Tuesday, October 27, 2009

City takes residents to court

The Western Cape Housing Department is taking the Mandela Park resident in Khayelitsha to court.

The department is claiming that the residents have illegally occupied the houses for the past three years.

Housing Minister in the Western Cape Bonginkosi Madikizela says the department will not tolerate disruption of the system from unruly people.

“We went to court to apply for eviction order because we can not allow the situation where the people can just occupy the houses they do not belong to them,”said the Minister.

Madikizela adds that the actually houses beneficiaries are now victims of the invaders.

“It is not far for the people who their houses were invaded three years ago,” added Madikizela.

Meanwhile, the residents are saying their worst nightmares are once again revealed.

Spokesperson for the Mandela Park Backyarders Mabhuti Matyida says the people are being evicted and a lot are being served with eviction letters.

“People who do not have the title deeds are being chased away from the houses to the streets,” said Matyida.

The matter will be heard in the Cape High Court tomorrow. - Bush Radio

Monday, October 26, 2009

Philippi marchers demand the basics

Frustrated Brown's Farm community leaders and Cape Town city councillors meet this week to discuss service delivery problems after protests this weekend led to clashes with police officers.
Residents of the Philippi informal settlement, frustrated with a lack of basic services, blocked two roads with burning tyres, rubbish skips, portable toilets and rocks.

"We don't have electricity, we don't have water, we don't have toilets, we don't have houses," said community leader Ntlala Kamteni.

He said residents had arranged to meet local councillor Moses Baskiti on Sunday morning but he had not been able to provide answers about when they would be provided with housing and services.

"The land there is privately owned; the city is still negotiating with the owner to buy the land. I had a meeting with them, explained this to them and said the city would get back to them," Baskiti said.

The follow-up meeting is scheduled for Thursday.
Angry and frustrated community members blockaded the road to show how "desperate" they were, but Baskiti said he explained to them this would not solve the problem or change the situation.

Kamteni said: "When we talk, they do nothing. We left there peacefully but the police opened fire on us. The police shot many people."

Police fired rubber bullets into the crowd to disperse the protesting community members. One of the people caught in the crossfire, Colin Mdlutha, was shot in the leg.

"We didn't do anything. We were just standing here. The police just came to shoot us," he said as he rolled up his trouser to show the bleeding wound.

Said police spokesperson Ntomboxolo Sitshitshi: "Officers had to shoot rubber bullets to control the people, because they were uncontrollable. They were damaging the toilets."

She said police officers had not injured anyone during the shooting.

Residents gathered amid rubbish and toilets turned onto its sides in the closed road on Sunday afternoon to discuss their grievances.

"We want to complain to Zuma. We voted for him - he can give us houses, he can give us electricity. This is the first time we are doing this, now we are sick and tired," said Nokuzola Magazi.

- The Cape Times

Sunday, October 25, 2009

Cape Town hiding the homeless for the World Cup

Cape Town is keeping it's street children out of sight and out of mind for Soccer World Cup in 2010 with the children undergoing (COMPULSORY?) performing arts training.

Under Cape Town's Second Chance initiative, street children will undergo performing arts training from groups including the Zip Zap Circus School and the Cape Dance Company.

"This is one of many programmes we have designed to break the cycle of poverty among street children in Cape Town," said Mansoor Mohamed, executive director for economic, social development and tourism in Cape Town.

He said the project would run throughout the year and be "accelerated" during the World Cup.

In addition, tourists in the Mother City would be discouraged from dishing out cash to beggars.

Instead, Cape Town was developing a programme allowing tourists to buy food or shelter vouchers to hand these out to the needy instead of cash.

Cape Town's chief of special law enforcement services, Rudolph Wiltshire, said 170 new seasonal law enforcement officers would be appointed next month. They would undergo "sensitivity training programmes" to help reintegrate street people back into their communities and their families. He said they had already successfully reintegrated 30 people. - The Sunday Times

"At least Cape Town's homeless kids can dance!"??? WTF!!!????

Friday, October 23, 2009

Paraffin stove accident burns down half a house in Langa

When will the carnage end? Paraffin fire claims house in Langa. "Keep the stove alive all the time the child was told...." The paraffin ran out.. and the petrol ran in. In the subsequent blaze half the family home burnt down.... No insurance means that the road back will be long and hard. The fire has been traumatic for everyone, especially the kids.

400 displaced by CT fire

Cape Town - About 400 informal dwellers have been displaced by a fire in the Du Noon / Doornbach settlement at Milnerton in Cape Town, the SABC reported on Friday.

Cape Town Fire said the residents were taken in by family and friends after 100 wood-and-iron structures were gutted on Thursday night.

No one was hurt during the fire, the cause of which is unknown at this stage. - SAPA

World Zero Evictions Days 2009

On the occasion of World Habitat Day 2009 celebrated by the UN-Habitat with the motto “Planning our urban future”, the International Alliance of Inhabitants, the world-wide network for housing rights with no frontiers, has issued a critical communiqué launching the World Zero Evictions Days to support resistances and alternatives for participating cities, a concrete foundation for a new Urban Social Pact.

