Wednesday, June 4, 2014

‘Rather kill me than take my home’

Cape Town - Some despairing residents of the unlawful Siyanyanzela informal settlement in Lwandle opted to torch their own shacks rather than watch the authorities demolish them and confiscate their building materials.

Three people were arrested on Tuesday on the second day of a tense stand-off between law enforcement agencies and residents after stones were thrown at police, who responded with stun grenades and rubber bullets.

Seven people were arrested on Monday after clashes with police. They are due to appear in court on Wednesday.

Amid the chaos life went on.

Sitting on the plot where her shack once stood, Nomapheli Pupu, 43, prepared food for her eight children.

She cooked samp for the three youngest children who were at school, while her eldest cooked chicken feet at another fire a few metres away.

She said: “My children left for school this morning and my shack was still standing then. I am left with this pot, samp and the chicken feet.”

Pupu moved to Siyanyanzela four months ago, after a church she was living in was demolished in Lusapho.

More than 100 shacks have been demolished.

Children’s clothing, wet mattresses and damaged building materials were scattered about the site.

The mother of a six-month-old boy, Andiswa Nhlapo, said she was left with nothing after her shack went.

“I begged police to allow me time to save some food and clothing for my baby, but they refused.

Nhlapo said she spent most of Monday night hustling food for her son from neighbours. “I went around begging neighbours to at least feed him tea because he was very hungry.”

On Tuesday, she begged police to rather kill her and her child instead of taking their home.

“I have no one to help me and my child. What more do these people want from us?”

Nonelwa Poto cut a forlorn figure last night as she packed what she could in a plastic bag, heaved it on to her head and walked away from the ruins of her home, her child Niya sleeping on her back.

She stepped through the mud in the fierce north-westerly wind, explaining: “I have found somewhere for us to sleep tonight, not far away.”

But that was as far as her plans stretched.

On Tuesday unhappy residents resorted to using petrol bombs to burn their own structures. About eight shacks were torched.

Ward councillor Mbuyiselo Matha said people were frustrated because most of them were still paying off their building materials.

“People were promised that their material would be returned. So they think it’s best for them to burn their own homes than to let the material go to waste in the hands of authorities.”

Matha said on Tuesday he was still negotiating space for people to sleep.

The land belongs to the SA National Roads Agency (Sanral) and is reserved for the rerouting of the N2. Sanral was granted an eviction order by the Western Cape High Court earlier this year.

The evictions have led to a blame game between the City of Cape Town and Sanral, with the national government and Cosatu weighing in.

Sanral has accused the city of walking away from discussions to find a solution to land in Siyanyanzela.

“This situation might not have arisen if the city had not walked away from the discussions with Sanral to find an amicable solution to the issue,” Sanral spokesman Vusi Mona said.

The city had abdicated responsibility towards residents of Lwandle, outside the Strand, he said.

“Despite the city’s efforts to put the blame on Sanral, the agency’s offer to donate land to Cape Town remains open. We call on the city to rescind its decision and restart the process to find a workable solution that will benefit the poor communities affected by recent events.”

But the city has hit back, calling on Sanral “to come clean on the facts”.

Siyabulela Mamkeli, the mayoral committee member for human settlements, said: “The city repeatedly warned Sanral to protect their land against the continual and new land invasions.

“They were advised by the city to purchase suitably sized land to accommodate the affected households. They have not done so.”

He said that the city had not objected to buying the Sanral-owned land for residents when it was discussed in 2011.

“It must be noted that Sanral’s statement, passing the buck to the city, is disingenuous.

“Their statement refers to historic occurrences and not to the new occupiers who have been affected by Sanral’s recent evictions. Sanral is evicting a new set of invaders.”

Mamkeli pleaded with Sanral to “stop this blame game and to put the needs of the residents first”.

The city would provide three community halls to house residents for one week only.

“We have a duty to protect the rights of those people who are on the housing waiting list. Therefore, if alternative accommodation in the form of a temporary relocation area was provided to the people who illegally invaded the Sanral land, we would in effect be rewarding queue-jumping at the expense of the rights of law-abiding residents.”

Transport spokesman Tiyani Ponto-Rikhotso said: “It is obvious that Sanral used the issue of toll roads in the Western Cape as an excuse to terminate discussions on the issue.”

Cosatu national spokesman Patrick Craven said Sanral’s actions were ruthless and inhumane.

“Families lost not only their homes but, what is worse, they weren’t offered alternative accommodation, but thrown on to the streets in the middle of winter,” he said.

Human Settlements Minister Lindiwe Sisulu has also entered the fray, saying the City of Cape Town and Sanral should have handled the evictions better.

“What we saw in the media, the information we gathered from the community, reports we received from Sanral and statements from the City of Cape Town leaves us with many unanswered questions,” she said in a statement on Wednesday.

“It is not possible that in the middle of a very cold Western Cape winter and rains and children writing exams the whole community can be removed in brutal force, that concerns me as the minister of human settlement, we are a caring government.”

