weeds are merrily spreading between the paving stones of the security road between the inner and outer perimeter fences, and rubbish is piling up, especially in a section of temporary buildings erected (at state expense, at least partially) to house construction workers and contractors who have been involved in the costly upgrade. Among the detritus is the carcass of a light bakkie, thoroughly stripped of its valuable parts.

The presidential cattle and their accommodation, on the other hand, are the envy of the neighbourhood.

"You must understand we love our cattle," said a herder, keeping an eye over his own small collection grazing nearby. Cattle theft is hardly a big problem, he allowed, but it would be "nice to have those men with guns" to look after them after dark.

If security includes preventing embarrassment, such as presidential stock theft, then R1-million may have been well spent. "Nobody is going to steal those cattle," said the herder.

Zuma's spokesperson had not responded to a request for comment by the time of going to press.

- M&G

Wednesday, July 10, 2013

Shack fire leaves five homeless

Cape Town - Five people were displaced when their shack caught alight in Khayelitsha on Wednesday morning, a City of Cape Town official said.

The fire was detected by crime surveillance cameras in Nonkqubela around 1am, said disaster risk management centre spokesman Wilfred Solomons-Johannes.

“As a result of the vigilance of the surveillance operators that observed the fire and the quick response of the fire and rescue services, the fire was prevented from spreading.”

Those affected were given food parcels, clothing, blankets, and building material. No injuries were reported.

The cause of the fire was unknown. - Sapa

Madonsela: Indifference is a plague

Cape Town - Public Protector Thuli Madonsela says maladministration in the country’s public service is having a greater impact on citizens than crime.

Indifference is a plague
Speaking in Cape Town at the launch of a public dialogue into health care matters on Wednesday, Madonsela said maladministration, particularly in the form of indifference, had left many families “traumatised and destitute”, and threatened to undermine the good work that the government had already done.

“We’ve had quite a number of people coming to our offices begging us for trauma counselling. I’ve seen men - breadwinners - in tears who have lost everything they had due to maladministration. These families end up being destitute because some government official hasn’t done his or her job.”

Indifference is a plague Indifference is a plague
While the country had shown significant improvement in meeting some of the Millennium Development Goals, including eradication of poverty, combating HIV/Aids and reducing child and maternal mortality, it could do even better were it not for maladministration.

Madonsela said that as part of an investigation into health issues - including staff working conditions, quality of care, procurement and child mortality - over the next few months she would hold public meetings in all the provinces.

These would focus on the maladministration that “threatens to undermine this good work”.

Indifference is a plague Indifference is a plagueIndifference is a plague Indifference is a plague Indifference is a plague 

While her office had received an unprecedented number of complaints recently, Madonsela said the service was being under-utilised. Only 43 percent of South Africans knew it existed.

In the past 17 years, the number of cases had jumped 12-fold to almost 34 000 cases last year - the highest in its history.

Another problem was limited funding of R200 million. This meant she could not investigate all the complaints.

Madonsela said they were focusing on the achievement of Millennium Development Goals and maladministration as “good governance is central to the eradication of poverty”.

Some at the launch vented their anger about health services in the province.

Indifference is a plague Indifference is a plague

Belinda Petersen, a Cape Flats community worker, invited Madonsela to visit clinics and hospitals in poorer areas and see for herself patients’ struggles.

Mzanywa Ndibongo, chairman of the Khayelitsha Health Forum, said the new Khayelitsha Hospital ”looks beautiful from the outside, but inside people are dying”.

Indifference is a plague Indifference is a plague Indifference is a plague Indifference is a plague Indifference is a plague Indifference is a plague

How Sexwale learnt his fate - He was 'working' LOCKED IN...

Former human settlements minister Tokyo Sexwale was locked in a meeting with his top management team in his office shortly before noon on Tuesday when his phone rang.

It’s not clear who was on the other side of the phone, according sources.

Sexwale rushed out to answer it. He took his time before returning to the office to resume the discussions.

Eventually, the businessman and former Gauteng premier returned to the room to share the bad news: He was about to be fired.

A well-placed source said: “He was in a top management meeting in his office. It’s clear it was people from the Presidency who called him. It’s sad.

“I sympathise with him for that. To be called and be told it’s over while you are dealing with issues you care so much about is not a good feeling.”

Departmental sources said Sexwale eventually went back to the meeting and informed his staff that he was about to be a former minister.

“It seems he won’t even go back to Parliament to be a backbencher,” an insider added.

Sexwale’s spokesman Xolani Xundu could not be reached for comment on Tuesday. He failed to respond to repeated calls and an SMS.

Sexwale "respected" President Jacob Zuma's decision, The New Age newspaper reported on Wednesday.