At its heart: the demand for a world-wide moratorium to evictions; and funding for housing and habitat in a “New Green Deal” for at least a billion people. This funding would be based, among others, on the investment of an important part of developmental aid as well as on the annulment of external debt, transformed into a Popular Fund for land and housing. This is the concrete enactment of the agreements made by all international networks for housing and city rights at the WSF 2009, the next step in the unifying process of building the World Assembly of Inhabitants on 2011.

Please follow all links and pictures
Resistances and alternatives for participating cities

Thursday, October 22, 2009

'Delivery protests are our right'

Groups representing impoverished Cape Town communities have lashed out at President Jacob Zuma's warning that the government will not tolerate violent service delivery protests, and the accompanying destruction of property.

Representatives of the Joe Slovo task team, the Landless People's Movement and Abahlali baseMjondolo defended these protests, saying they were the only way to get the government to pay attention.

"So-called democratic grievance routes," failed to get answers, they said.

Zuma's comments came yesterday during his address to most of South Africa's 283 mayors and all its premiers. He told them there was "no cause in a democratic and free society, however legitimate, that justifies the wanton destruction of property and violence" that had been witnessed in the country.

"South Africa has a proud history of protest against wrong-doing and injustice," Zuma said.

"There is no institution or individual that our people cannot stand up to and challenge if they think an injustice has been committed."

But the three organisations, which form part of the national Poor People's Alliance, said Zuma's words were nothing new.

"We are not surprised by what he is saying. We have heard these statements in the past that government will not tolerate these protests," said Mzwanele Zulu of the Joe Slovo task team.

He accused the ANC government of forever "duplicating and assimilating" practices of the apartheid government.

"What is happening is our leaders are turning against us when they are in power. We are becoming foreigners in our land of birth," he said.

Zulu argued that burning tyres as a sign of dissatisfaction was not a violent means of expression, and said the only reason it was done was in an attempt to engage government authorities, something which did not happen when they tried the legitimate channels.

Maureen Mnisi of the Landless People's Movement, said government departments had done "a lot of ignoring".

"People submit memoranda over a lack of service delivery, but there is no reply. People don't deliver," she said.

"To demonstrate on the street is part of the process. The government has to recognise that. If they can't tolerate (such) actions, they have to provide services," Mnisi said.

Mzonke Poni of Abahlali said that if South Africa were a democracy, "then democracy was supposed to have been able to improve these appalling conditions people are living under".

He said the inability to access essential services was also a form of violence.

"It is reactionary of him (Zuma) to say this. The ANC government has failed to deliver services to the poorest of the poor, and they have tried in the past to shift the blame for service delivery failures."

Poni said people viewed taking to the streets as legitimately exercising their right to freedom of expression.

Meanwhile, Minister in the Presidency Collins Chabane said yesterday that the face of local government was set to change, in an effort to improve service delivery at municipal level.

He said there was a need for reform in the local government regulatory framework, and that the relationships between the spheres of government needed to be optimised to speed up delivery and ensure efficiency.

Chabane, speaking after Zuma's indaba yesterday, said several processes aimed at local government reform would start from today.

- Cape Argus

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Single election to cure woes

The idea of a single election will be discussed at a local government meeting in Boksburg, Co-operative Governance and Traditional Affairs Minister Sicelo Shiceka said on Wednesday.

This year national and provincial government elections were held in April, while local government elections are scheduled for 2011.

"This matter was raised by the people on the ground... They believe we must be able to align and simplify our system of government," Shiceka said.

The idea would be put to the delegates at the indaba and would then go to the various levels of government for further discussion.

Watershed meeting

Shiceka described the indaba as a "watershed meeting" aimed at answering the questions raised by President Jacob Zuma regarding local government.

Possible constitutional changes and a possible review of certain laws may result from the meeting.

SA Local Government Association chairperson Amos Masondo said local government enjoyed powers and functions spelt out in the Constitution.

"... We had to go back to the drawing board and ask questions around what's working and what's not working," he said.

Masondo said functions, for example the delivery of housing, currently located at provincial and national level, could be delegated to local government level.

He said that capacity existed at local level to accomplish this and where it did not exist the capacity could be built.

'Unprecedented' system of governance

The indaba comes in the wake of protests against lack of service delivery across the country with many turning violent and seeing the destruction of property.

Shiceka said a turnaround strategy would be put together by December and go through the various levels of government for discussion and implementation early next year.

"When you buy services you must get value for your money.

"We are going to have a system of local governance that is unprecedented in South Africa."

A report on the state of local government was released at the conference, which indicated that 30% of the protests from January to July this year took place in Gauteng.

North West experienced 17% of the protests, 15% were in the Free State and 12% in the Western Cape.

- SAPA

City backs down on moving squatters to Avondale

The City of Cape Town’s has backed down on its plans to set up a Temporary Relocation Area (TRA) for Frankdale squatters next to the middle-class Avondale suburb in Atlantis.