Sisulu said an inquiry would be established to investigate all processes and procedures followed by all involved until the removal was authorised by the High Court and subsequently implemented this week.

Deputy Human Settlements Minister Zoe Kota and Transport Minister Dipuo Peters went to visit the scene of evictions.

They were briefed by the human settlements department in the Western Cape, Sanral and representatives of the community on Tuesday.

The department said that after a visit, Sisulu and Kota agreed that Sanral and the city could have handled the dispute and the whole relocation process differently.

The human settlements department said on Wednesday, that the ministers said that if the city and Sanral could not find a solution they should have gone to the provincial and national government for “mediation and guidance”.

Sisulu said that in consultation with Peters, the illegal occupiers will settle temporarily while government can assist to find a solution.

“We must be very clear, we do not encourage illegal occupation of land, it is the inhumane way in which children and women are being removed during winter that we are concern about, the people will have to move out of the land when necessary arrangements are made,” Sisulu said.

zodidi.dano@inl.co.za

Sisulu criticises Lwandle evictions

CAPE TOWN - The City of Cape Town and Sanral should have handled the evictions at Lwandle near Strand in the Western Cape better, Human Settlements Minister Lindiwe Sisulu said on Wednesday.

"What we saw in the media, the information we gathered from the community, reports we received from Sanral and statements from the City of Cape Town leaves us with many unanswered questions," she said in a statement.

"It is not possible that in the middle of a very cold Western Cape winter and rains and children writing exams the whole community can be removed in brutal force, that concerns me as the minister of human settlement, we are a caring government."

Sisulu said an inquiry would be established to investigate all processes and procedures followed by all involved until the removal was authorised by the High Court and subsequently implemented this week.

Deputy Human Settlements Minister Zoe Kota and Transport Minister Dipuo Peters went to visit the scene of evictions.

They were briefed by the human settlements department in the Western Cape, Sanral and representatives of the community on Tuesday.

The department said that after a visit, Sisulu and Kota agreed that Sanral and the city could have handled the dispute and the whole relocation process differently.

The eviction of shack dwellers began on Monday and continued into Tuesday.

The SA National Roads Agency Limited (Sanral), the owner of the land, was granted an eviction order by the Western Cape High Court earlier this year.

Western Cape police said 10 people had been arrested for alleged public violence since the evictions began, with petrol bombs thrown and tyres set alight.

The human settlements department said on Wednesday, that the ministers said that if the city and Sanral could not find a solution they should have gone to the provincial and national government for "mediation and guidance".

Sisulu said that in consultation with Peters, the illegal occupiers will settle temporarily while government can assist to find a solution.

"We must be very clear, we do not encourage illegal occupation of land, it is the inhumane way in which children and women are being removed during winter that we are concern about, the people will have to move out of the land when necessary arrangements are made," Sisulu said.

Earlier on Tuesday, the municipality's human settlements MMC Siyabulela Mamkeli said the city had repeatedly urged Sanral to protect their land against the continual land invasions.

On Tuesday, transport department spokesman Tiyani Ponto-Rikhotso said the City of Cape Town should shoulder responsibility for the events that led to the evictions.

- Sapa

Tuesday, June 3, 2014

Sanral blames City for evictions

Cape Town - Cape Town City could have avoided the eviction of shack dwellers in Lwandle settlement, Sanral said on Tuesday.

“This situation might not have arisen if the city did not walk away from the discussions with Sanral to find an amicable solution to the issue,” Sanral spokesman Vusi Mona said in a statement.

He said the city abdicated responsibility towards residents of Lwandle, outside Somerset West.

“Despite the city's efforts to put the blame on Sanral, the agency's offer to donate land to Cape Town remains open,” Mona said.

“We call on the city to rescind its decision and restart the process to find a workable solution that will benefit the poor communities affected by recent events.”

The eviction of shack dwellers began on Monday and continued into Tuesday.

The SA National Roads Agency Limited, the owner of the land, was granted an eviction order by the Western Cape High Court earlier this year.

Western Cape police said 10 people had been arrested for alleged public violence since the evictions began, with petrol bombs thrown and tyres set alight.

Mona said Sanral had been engaging with the city since 2003 to relocate the occupants living in the road reserve to alternative accommodation or serviced sites.

“The deliberate inaction of the city brought this process to an abrupt end.

“This caused further invasion of the land. Sanral eventually had no other option to apply for a High Court Order to prevent further land invasions.”

Earlier, the city's human settlements MMC Siyabulela Mamkeli said those evicted would be given short-term shelter.

“The city cannot incentivise illegal land invasion by providing alternative accommodation, as we have a duty to protect the rights of those people who are on the housing waiting list,” Mamkeli said in a statement.

“However, as part of our commitment to being a caring city, the City of Cape Town has decided to make available community facilities to those people affected by Sanral's legal action.”

Transport Minister Dipuo Peters and Human Settlements Minister Lindiwe Sisulu were expected to visit the site of the evictions on Tuesday.