"I respect whatever decisions are made by the president," said Sexwale.

"Whatever they are, we respect it."

A few hours later, President Jacob Zuma sealed the fate of Sexwale and two other ministers – former communications minister Dina Pule and former co-operative governance and traditional affairs minister Richard Baloyi.

It was Zuma’s fourth cabinet reshuffle since 2009.

“Ladies and gentlemen, 20 years of democracy have changed the face of our country, and the last five years have pushed that change forward.

“To take that change forward, to take it further, I have decided to make some changes to the national executive,” he said.

Zuma did not mention Baloyi, Pule and Sexwale by name. While the previous reshuffles were prompted by Public Protector Thuli Madonsela’s adverse reports against former public works minister Gwen Mahlangu-Nkabinde and former national police commissioner Bheki Cele – indicating that Zuma was perhaps responding to the concerns of the public – on Tuesday’s move seems to have been motivated by various developments in and outside the government.

Pule has a cloud over her head over allegations that she misused public funds and allowed her boyfriend to hijack her department, while Baloyi is perceived to have largely failed to take the crucial service delivery department forward.

Sexwale, on the other hand, appears to have paid the price for challenging Zuma openly ahead of the ANC’s Mangaung conference last December and his subsequent failure to try to mend relations after the fallout.

Tuesday, July 9, 2013

InternAfrica waves farewell to Tokyo Sexwale & Waves hello to Connie September

HUMAN Settlements Minister Tokyo Sexwale and embattled Communications Minister Dina Pule received the boot on Tuesday as President Jacob Zuma reshuffled his Cabinet for the fourth time in his first five-year term, set to conclude next April.

Dispensing with the dead weight in his Cabinet has become a hallmark of the Zuma presidency, despite his detractors criticising him for being soft on slackers.

Speaking in Pretoria, Mr Zuma made the following appointments:

• Minister of Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs: Lechesa Tsenoli, former deputy minister for rural development and land reform, to replace Richard Baloyi.

• Minister of Human Settlements: Connie September, African National Congress (ANC) MP, to replace Mr Sexwale.

• Minister of Communications: Yunus Carrim, former deputy minister of co-operative governance and traditional affairs, to replace Ms Pule.

• Minister of Energy: Ben Martins, former minister of transport, to replace Dipuo Peters.

• Minister of Transport: Ms Peters to replace Mr Martins.

• Deputy Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development: John Jeffery, ANC MP, to replace Andries Nel.

• Deputy Minister of Science and Technology: Michael Masuta, to fill vacancy.

• Deputy Minister of Rural Development and Land Reform: Pamela Tshwete, ANC MP, to replace Mr Tsenoli.

• Deputy Minister of Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs: Mr Nel, to replace Mr Carrim.

Mr Zuma’s first Cabinet reshuffle was in October 2010, just more than a year after taking office, his second in October 2011 and his third in June last year. Tuesday's overhaul marks his fourth, about 10 months before South Africa's fifth democratic general election.

Mr Sexwale had backed former ANC deputy president Kgalema Motlanthe in the party's elective race in Mangaung last year.

Ms Pule has long had a cloud of allegations and corruption hanging over her — including that her boyfriend received access to funds raised for an Information and Communication Indaba. He allegedly used the money to buy her Christian Louboutin shoes.

- BDlive

Toilet drive city’s best shot, says De Lille

Cape Town - While the City of Cape Town’s solutions to the sanitation backlog are “not ideal”, they are the “very best anyone can provide in challenging circumstances”, says mayor Patricia de Lille.

The solutions include the provision of chemical toilets, container toilets or portable flush toilets, depending on the density of the informal settlement and ease of access for council staff needing to service the units.

De Lille said the city’s toilet problems were compounded by the legacy of apartheid spatial planning, the use of land in flood-prone areas and the concomitant risk to sewer systems.

“This state of affairs is not right and it is not fair, but it is what this government has to work with, said De Lille. As the city was bound by the constitution to provide access to basic services, it had a “duty to come up with innovative solutions… with every means at (its) disposal”.

Many of the city’s 233 informal settlements were located on unsuitable land, such as low-lying floodplains, and were characterised by high density and poverty.

“And when we are confronted with these informal settlements, we are faced with the challenge of providing services where our engineering reaches its limitations and the land topography does not allow us to install the level of services we want to,” she said.

It was not always possible to install water-borne sanitation, especially in flood-prone areas. Pipelines would sag or misalign, causing blockages and spills that would put the health of residents at risk.

The metro was the leading sanitation provider in the country, said Ernest Sonnenberg, mayoral committee for utility services.