Atlantis residents were up in arms over the proposed temporary resettlement of the squatters, saying public services in the poverty-stricken area were already overloaded and the TRA would bring down the value of the Avondale properties which many residents had spent their life savings on improving and maintaining.

The City needs to move the 480 squatter households from where they are living next to the Vissershok landfill site because it is unsuitable for human habitation and because they need to extend the landfill area.

The City’s rethink on their plans emerged on Saturday morning during a meeting between Western Cape Premier Helen Zille, Cape Town mayor Dan Plato and concerned residents.

Zille reassured residents that the TRA would not be set up next to Avondale following the objections and grievances expressed by the residents.

But residents remain concerned that the City is still planning on establishing the TRA elsewhere in or near Atlantis

Concerned Residents Association Chairperson Whilma Liedeman said although the premier assured residents the TRA plans for Avondale were off the table, it seemed as if they were still looking at other areas in Atlantis.

Liedeman said both the mayor and premier needed to listen to the people of Atlantis, most of who were against the TRA being set up anywhere in Atlantis.

She said some Atlantis residents seemed to think they would benefit from the TRA but the did not understand it properly, like the fact that TRA residents would only have one outside toilet for every four homes and they would be living in corrugated iron structures. She said she would be “going out” tonight (subs: Wed) to inform people about implications of having a TRA in their area.

Independent Democrats councillor Cynthia Clayton said she, and Avondale residents, were happy about the city’s decision not to back down on their plans.

Clayton said before accommodating people from outside the area, housing and living conditions needed to be improved for Atlantis residents, an unusually high proportion of whom were unemployed and living in poverty.

She encouraged the community to participate in sub-council meeting and work through their ward councilors to prevent Atlantis from becoming a “dumping site”.

- West Cape News

Service deblabble



While President Jacob Zuma was addressing most of the country's mayors, municipal managers, premiers and local government MECs at the OR Tambo Hall in Khayelitsha, angry residents of the neighbouring RR-Section informal settlement wanted to know why they had not been invited.

As police kept an eye on him, an angry resident, who would be identified only as Mthuthuzeli, expressed his disappointment at Zuma for not inviting members of the public to the meeting.

'could Zuma smell the excrement'
"When he was canvassing for votes, he came into our shacks and didn't put up a fence to keep us out. I want to know whether he could smell the excrement from inside the hall where he was sitting."

Another resident, Sizwe Dlabantu, asked: "If it was only for VIPs, why did they bring it here to Khayelitsha. They could've had it at the Arabella Sheraton in town."

'We don't have any rights even though we voted'
Kept out of the venue by a three metre-high fence which had closed off a section of Lansdowne Road, and guarded by a small army of police and VIP guards, the residents could only look on at the procession of luxury German vehicles which entered the venue.

The area chosen for the meeting has had several service delivery protests over the years, with shacks located along the road built below the flood plain.

This was one of the reasons the city council had given for why services could not be provided for some of the shacks around Lansdowne Road.

Asked why the venue had been chosen, Minister in the Presidency Collins Chabane said he had not been part of the decision, but said it was a good venue.

Zusiphelhe Mathanda, who lives at the BT-Section informal settlement where people forcibly closed off a section of Lansdowne Road for almost a month in September, said Zuma should have gone on a walkabout in the area.

He mentioned a semi-permanent presence of the Metro Police on Lansdowne Road, which has prevented objects such as shipping containers being moved on to the road and has stopped the digging of trenches by a community insisting on being moved.

"We don't have any rights even though we voted. Zuma should pressurise Dan Plato so that he can give us a piece of land," Mathanda said.


- Cape Times

South Africa will not tolerate violent protests: Zuma

The South African government will not tolerate violent protests that have rocked poor townships, President Jacob Zuma said Tuesday while calling for service delivery to be stepped up.

"Burning down libraries, torching people's houses, and looting spaza (small) shops do not build a strong nation. It does not solve our legitimate problems," Zuma told a meeting of 238 mayors in Cape Town's Khayelitsha township.

South Africa has been hit by a series of service delivery riots since July in communities fed up with shoddy public service, with calls for Zuma to meet promises to speed up delivery and act against corrupt officials.

"There is weak financial management, which often results to irregular expenditure, corruption, and adverse audit outcomes," Zuma said.

The protests have seen property set alight and roads barricaded in poor informal settlements where demands for access to water, electricity and housing have turned violent.

"There is no cause in a democratic and free society, however legitimate, that justifies the wanton destruction of property and violence that we have witnessed," Zuma said.
The government had made progress but faced significant backlogs in rolling out basic services, he told the meeting which follows mass meetings with the country's police commissioners and school principals.

"It is clear that we need to do more, and that we need to do things differently," he said, calling for dialogue with voters to "bridge the gap and close the social distance".

- AFP

Tuesday, October 20, 2009

'Could Zuma smell the excrement?'

While President Jacob Zuma was addressing most of the country's mayors, municipal managers, premiers and local government MEC's at the OR Tambo Hall in Khayelitsha, angry residents of the neighbouring RR-Section informal settlement wanted to know why they had not been invited.