- Sapa

Ministers to visit Sanral evictions site

Cape Town - Transport Minister Dipuo Peters and Human Settlements Minister Lindiwe Sisulu were to visit the scene of evictions at Lwandle near Strand in the Western Cape on Tuesday.

“The ministers have expressed concern over the humanitarian situation caused by the evictions,” transport department spokesman Tiyani Ponto-Rikhotso said in a statement.

“They 1/8ministers 3/8 will this afternoon meet with the leadership of the community to find solutions to the current challenges.”

The eviction of shack dwellers began on Monday and continued into Tuesday.

The SA National Roads Agency Limited (Sanral), the owner of the land, was granted an eviction order by the Western Cape High Court earlier this year.

Western Cape police said 10 people had been arrested for alleged public violence since the evictions began, with petrol bombs thrown and tyres set alight.

Ponto-Rikhotso said the City of Cape Town should shoulder responsibility for the events that led to the evictions.

“Sanral has clear evidence that the city prevented the acquisition of an alternative piece of land for the relocation of communities living inside the N2 road reserve,” he said.

“It is obvious that they used the issue of toll-roads in the Western Cape as an excuse to terminate discussions on the issue.”

He said Sanral had been engaging with the city since 2003 to relocate the shack dwellers to alternative accommodation.

“The inaction of the city brought this process to an abrupt end, and Sanral eventually had no other option to apply for a High Court order to prevent further land invasion.”

Ponto-Rikhotso said the order was granted on January 24 and Sanral started with the enforcement of the order on February 19.

Earlier, the municipality's human settlements MMC Siyabulela Mamkeli said the city had repeatedly urged Sanral to protect their land against the continual land invasions.

“As the land in question is owned by Sanral, the city has not been responsible for policing these informal settlements,” Mamkeli said.

“As the settlements are on Sanral land, the city may not provide services without the consent of the landowner, which in this case is Sanral.”

Sanral had appointed a private company to ensure the settlement did not grow further, but new structures continued to be built on the Sanral land, said the MMC.

- Sapa

Temporary shelter for Sanral evictees

Cape Town - People evicted from Sanral-owned land at Lwandle, outside Cape Town, would be given short-term shelter, the City said on Tuesday.

“The City cannot incentivise illegal land invasion by providing alternative accommodation, as we have a duty to protect the rights of those people who are on the housing waiting list,” human settlements MMC Siyabulela Mamkeli said in a statement.

“However, as part of our commitment to being a caring city, the City of Cape Town has decided to make available community facilities to those people affected by Sanral's legal action.”

Three community facilities would be made available for a maximum period of one week.

This would ensure that with the onset of cold weather, those affected by the evictions would be sheltered while they made alternative arrangements.

Violence ensued on Monday following the enforcement of an eviction order.

It was granted to the SA National Roads Agency Limited (Sanral), owner of the land, by the Western Cape High Court earlier this year.

Lt-Col Andre Traut said three people had been arrested on Tuesday for public violence during the evictions, with the situation having cleared since the morning.

Earlier in the day, petrol bombs were thrown and tyres set alight and the situation was described by Traut as “tense”.

“We are policing the eviction notice being carried out by the sheriff of the court,” Traut said at the time.

Another seven people were arrested on Monday for public violence, and three petrol bombs confiscated.

Mamkeli said it appeared many of those affected by the evictions were young people from backyards, and it was likely they could return to their families or find other alternatives.

“The City is making this undertaking as a last resort and out of a humanitarian concern,” the MMC said.

“We will engage with Sanral to find a more long-term solution.”

- Sapa

Three held for Lwandle protest violence

Cape Town - Three people were arrested for public violence on Tuesday during evictions in Lwandle, outside Cape Town, Western Cape police said.

“Three people have been arrested because of alleged public violence. The situation has cleared since this morning ... and the situation is quiet at this stage,” said Lt-Col Andre Traut.

Earlier in the day, petrol bombs were thrown and tyres set alight and the situation described as “tense”.

“We are policing the eviction notice being carried out by the sheriff of the court,” Traut said at the time.

Another seven people were arrested on Monday for public violence, and three petrol bombs confiscated.

The violence began on Monday following the enforcement of an eviction order.

It was granted to the SA National Roads Agency Limited (Sanral), owner of the land, by the Western Cape High Court earlier this year.

Democratic Alliance national spokeswoman Phumzile van Damme said the African National Congress blaming the DA for the evictions was nothing short of cheap and petty politicking.

“It is entirely disingenuous and in no way accurate,” she said in a statement.

“Yesterday (Monday), SA National Roads Agency Limited (Sanral), a national state entity, through the Sheriff of the Court enforced an interdict against people occupying land owned by it.”

She said responsibility for the evictions lay squarely with Sanral and the national transport department, who sought the court interdict themselves and who owned the land in question.