In June last year, the city faced a toilet backlog of 26 450 toilets. However, the city is providing 23 000 portable flush toilets, 1 300 full flush toilets as well as container and chemical toilets, said Sonnenberg. The city had set a target of one toilet for every five households, or less, in informal settlements.

The city had also allocated a combined capital and operation budget of R520 million for water and sanitation in informal settlements for this financial year, he said.

Nkandla: transparency and secrecy have swapped places

AMONG a long list of idealist sentiments since ridden roughshod over, this quote from President Jacob Zuma, dating from 2000 when he was deputy president, is worth some reflection: "I think it is important to say that public servants, in particular, more than anybody else, ought to be aware that they should be more upright and transparent insofar as the use of public funds is concerned."

Zuma said this in the National Assembly while answering a parliamentary question, one of the constitutional oversight mechanisms designed to ensure that very thing: the open and accountable conduct of public business.

Since then, however, rather than entrench that principle, the Zuma administration has done much to curtail it. Secrecy, not transparency, is becoming its default position. Instead of the onus being on public officials to explain why information should not be made public, it would now appear to be the case that an argument should be made for why it should.

In other words, the first impulse of the executive is to withhold information (as classified, confidential or a security risk) rather than reveal it.

This subversion is significant. The constitution aims to ensure that the obligation is on public officials to be transparent. The Promotion of Access to Information Act states: "Section 32(1)(a) of the constitution provides that everyone has the right of access to any information held by the state."

From first principles, information held by the state is effectively public property. Officials, elected by voters to represent their interests, are merely its custodians.

It is true there are exceptions — for example, when the availability of such information might genuinely threaten the public good or violate an individual’s private rights — but where there is a constraint, the state must prove that to be the case.

Zuma’s personal KwaZulu-Natal mansion, Nkandla, has come to embody this perversion — and it is doubly problematic. Not only is much of his house built and secured using public money, but the documentation of how the money was spent is public too. Yet those decisions have been shrouded in secrecy.

Only Deputy President Kgalema Motlanthe seems to be willing to advocate for more transparency: "Of course, you cannot divulge information that would make the occupants of that residence vulnerable, but I would have thought that the scope of the project would be made public. Accountability and transparency are two sides of the same coin. It is important to be accountable in the public space. Once there’s a shroud of secrecy, it gives rise to speculation, suspicion and mistrust."

It is not clear why Motlanthe decided now was the time to be forthright about Nkandla. Since Mangaung, where he was ousted as African National Congress deputy president, both his power and influence seem to have waned, but whatever the politics, his recent remarks capture perfectly the obligation on the state.

That very public contradiction will win the deputy president no friends. It is as much a political attack as it is a principled position. Nevertheless, it is absolutely correct. Those ministers responsible for the report into Nkandla cannot hide a range of non-security-related expenses behind a veil of secrecy, claiming that any disclosure would compromise Zuma’s safety. The general thrust of the expenditure simply does not relate to security.

What is so refreshing about Motlanthe’s position is that it speaks to a principle, not just to the practical nature of the problem.

One of the biggest problems facing South Africa is the general inability to separate principle from practical concern. Too often we suspend or pervert a principle because we are suckered into obsessing about the particular nature of the practical problem in front of us.

This great love for all things pragmatic means we become distracted. If the issue is Nkandla, all we see is Zuma or presidential privilege. If the issue is Brett Murray’s Zuma painting, The Spear, all we see is culture or nudity. If the issue is the Olympics, all we see is national pride or patriotism. But there are critical principles and values at play in each case: transparency, freedom of speech and excellence.

In 2000, Zuma, too, articulated a principle. It is next to impossible to find that kind of sentiment made by him today. His rhetoric has become fused with pragmatism, not principle. It is no surprise that, under Zuma, we have seen the formulation of the Protection of State Information Act — in many ways the antithesis of the Promotion of Access to Information Act.

This attitude is to subvert the constitution itself — South Africa’s ultimate set of principles. If the state’s first inclination is always to say why something cannot be done, as opposed to why it should be, there is little point to ideals; for then it is striving not for a better future but simply to maintain the status quo. Governments driven by pragmatism are dangerous indeed.

It is telling that both references to principle — Zuma’s 2000 statement and Motlanthe’s more recent remarks — were made possible because of their relationship to power. Zuma, as deputy president, enjoyed less of the close scrutiny he does now; likewise, as so often happens, as Motlanthe’s position has become more fraught and he less beholden to his political masters, so his tongue has loosened.

If this is what is required for our public representatives to advocate for principles, we have much to be worried about. Just as the state’s first obligation should be to transparency, so our public representatives should be the first to articulate, promote and defend those principles that define our constitutional order.

Alas, as the order of things has been reversed, principles have become increasingly subservient to practical constraint, and our ideals restrained by self-interest and shortsightedness.