As police kept an eye on him, an angry resident, who would be identified only as Mthuthuzeli, expressed his disappointment at Zuma for not inviting members of the public to the meeting: "When he was canvassing for votes, he came into our shacks and didn't put up a fence to keep us out. I want to know whether he could smell the excrement from inside the hall where he was sitting."

Another resident, Sizwe Dlabantu, asked: "If it was only for VIP's, why did they bring it here to Khayelitsha, they should've had it at the Arabella Sheraton in town."

- Cape Times

Symphony Way families to be forcibly removed

Delft Symphony Way dwellers may be forcibly removed soon.

The Western Cape High Court on Monday confirmed an earlier court order giving the city the right to relocate the families.

They have been living on the pavement since being evicted from Delft houses they illegally occupied.

The order paves the way for the City of Cape Town to move into Symphony Way and start relocating scores of families to Blikkiesdorp.

Residents said they were disappointed.

Some vowed to stay put and said they would fight any attempt to remove them and their belongings from the temporary structures.

Earlier, the residents’ legal team put a list of demands to the court saying they were only willing to move if living conditions at Blikkiesdorp were significantly improved.

The court rejected the demands, saying improvement could not happen overnight.

- Eyewitness News

Monday, October 19, 2009

Three killed in shack fire

Khayelitsha police are investigating the cause of the fire that killed three people, including two children after their shack in BM section burnt down yesterday.

Police spokesperson Constable Mthokozisi Gama says 34 year old Ntombizonke Nonzwane and her daughters, five year old Anako and 13 year old Yonela were burnt beyond recognition when their shack went on flames in the early hours of yesterday.

Two other shacks were also gutted by the fire.

Anyone with the information regarding the incident is asked to contact:
the investigative officer, Constable Sinethemba Jamjam at 021 360 2389.

- BushRadio News

ADDRESS BY THE MINISTER OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT ON THE OCCASION OF THE LAUNCH OF THE HEMP PROJECT, MAPONYA MALL-SOWETO

Master of Ceremonies, Honourable Premier of Gauteng, Ms Nomvula Mokonyana, Executive Mayor of the City of Johannesburg, Mr Amos Masondo, Honourable MEC of Social Development, Ms Qedani Mahlangu , Honourable Minister of Human Settlements, Mr Tokyo Sexwale, Director-Generals and senior government officials here present, Representatives and leaders from the private sector, Distinguished guests, Comrades and friends, Ladies and Gentlemen

Thank you for joining us this morning on this important occasion in which we seek to intensify our efforts to combat the poverty. As a department, we have looked forward to this launch because the ultimate goal of our work is to engender self reliance in our people and communities.

With us coming together as government, the development agencies, the private sector, NGOs and our international partners to launch this project, we show our willingness and commitment to confront poverty which continues to undermine people’s dignity and overshadow the achievements of the last fifteen years.

It is befitting and inspiring that we launch this project here at the Maponya Mall, the brainchild of the Soweto veteran businessman and the pioneer of black township business, Ntate Richard Maponya. What an inspiration it is to be launching the Hemp project in the presence of a man who defied his poor background and hostile apartheid policies to become one of the leading and respected black businessman who paved the way for a new generation of emerging black business leaders.

We are equally honoured to have with us, one of the leading academic minds and development activist, Dr Mamphela Ramphele who has written extensively on the subject of poverty. Many of us in the development sector draw on your knowledge to infuse thinking about the South African development trajectory. You have contributed to this effort in no small measure.

We are greatly honoured and pleased that you all took time from your busy schedules to join us in this national civil society dialogue. Our ultimate long term goal remains uprooting poverty (to borrow from the title of Dr Mamphela’s report on poverty) through building a more caring society…. together, for the mark of a noble society is found not in how it protects the most powerful, but how it defends the most vulnerable.

I do not know if it is fate or design that the launch of this project is taking place here in Soweto- a township that was the nucleus of our struggle for freedom and justice. Whatever the reason, the launch could not have happened at a more appropriate place than here.

It was in the streets of this vast township that our youth, armed only with stones and petrol bombs, fought relentlessly against the heavily armed security forces. Many of you will remember that in 1956 during the height of apartheid, the Congress of the People took place in Kliptown (not far from here) to draw up the Freedom Charter which became the foundation of our Constitution.

At that historic gathering, the forefathers of our struggle pledged: “the state shall help the peasants with implements, seed, tractors and dams to save the soil and assist the tillers”. As a nation we have walked a long road since that historic gathering, but the Freedom Charter remains a living document that guides our national democratic revolution.

Today, 54 years on and 15 years into a democratic South Africa, we are gathered here to make a similar pledge to work together to eliminate extreme hunger and poverty in our midst. On this historic occasion of the launch of the Hemp Project, let me start by saying that it gives me great pleasure to be present at a function of this kind as it gives us an opportunity to witness first hand, how much can be achieved when government joins hands with the private sector, research institutions, development agencies and communities to tackle the challenges confronting us. On behalf of my Department I would like to thank all the stakeholders in the Hemp project.