Earlier, ANC national spokesman Zizi Kodwa claimed the eviction was punishment for the community not voting for the DA in the May 7 general elections.

“The ANC condemns the eviction... by the Cape Town metro without being given alternative accommodation as required by the law,” he said in a statement.

“This is tantamount to undermining democracy and the freedom of choice by the DA metro.”

Van Damme said beyond Sanral and the transport department being responsible for the evictions, Transport Minister Dipuo Peters was nowhere to be seen, as her department remained silent on the issue.

“Both Sanral and the department must answer for their unwillingness to take reasonable steps to ensure that the eviction occurs in a manner that does not rob people of their security and dignity,” she said.

“As such, the ANC would do well to familiarise themselves with the facts of this issue and redirect their condemnation to the national government - which they have just been elected to govern.”

Kodwa said the ANC had asked the national transport and human settlements departments to intervene.

Congress of SA Trade Unions provincial secretary Tony Ehrenreich said it was outraged by the treatment of those who built their homes on the Sanral land.

“The police are clearly guilty of abuse in the manner in which people have been treated during this eviction operation,” he said in a statement.

People should be given alternate land to build their houses on, in the event of them having to move off land for whatever legitimate reason.

“Where do the authorities expect people to go when there are no alternatives for them, and this in the middle of winter?” he said.

- Sapa

Petrol bombs fly in Lwandle evictions

Cape Town - Petrol bombs were thrown during evictions in Lwandle, outside Cape Town, on Tuesday, Western Cape police said.

“Petrol bombs are being thrown, tyres are being lit and the situation is tense at this stage, but police are maintaining law and order. The eviction operation is unfolding at this time,” Lt-Col Andre Traut said.

“We are policing the eviction notice being carried out by the sheriff of the court.”

No arrests had been made.

On Monday seven people were arrested for public violence.

“Three petrol bombs were confiscated. The suspects will make a court appearance once they have been charged. They are currently in police custody as they go through processing,” Traut said.

Earlier on Tuesday, the ANC claimed the eviction was punishment for people not voting for the DA in the May 7 general elections.

“The African National Congress condemns the eviction... by the Cape Town metro without being given alternative accommodation as required by the law,” spokesman Zizi Kodwa said in a statement.

“This is tantamount to undermining democracy and the freedom of choice by the DA metro.”

The violence began on Monday following the enforcement of an eviction order. It was granted to the SA National Roads Agency Limited (Sanral), owner of the land, by the Western Cape High Court earlier this year.

City of Cape Town human settlements MMC Siyabulela Mamkeli said in a statement on Monday: “The interdict authorised the sheriff and the South African Police Service to give effect to the provisions of this order.”

This was against any person or structure erected that breached the order after it was served.

“The sheriff of the court has been assisted by its contractors to remove the structures following an illegal land invasion on this Sanral-owned land,” said Mamkeli.

Kodwa said the ANC had asked the national transport and human settlements departments to intervene.

Mamkeli said police supported the sheriff of the court's actions.

“City law enforcement agencies were present, on the specific request from the sheriff of the court and the SAPS. City law enforcement has no role in the removal of structures.” 

- Sapa

‘We can’t stop the water from coming in’

Cape Town - They may be veterans of Western Cape winters, but the cold, rain and frequent flooding is something the Tununu family could do without.

Their two-roomed shack in Brown’s Farm in Philippi is full of reminders of valuables damaged in winters past.

They are among the thousands of families who are battening down the hatches this week as a severe cold front heads towards us.

The narrow pathways around the home of Thandi Tununu, 23, and her family are already under water from the weekend rain, prompting residents to don their wellies.

“When it rains a lot this is not a good place to be,” said Tununu, looking miserably around the home she shares with her mother, twin sister and her sister’s three young children.

“There is nothing we can do to stop the water from coming into our homes here. We do what we can to try and save our belongings from being damaged by the water, but at the end of the day it’s always too late.”

The beds have already been placed on top of crates in anticipation of water coming in. The wardrobe is rotting away from being exposed to damp conditions and is barely upright. In the kitchen, Tununu and her mother have attached steel covers to the bottom of kitchen cupboards to try to protect them.

When there is a heavy downpour, they will throw loose sand inside and around their shack to soak up excess water.

“This is all we can do. We have been staying here for 10 years and every winter we have to deal with this problem. Nothing can stop the water from coming in. We sleep with water around us. It is difficult because the water brings the cold with it.

“There is not even a protective covering on our roof to stop the water from seeping through because it is too expensive.

“Also, the water on the ground is not clean. It mixes with the sewage from the drains around us and it is causing the children around here to get sick.”

Tununu showed the Cape Argus some of her nephew’s ailments caused by exposure to toxic sludge. Three-year-old Emihle Tununu’s arms and legs are covered in sores. He was given creams at the clinic.

“We cannot live like this. The government needs to do something to stop the flooding permanently or provide us with houses. They give us food parcels and blankets when we are hit with storms. What does that do? The blankets won’t make the water go away and the food doesn’t last.”

Families across the city will also look for a variety of ways to keep warm this week, which has its own dangers attached to it. Four people, including two children, died in shack or backyard fires at the weekend.

The city’s Disaster Risk Management has called on residents to take care when using candles and paraffin stoves.

Meanwhile City of Cape Town departments have been hard at work to get their winter readiness programme organised in time to help prevent flooding.

There is a particular focus on poorer areas, often the most severely affected.

The Disaster Risk Management Centre will ensure that all rescue and disaster assistance agencies are on standby. They also have an early-warning system in place so that the city has as much time as possible to prevent disasters.

In the past month, residents have been given tips on how to raise floor levels, divert flood waters, and reduce the health hazards associated with stagnant water.

The Human Settlements Directorate also has plans to reduce the impact of the inevitable winter storms and flooding.

It is asking residents to contact the city’s call centre for sandbags to keep water out. Flood kits will be distributed where flooding has been severe.

Solid Waste Management is clearing stormwater drains to prevent blockages.

Social Development and Early Childhood Development will provide aid in the form of food, blankets and toiletries to those affected by winter weather around the city. The city’s field workers are also able to help people who need emergency accommodation, social work services, and rehabilitation services by directing them to one of the city-wide assessment centres.

The city can be reached at 0860 103 089.

For all life- or property-threatening emergencies, call 107 from a landline, or 021 480 7700 from a cellphone.

Disaster Risk Management says people can donate food or blankets at their nearest fire stations.

Spokesman Wilfred Solomons-Johannes said there were 30 fire stations in the city.

People can also call the Disaster Risk Management centre on 0809 114 357.

Food or blankets can also be donated to:

* The Haven night shelter for homeless people in Claremont, Green Point, Woodstock and Retreat can be contacted on 021 425 4700.

* The Ark night shelter in Somerset West on 021 855 2329 or U-turn, an organisation assisting homeless people, on 021 674 6119.

warren.fortune@inl.co.za

Evicted with boots and rubber bullets

Cape Town - Images reminiscent of a war zone have elicited outrage from South Africans, as a shack demolition unfolded near the Strand.


Social media took the unfolding drama viral as black smoke billowed in the sky, rubber bullets rebounded off the tarmac and stun grenades echoed in the streets of Nomzamo, adjacent to the historic hostel township of Lwandle.

An eviction five months in the making was met with fury as a court-appointed sheriff rolled into Lwandle on Monday to flatten shacks built on land designated for the rerouting of the N2.

Residents and police clashed. Rocks were thrown, rubber bullets shot, small fires lit in the street and stun grenades lobbed into the crowds.

But as the skirmish progressed, the crowds began to thin out, the last rioters were tackled to the ground, their faces wet with yellow pepper spray.

Seven men were arrested for public violence, police spokesman Lieutenant-Colonel Andre Traut said, and three petrol bombs were confiscated.

“They will appear in court where they will be officially charged.”

But the sight of now homeless residents on a damp winter day – especially women with children – prompted fury among many South Africans. One tweeted that the scenes were “another demonstration of SA’s contempt for the poor”.

Another protested: “As if people choose to be poor!”

And: “I cannot believe the apartheid-style shack demolitions.”

Social commentator Rebecca Davis described as heartbreaking the images of residents pleading for their shacks not to be demolished.

Western Cape Premier Helen Zille tweeted: “Neither the province nor the city received prior notice of this eviction. Sanral and the national minister must provide answers.”

By late in the afternoon, peace had returned, but many residents were left to pick up the pieces of their homes, salvaging what they could before they were flattened.

The contested site is home to perhaps 150 shack dwellings, but only about 20 were destroyed in Monday’s enforcement of the court order obtained by landowner Sanral.

With more shacks set to be taken apart later, residents were in a race against time to find a place to stay as temperatures dropped in the township on Monday night.

The SA Roads Agency (Sanral), which owns the land, said it had applied for a court interdict preventing any invasion on the property in January after the first set of shacks had been unlawfully erected.

“The court order was contravened on numerous occasions, forcing us to obtain the services of the sheriff and members of the police to evict the illegal invaders on the property,” spokesman Vusi Mona said.

Mona said the violence was regrettable. But, according to the company, the evictions were for the greater good since the land would allow it to maintain the roads through the rerouting of the N2 highway, as per the agency’s mandate.

Later on Monday, the City of Cape Town explained it was not involved, and detailed the history of the saga.

Mayoral committee member for human settlements Siyabulela Mamkeli said city law enforcement agencies were present, “on the specific request from the sheriff of the court and the police”.

But, “this particular case involves a private eviction – from Sanral land, not public, city-owned land – thus city law enforcement has no role in the removal of structures”.

However, the city had repeatedly urged Sanral to protect its land against the continual and new land invasions.

“As the land in question is privately owned, by Sanral, the city has not been responsible for policing these informal settlements. Sanral appointed a private company to ensure that no further growth of the settlements takes place, but new structures have continued to be built on the Sanral-owned land,” said Mamkeli.