The fact that the Hemp project takes place today, on the same date as the International Day for the Eradication of Poverty, is a matter of historical significance. Every year, 17 October is observed by United Nations Member States as the International Day for the Eradication of Poverty- a global awareness campaign dedicated to fighting poverty and destitution around the globe.

The history of this campaign can be traced back to 1987 when over a hundred thousand people gathered in Paris, where the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was signed in 1948, to honour the victims of extreme poverty, violence and hunger.

They proclaimed that poverty is a violation of human rights and affirmed the need to come together to ensure that these rights are respected. Since then, people of all backgrounds, beliefs and social origins have gathered every year on this day to renew their commitment and show their solidarity with the poor. For us this day presents us with a watershed opportunity to launch this very exciting and ground breaking development initiative.

What makes this initiative so much interesting is that it is spearheaded by a community-public-private sector partnership that brings together the synergy, expertise and resources between various stakeholders. Without any doubt, today’s event signifies unity in diversity and action.

Furthermore, today's event is a very important and rewarding milestone for my Department as this project is a direct beneficiary of our Sustainable Livelihood Approach- an innovative development strategy which seeks to teach people that through cooperative self-help and a united approach to common problems, the vast potential for their own self-improvement can be translated into effective programmes which can do much to improve their standard of living.

Mahatma Gandhi once said “Poverty is the worst form of violence”. None of us in this room can deny that poverty is a reality in this country, and, if South Africa is to grow and prosper, it needs to eradicate poverty as a matter of extreme urgency. It is for this reason that the government embarked some years ago on the strong drive to eradicate poverty in South Africa, especially in the rural areas, hit the hardest by the global economic recession and the widespread retrenchments. As a government, every day we respond as best we can to the concerns of those hit hardest by this crisis. While we continue to reap the benefits of globalization, we clearly have not been immune to the shocks that come with it.

Over the last fifteen years government has been implementing a myriad of poverty alleviation measures, with social assistance programme being the biggest of them all, aimed at achieving the goal of a better life for all. To date this programme is one of the most comprehensive and sophisticated in the developing world. We have, progressively expanded social grants to vulnerable groups since the dawn of our democracy and more than a quarter of the population is receiving income transfers.

I have said it before, and at the risk of sounding like a broken record-player, I would like to repeat that while appropriate social security provisioning plays a critical role in addressing the basic needs of the poor households, it is only meant to be a temporary measure.

From its inception, the social assistance programme was not specifically designed with strategies to connect recipients and other able-bodied and unemployed household members to opportunities for sustainable livelihoods, employment and other economic opportunities.

Having succeeded in expanding the reach of our social security system to so many in our country, the challenge now is to focus on programmes that have the potential to graduate people out of poverty.

To respond to this challenge, my Department initiated the Sustainable Livelihoods to link the poor, vulnerable and marginalized, with particular focus on able-bodied beneficiaries of social grants, to opportunities for sustainable livelihoods and economic activities. The programme does not intend to exit social grant beneficiaries from the system in the short-term, but to create opportunities for sustained work opportunities and income in the long-term.

This programme operates within the framework of adaptive social protection- a process which facilitates the strengthening of coping strategies of the poor to tackle vulnerabilities and build their adaptive capacities to improve access to socio-economic opportunities. It might not solve all their problems, but it does build up their confidence to tackle such problems more effectively. We strongly believe that the pursuit of the goals and, in the end, of development and poverty requires the active participation of the beneficiaries.

One such project, which has proven successful as it gives communities the opportunity to determine their own patterns and priorities of development, is Silindithemba project (Dutyini, Eastern Cape) on “linking grants to sustainable livelihoods and co-operatives”.

The success of the Silindithemba project, which is driven mainly by rural women who were previously disenfranchised simply on the basis of their gender, is testimony that with initiative and the right support, women are creating markets where none existed, turning a profit, and prioritizing investing in the education and health of their families. It has been proven that investing in women and girls is not only a worthy goal in its own right - it is one of the fastest and best means of advancing human development for all.

Today’s launch of the Hemp Project is the culmination of long standing partnership between my Department, the Centre for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), Agricultural Research Council (ARC), the Eastern Cape Departments of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries (national and provincial), Eastern Cape Department of Economic Affairs, Eastern Cape Development Agency, Department of Science and Technology, the Development Bank of Southern Africa (DBSA) and the Department of Trade and Industry.

The majority of people participating in this project are women. Given the historical importance of this day, and the fact that poverty disproportionally affects women than men, what a better way of showing our commitment to poverty reduction than to invest in the Hemp Project?

Analyzing data from two surveys conducted by Statistics South Africa, a recent study by the University of Stellenbosch found that 45 percent of female-headed households lived below the poverty line, as compared to only 25 percent of male-headed households. The findings of this study are comparable with international trends which show that of the world’s 1.3 billion poor people, women constitute 70 percent.

This state of affairs is variance with the Freedom Charter and the Constitution both of which are premised on the concept of social justice and gender equality. For this reason, we welcome and support development initiatives that strengthen the value chains for women cooperatives.