Also, because the settlements were on private land, the city could not provide services without the consent of the land owner.

“Previously, as part of our commitment to building a caring city, the city offered to provide a certain number of container toilets in the settlements, which Sanral allowed. These toilets have unfortunately been vandalised and damaged beyond repair.

“The ward councillors requested that the city provide additional services. The city has, in an effort to provide services and interim relief to these residents, provided services on the periphery of city-owned land, adjacent to Sanral’s property,” Mamkeli said.

Amid the chaos of Monday morning, individual stories of vulnerability surfaced – like that of Simanyene High Grade 12 pupil Anelise Mange, 17, who returned from school to try to rescue her family’s entire household. With urgency, yet calm, she threw each item out through their front door, before loading herself up and hurling the contents to safety on the far side of a roll of razorwire.

Last came her study notes.

“I’m meant to be writing exams,” she said quietly.

In the end, the demolition teams pulled out without touching her home – only those of many of her neighbours – for reasons still unclear to residents.

Another resident Ntombikhona Somni’s hands were filthy as she scratched through the wreck of her demolished home. She eventually found what she was looking for – her three-year-old child Iminathi’s little soccer shoes.

Rain had turned the plot where her home had stood on Monday morning to mud. As she fled from the chilly north-westerly wind and rain, she dragged a dirty plastic container carrying her only possessions.

“I don’t know where we are going to sleep tonight.”

At sunset, the air was filled with the relentless tap of hammers on nails, as men banded together to work on each others’ homes.

Nomkita Tlale worked frantically to rebuild her shack as darkness fell. Her 10-month-old daughter Pinky sat under a makeshift shelter not far away, exposed to the weather.

Sanral, a court and perhaps even the constitution may all be telling her the home is illegal.

But it’s the only one she and her infant have.

Monday, June 2, 2014

EFF calls for Nkandla ad-hoc committee revival

Economic Freedom Fighters leader, Julius Malema, says his party will support the re-establishment of an ad-hoc committee on Nkandla.

He has addressed journalists in Parliament on Sunday.

Shortly before the national elections last month, Parliament established an ad-hoc committee to deal with the findings of Public Protector Thuli Madonsela on the multi-million-rand upgrades at the private home of President Jacob Zuma.

The committee never got off the ground, due to the fourth Parliament which was ending as the country went to the polls.

Opposition parties in Parliament have already called for the re-establishment of the committee.

Malema says they won’t retreat until the committee is re-established.

“We want the ad-hoc committee on Nkandla. We won’t retreat. We want reports and President Zuma must be held accountable for resources misused. We support the Public Protector. Parliament must still debate the Nkandla report.”

Meanwhile, Malema says his party will table a motion in Parliament that all public representatives should by law be required to use public facilities, such as hospitals, schools and transport.

The party has 25 seats in the National Assembly and six in the National Council of Provinces.

Malema says forcing MPs, ministers and MECs to use public facilities, will improve the quality of services.

“Let all of us make use public hospitals and schools - we will put that motion…we want schools and hospitals upgraded. They won’t be upgraded if leadership is not using it.”

- SABC

Study to probe shebeens and crime link

Cape Town - With hundreds of illegal shebeens mushrooming in Khayelitsha, the burden on law enforcement has sparked an in-depth study into the links between heavy drinking and crime.

“It is generally assumed that there is a link between alcohol consumption and crime,” chief executive officer of the Western Cape Liquor Board Thys Giliomee said.

“However, there has never been in-depth, credible, subject specific research conducted to prove this.”

Giliomee said that the liquor board would commission the study this year.

Police spokesman Lieutenant-Colonel Andre Traut said that police were often called out to attend to crimes that occurred at or near shebeens.

He said shebeens contributed to crime in areas such as Khayelitsha, many parts of the Cape Flats, Nyanga and Delft, as people drank too much and were then involved in fights and violent crimes, including rape, murder and attempted murder.

Last October, five people were shot dead and three were wounded when a man opened fire in a popular shebeen known as Emaplangeni at Ilitha Park in Khayelitsha.

The gunman allegedly had an argument with a fellow patron over spilt alcohol.

“Shebeens in informal settlements are difficult to identify because many of them sell liquor on a small scale and are hidden in the settlement and cannot be viewed from the outside,” Traut said.

Khayelitsha and Nyanga were the most problematic clusters, he added.

According to last year’s national crime statistics, Khayelitsha is second in the Western Cape’s worst 10 precincts with 168 contact crimes (crimes against a person).

Nyanga is in first place with 262.

Giliomee said that records showed there were 134 licensed liquor outlets in the larger geographical area of Khayelitsha.

However, evidence emerged at the Khayelitsha commission of inquiry last month that there were about 1 400 unlicensed shebeens in the township.

The commission was established in August 2012 to investigate alleged police inefficiency in Khayelitsha. Giliomee was one of those who testified.