Comrades and friends, we believe that value chains will certainly address poverty and gender disparities. An enhanced value chain is a great incentive to production and income generation, however it cannot sustain unless market access is possible for them.

We have learnt that most cooperatives, some of which have huge potential to succeed and benefit many people, did not last for long due to limited or no market accessibility. Judging by the presence of so many entrepreneurs in this room, I am hopeful that we can rely on your business acumen to improve the Hemp project’s production chain and to increase its competitiveness and market penetration.
Support for more commercially orientated production, improved marketing, and private sector involvement is identified as a strategic object in most of the development initiatives. The beauty about the Hemp project is that it fully embraces the concept of sustainable livelihoods in that it highlights the need for communities to use natural resources in a sustainable fashion.

I therefore would like urge each and everyone in this room to share your expertise by participating in this national flagship programme in order to create production and marketing capacities as well as competitiveness in national and international markets.

Judging by the long list of government departments and agencies involved in this project, our government is up to the challenge of eradicating poverty. But it is clear that our success will come only if it is a true team effort. Government is doing its part, but the private sector must step up and seize the opportunity we have created. Working together, we can do much better to reduce poverty.

So now, I call upon the leaders of our private sector to take up the challenge at this important time: to join your government and continue to invest in our nation’s future. Work with us to ensure that our nation’s limited resources are able to meet the objective of improving the lives of the people of South Africa, particularly poor women in rural areas.

Before concluding, let me take this opportunity to congratulate the pioneers of the House of Hemp, in particular Dr Thandeka Kunene and the project’s investment partner, Dr Mamphela Ramphele, and members of my department for successfully organizing this launch.

I should also point out that the foundation for the partnership agreement between the Department of Social Development and the House of Hemp, was laid by the sterling support and contributions from the CSIR, ARC, Eastern Cape Department of Economic Affairs, Eastern Cape Development Agency, Department of Science and Technology, DBSA, Department of Trade and Industry and the Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries. The stage is set and we call aboard all actors to participate.

We must all band together to shoulder the responsibility of bringing our nation through these challenging global times. As I said, to date we have been successful. But now is not the time to be complacent. It is the time to step up to the challenge and work hard to ensure our nation’s bright economic future. We owe this to gallant men and women who in 1955 gathered in Kliptown to adopt the Freedom Charter.
As Norman Peale once said:
Empty pockets never held anyone back. Only empty heads and empty hearts can do that.
As we launch this project on this historic day, we do so with the hope that it will bring us much closer to the attainment of our shared and common goal of making poverty a history.

I thank you.

- Department of Social Development

- South African Government Information

W Cape backyard dwellers to know their fate today

Shacks

The Western Cape High Court is today expected to confirm an order for the eviction of more than 100 families who are living on the pavement in Delft's Symphony Way. Today’s verdict is expected after the former backyard dwellers and the City could not reach an agreement last week over where they should be relocated to.

The City wants to move them to Blikkiesdorp in Delft, but residents are adamant they will not go there. The families are former backyarders who illegally occupied newly-completed homes in Delft intended for beneficiaries of the N2 Gateway project. If the order is confirmed today, they will be moved to Blikkiesdorp in weekly batches of 25.

On Saturday, reports indicated that the City of Cape Town and the families failed during a mediation process to reach an agreement as to where the dwellers should be relocated to. The families have been living on the pavement next to the houses for 18 months. Last week the Western Cape High Court ordered that they be relocated and that the nearby Blikkiesdorp is a suitable temporary settlement for them.

Anti-Eviction Campaign spokesperson Ashraf Cassiem pronounced that the families were prepared to move anywhere, as long as there is provision of proper sanitation. Cassiem says the people are also demanding to be moved to a place where their safety will be ensured.

- SABC

Friday, October 16, 2009

SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT MINISTER TO LAUNCH COMMUNITY UPLIFTMENT PROJECT TO MARK INTERNATIONAL DAY FOR THE ERADICATION OF POVERTY

To mark the International Day for the Eradication of Poverty the Minister of Social Development, Ms Edna Molewa, will tomorrow, 17 October 2009, launch the Hemp Project, a partnership between government, private sector and women cooperatives aimed at uplifting emerging black women farmers in the Eastern Cape. The event will take place at Maponya Mall in Soweto, Johannesburg.

The Department of Social Development has entered into a Cooperation Agreement with the Hemp Industrial Park to set up a Hemp Cottage Industry in partnership with Silindithemba Cooperative and Indalo (a black-owned farming enterprise).

The project targets mainly rural women, most of whom are caregivers of the beneficiaries of social grants. The intention is to link the beneficiaries of social grants to sustainable livelihoods and cooperatives which will in a long term graduate them out of poverty.

At the launch the cooperatives of this R20 million venture will showcase a variety of hemp products including clothes, food supplements and health products.

Media are invited to cover the event.

Details of the event are:

Date : Saturday, 17 October 2009

Time : 10am

Venue : Shop 185, Maponya Mall, Soweto

Enquiries : Zanele Mngadi at 0823301148

RSVPs : Jackie Kobue on 073026 1111/ 012312 7793

Issued by the National Department of Social Development - PTA

Thursday, October 15, 2009

An end to free houses?

Giving poor people free houses is not a sustainable plan, says the Western Cape MEC for housing, and it's time for the national government to rethink its policy in this regard.

Housing MEC Bonginkosi Madikizela said it was time for the government to take a long, hard look at how it delivered housing. He said the approach to housing delivery was doing a lot for a few.

"If we were in the business of providing people with cars, we would be giving one person a Rolls-Royce when we could be giving 10 people Citi Golfs."

An up-to-date study put the housing backlog in the province near 500 000.

Have your say...

This breaking news flash was supplied exclusively to iol.co.za by the news desk at our sister title, the Cape Argus.

There are come choice comments follow the link above....

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

New housing plan needed

Cape Town - It was time for a rethink on the provision of free houses, Western Cape housing MEC Bonginkosi Madikizela said on Wednesday.

He also said the government should "revisit" the Prevention of Illegal Eviction Act (PIE), as it was a major obstacle to housing delivery.

Addressing a housing conference in Cape Town, he said South Africa appeared to be the only country in the world that gave people free homes.

There were five million registered taxpayers in South Africa, supporting 13 million grant recipients.

The unemployment rate was between 30% and 40% and growing, which meant the bulk of the population depended on a small and diminishing number of taxpayers for their basic needs.

"It is quite clear that we need to rethink whether or not we continue to give people a free house.

"This is not an easy decision to make... But we need to decide: do we continue to do a lot for a few people or do we shift towards a little for many people?

"It cannot be fair or just that a beneficiary can receive a full house with services free of charge, whilst hundreds of thousands of others have to wait for years in backyards or informal settlements without even basic services."

Serviced sites over complete houses

This was why the Western Cape - the only province controlled by Madikizela's Democratic Alliance - would in coming years prioritise provision of serviced sites over delivery of complete houses.

Going this route meant it would be able to give housing opportunities to three times as many people as was currently the case.

Madikizela said there was a housing shortage of about half a million units in the Western Cape.

With the R1.58bn the province would get this year from national government in terms of the Division of Revenue Act, it could build about 16 000 housing units and 18 000 serviced sites.

At that rate, and if the housing shortage remained static, it would take some 28 years to eliminate the backlog.

However the backlog was growing as people migrated to the Western Cape from other provinces.

If the current "high growth trajectory" continued, by 2040 the backlog would have nearly doubled to 804 000.

PIE 'a problem'

"It is time for us to make some critical choices about the way we deliver housing," he said.

"Politicians need to summon the political will to take decisions that may be unpopular in the short term, but will have long term benefits for everyone."
He said PIE was problematic because it rewarded people who broke the law.

"People invade the land, and when we evict them as government, the PIE act says we must find alternative land. That is a serious problem.

"So we [have] actually asked the national department and the national Cabinet to look seriously at this act, because really it is a stumbling block on us building houses as quickly as we would want."

- SAPA

Housing MEC admits backlog is not shifting

Western Cape Housing MEC Bonginkhosi Madikizela has warned if something drastic is not done it could take 28 years to address the housing backlog in the province.

He addressed nearly 100 delegates at an international conference in Cape Town on Wednesday.


The MEC maintained there were innovative ways of tackling the severe housing backlog.


The province has a housing shortage of nearly 500 000 units.

Madikizela said with an annual 17 percent migration rate to the Western Cape, the housing backlog would only get worse.

He conceded housing delivery was moving at a slow pace and said a concerted effort was needed to tackle the challenge.

- Eyewitness News

Abahlali baseMjondolo celebrates as Constitutional Court declares KZN Slums Act unconstitutional

After being the subject of political violence and shameless slander over the last two weeks, the Abahlali baseMjondolo Movement (AbM) has something to celebrate as the Constitutional Court (CC) today declared the provincial KwaZulu-Natal Elimination and Prevention of Re-emergence of Slums Act (Slums Act) unconstitutional.

Specifically, the CC declared section 16 of the Slums Act is unconstitutional and invalid. This section makes it compulsory for municipalities to institute proceedings for eviction of unlawful occupiers where the owner or person in charge of the land fails to do so within the time prescribed by the MEC. The applicants argued that section 16 of the Slums Act is in violation of section 26(2) of the Constitution in three ways: it precludes meaningful engagement between municipalities and unlawful occupiers; it violates the principle that evictions should be a measure of last resort; and it undermines the precarious tenure of unlawful occupiers by allowing the institution of eviction proceedings while ignoring the procedural safeguards inherent in the PIE Act. Without section 16, the Slums Act is rendered ineffective.

The application in Abahlali baseMjondolo Movement SA and Another v Premier of the Province of KwaZulu-Natal and Others was first brought by AbM and its president, Sibusiso Zikode, in the Durban High Court in February 2008. The case was heard before Tshabalala JP on 6 November 2008. AbM challenged section 16 of the Act specifically, which they contend bypasses the national Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act (PIE Act), particularly safeguards in the Act which protect unlawful occupiers from eviction.