“Illegal trading in liquor is a very complex problem. There are many factors that contribute to this problem and therefore enforcement alone will not solve this problem,” he said.

“The factors include poverty and unemployment. An alternative to the unlicensed liquor outlets, in the form of licensed liquor outlets, is required if we are to have any success with the enforcement in respect of unlicensed outlets.”

Giliomee said the process that needed to be followed to revoke a liquor licence was “very onerous and similar to that of a criminal matter”.

“Enforcement of unlicensed liquor outlets are done by SAPS and we do assist them when requested to do so,” he said.

There were only seven liquor inspectors serving the entire Western Cape.

“Joint operations are vital in the enforcement of the Western Cape Liquor Act and other applicable acts, and as such these operations can in many instances only be performed with the co-operation of SAPS. SAPS has to perform a much bigger crime- prevention role with limited resources, of which liquor enforcement is only one,” Giliomee said.

Welcome Makele, a Khayelitsha community support officer of the Social Justice Coalition, said shootings and fights that resulted in stabbings were a regular occurrence at the township’s drinking holes, especially over weekends. He estimated that there was a shebeen in almost every fifth house in the area.

“Most people don’t even know how to go about obtaining a liquor licence, the most important thing for them is putting food on the table,” Makele said.

The Cape Argus visited several unlicensed and licensed shebeens in Khayelitsha sites B and C.

Several owners of illegal shebeens, who asked not to be named in fear of prosecution, said they would go hungry if they followed the legal route.

A 31-year-old illegal shebeen owner said she had been forced to drop out of university to run the family’s shebeen when her parents, who are pensioners, became too sickly.

She lives in an informal settlement in Site B. The mother-of-three runs the shebeen from the back of her two-roomed shack.

When the Cape Argus visited, her children were watching a movie in the living room, while the other side of the dimly lit room was used for the sale of alcoholic beverages and as a seating area for patrons.

The woman said she had tried several times to legalise her shebeen and had even spent R6 000 on a lawyer who absconded with her money. She then gave up.

“Police come here all the time… about three times a month. They were here last week. And they take all the alcohol they can find. We lose a lot of money because of that. Each time you start afresh.

“They must make it easier for us to get a licence. It’s not that we are not trying, the process is too long and in the meantime, we have to make a living, just like everyone else,” she said.

“I feel the police are also taking advantage of us. They know we are uneducated and don’t really know our rights, so they come here and do as they please.

“They don’t speak properly to us. Sometimes they take our alcohol and sometimes they take you to the police station.

“Clearly shebeens are not going to go away. They need to come up with a better solution for us to run our businesses.”

Another owner of an illegal shebeen in Khayelitsha’s Site C said getting a liquor licence was “tough business”.

He said he has been trying to get one since the late 1990s.

“One of the requirements is that you have to have a proper structure before you apply. And how exactly is one supposed to fund this structure if you are not working?”

However, builders were hard at work on his shebeen last week.

“The police come here all the time to raid my place and I have paid the R1 500 admission of guilt several times,” he said.

“When police do their raids they come here with trucks and several vans, as if we are criminals. Serious crime is escalating in the area but then they are nowhere to be found.

“We had shebeens during the apartheid days and we will continue to have them in a democratic South Africa. They demolish one shebeen and five more will pop up around it. The demand is there and it’s growing.”

Some illegal shebeen owners admitted that there were regular fights at the shebeens, but claimed they were “usually not extreme”.

“We are not the only problem here,” said one.

“Closing shebeens while retailers selling liquor in the townships are growing is not helping. Retailers are cheaper than us; people come to us already drunk from drinking their (retailers’) booze at home.”

‘Getting my licence was like Mandela’s Long Walk to Freedom’

Getrude Quta of Nomnqwamzo Corner, a tavern in Site B, wanted to open a place for people to socialise over a drink in the township in the early 1990s to spare them a trek to the city.

“People had no place to sit and drink, alcohol was in demand and still is… this is why the shebeens are growing,” she said.

She likened getting a business licence to Mandela’s Long Walk to Freedom.

Her tavern is a double storey built over two sites. Downstairs is a bottle store and upstairs is a sitting area.

“I had to follow a long route which included a lot of documents and paying a lawyer to handle the process for me,” she said

Her annual licence costs R6 000.

“Some people start little by little and others are battling as owning a proper shebeen is expensive.

“The police raids are not a solution and are only making people go hungry and result in desperate measures to try to make a living,” she said.

Quta, 54, pictured right, said some people bought a case of beer from her bottle store and sold it at a marked-up price to earn a few rands.

She said that patrons had fought in the tavern and a shooting had occurred two years ago. She now has tighter security.

How to apply for a liquor licence

With the Western Cape Liquor Authority at their offices on the 6th Floor of the NBS Waldorf Building, 80 St George’s Mall, Cape Town and with the Designated SAPS Liquor Officer in whose area of jurisdiction the business is located.

Who may not apply for a liquor licence?

* Someone who has, within five years prior to the lodgement of the application, been sentenced to imprisonment without the option of paying a fine.

* Someone who has, within five years prior to the lodgement of the application, been declared to be unfit to hold a liquor licence.

* Somebody who was the holder of any liquor licence which was cancelled within a period of 12 months prior to the lodgement of the application.

* Somebody who is an unrehabilitated insolvent.

Where and when are applications lodged?

Through a lawyer or liquor consultant, or in your personal capacity. The different application forms are available from the Western Cape Liquor Regulations document. See http://www.westerncape.gov.za/service/liquor-licence-applications

Minister warns on fire risk for kids

Cape Town - More would be done to protect children falling prey to violence, particularly in communities where abuse, neglect and rape were rife, said Minister of Social Development Bathabile Dlamini.

She visited Delft on Sunday – the launch site of this year’s Child Protection Week which is commemorated annually to raise awareness of the rights of children.

Dlamini said that this week her department would evaluate the work of institutions which protected children and also look at new problems which emerged as a result of a changing society.

“We have tabled a White Paper on families which puts forward proposals on how South African families should be supported in order to flourish and function optimally. The paper views family as a key development imperative and seeks to mainstream family issues into government-wide policy initiatives,” she said.

On Friday – two days before the start of CPW – two children living in a backyard dwelling in Delft died in a fire which destroyed their shack.

The children, Alfonzo Solomon, 6, and his brother Marshall, 5, were left unattended by their grandmother who went to buy food.

Visiting the site on Sunday, Dlamini said the children might have survived the fire if they had not been left alone.

“Reports about the fire shows a lack of a support system for both the children and the grandmother. Had a proper family support system been in place, there would have been no need to leave the children locked up and unattended, and they might have survived the fire,” said Dlamini.

The boys’ grandmother and foster mother, Elaine Steneberg, wept as she recalled details about the night she left the boys at home.

Their mother, Steneberg said, was a substance abuser who had never been there for the children.

“I have looked after them since they were babies,” she said. “On Friday, they went to sleep early and I decided to collect a food parcel, just down the road.

“When I was being served at the counter, the neighbour ran to me and told me my house was on fire.”

Steneberg and Solomon were staying at their church pastor’s home until she was able to get back on her feet.

Dlamini said households headed by grandparents were an increasing trend in South Africa, and the trend could be avoided.

On Sunday, she offered to help get Steneberg’s daughter into a counselling programme.

“I want to urge people not to leave their children alone. It is unfortunate that such young lives had to be lost this way. Our thoughts are with the family,” Dlamini said.

francesca.villette@inl.co.za

Saturday, May 31, 2014

Long wait for ‘shoddy’ new homes

Cape Town - After more than 20 years on a waiting list for houses, residents from various informal settlements finally received new homes in Pelican Park, near Grassy Park – but many are bitterly disappointed at “shoddy workmanship”.

They complain of uneven floors, skew walls, poor ventilation and cheap alternative materials used in the building.

Winnie Poggenpoel, said her family had moved into their new house only three months ago. But the only difference between the house and their old shack was that they could no longer hear the rain like they did while living in Zille-Raine Heights in Parkwood.

“When we were staying in Zille-Raine Heights we were happy there. I was on the housing waiting list for 22 years and when I got the letter to say I qualify for this house, I was thrilled because I would finally have a place to call my own. I don’t want to sound ungrateful but this is not the standard of housing I expected.”

Poggenpoel lives in the two-bedroom house with her family of six. She says they’re not able to make any alterations because they rely on government grants for an income.

Her neighbour Yahgia Amaldien, who has worked previously in construction, said the houses were being built way too fast, and that the exterior walls had not been properly plastered.

“The walls look like they’re plastered on the outside, but when it rains the inside still gets wet. Besides the plastering, the ventilation is also not right, and in the bathroom there is a pipe which isn’t long enough, so they used a piece of plastic to make it longer.”

Amaldien said he and his family moved in three weeks ago. The only good thing was they now had electricity.

Paul Johnson, who also lived in Zille-Raine Heights, has been in his new house for five weeks.

He pointed to a number of problems, including doors too big for their frames.

“I am a pensioner and I cannot be fixing these things. I have made complaints to the company and they said they will get back to me, but so far I haven’t heard anything.”

Power Construction built the homes, and when approached for comment, spokesman Bongani Mgayi said they were aware of some of the complaints.

If residents reported complaints via the correct channels which had been made available, the company could respond to them properly.

yolisa.tswanya@inl.co.za

Two boys die in Delft fire

Cape Town - Two boys died after a fire broke out in a homestead in Delft, Cape Town's disaster risk management centre said on Saturday.

“Two boys aged five and six died in the fire. It is not yet known what caused the fire,” said spokesman Wilfred Solomons-Johannes.

The fire destroyed two backyard dwellings in Fort Worth Street in Delft on Friday night.

Police have opened an inquest docket, Solomons-Johannes said. - Sapa