Tshabalala JP handed down judgment on 27 January 2009 dismissing the application, finding that the Slums Act was reasonable and not inconsistent with the Constitution or the PIE Act. He congratulated the Province for passing the legislative measures to eradicate slums. This decision was appealed to the CC and the case was heard on 14 May 2009.

In a judgment written by Moseneke DCJ (with all the judges except Yacoob J concurring), he found that “section 16 cannot be reconciled with the national Housing Act and the National Housing Code, both of which have been passed to give effect to section 26(2) of the Constitution” and that the MEC’s power to issue a notice as envisioned in section 16 is “overbroad and irrational”. Moseneke DCJ further found that section 16 is incapable of an interpretation that promotes the ostensible objectives of eliminating and preventing slums and providing adequate housing. He referred to the fact that other provinces were “awaiting guidance from the Court before deciding on similar legislation.” This clarity has now thankfully been restored.

According to Kate Tissington, a researcher at CALS, “the Slums Act equates the elimination of slums with the eviction of people living in them and was intended to make that a much more frequent and easily facilitated occurrence. The core focus of the Act is on facilitating eradication, not in providing adequate housing. While it ostensibly allows government to fast track housing delivery, the Act has the real and pernicious effect of actively encouraging the eviction of unlawful occupiers living in informal settlements and buildings without taking into account their circumstances or the provision of alternative accommodation. There is a lack of acknowledgment that informal settlements and slum conditions are a symptom of a bigger problem in South African cities around well-located land and access to livelihoods.”

The Constitutional Court win affirms AbM’s interpretation of the Act and means that a repressive and constitutionally inconsistent piece of legislation is now inoperable and will not be replicated in other provinces.

The applicants were represented by CALS with Wim Trengove SC, Heidi Barnes and Kirsty McLean as counsel.

For more information please contact:

Kate Tissington: kate.tissington@wits.ac.za or 072 2209 125

Teboho Mosikili: Teboho.mosikili@wits.ac.za or 011 717 8614


ANC suspects own members could be behind service delivery protests

As three townships erupted into violence, the ANC said it now suspects that some of its own members could be behind the service delivery protests.


The party also revealed that it would discourage President Jacob Zuma from making whistle-stop visits to areas hit by unrest, especially if the protesters demanded to see him.

Thousands of Sakhile township residents in Standerton, Mpumalanga, went on the rampage yesterday - burning down two municipal buildings, a truck, and looting vending stalls.

Police had to fire rubber bullets at the crowd when some protesters began stoning armoured vehicles...

- The Times

Habitat problems outside the WC

When: Wednesday 14 October at 1:00pm
Where: Jammie Plaza, UCT Upper Campus
What: Civil society solidarity protest with Abahlali baseMjondolo


The UCT History and Current Affairs Society (HCA), UCT Student Worker’s Alliance (UCTSWA), UCT’s branch of the Social Justice Coalition (SJC) and the UCT branch of Students for Law and Social Justice (SLSJ) have been horrified by the seeming prioritising of political and economic interest over human life in Kennedy Road, an informal settlement in Durban.

The Kennedy Road Development Committee and the members of the shack dwellers movement, Abahlali baseMjondolo were on the receiving end of the police-sanctioned violence at the end of last month, when a group of about 40 men attacked members of these organisations while chanting “anti-Mpondo” slogans and calling for “all the amaZulu to come out”.

This is a politically and ethnically motivated attack, which is attempting to silence voices of political opposition and exploit the poor. Together with Abahlali baseMjondolo, we call on President Jacob Zuma to intervene to end the criminalization of a democratically elected civil society organisation that seeks to improve the lives of its members, irrespective of their political, religious or ethnic backgrounds. - Abahlali

Cure rate of TB abysmal, admits Minister

Control of tuberculosis in South Africa is among the worst in the world, with infections tripling over the past decade.

“South Africa is among the 10 worst-performing countries on TB control,” Deputy Health Minister Molefi Sefularo said on Monday at the sixth annual investigators’ meeting of Aids and TB specialists in Cape Town.

The meeting was held to outline SA’s progress on TB control. Researchers from South Africa, Zambia, Zim-babwe, Kenya, Brazil, the US and the World Health Organisation (WHO) attended.

A Statistics SA report of a few months ago indicated that in 2006 TB accounted for 13% of deaths, making it the number one cause of death in the country.

The WHO estimated that almost 1% (461 000) of South Africans developed TB annually.

The TB cure rate in SA is at 65%, whereas the WHO recommends an 85% cure rate to disrupt high levels of infection

Sefularo announced that the department was in the process of reviewing the country’s TB programme and hoped a plan would be presented to a consultative meeting by April 2010.

- The Citizen

Monday, October 12, 2009

Air pollution costs SA R4bn in healthcare

Air pollution is responsible for more than R4-billion in health costs, the Department of Environmental Affairs said on Monday.

"Healthcare costs associated with the burning of fossil fuels amount to R4-billion," the department's national air quality officer Peter Lukey told reporters in Vanderbijlpark at the Air Quality Governance Lekgotla.

He said the poor were disproportionally affected by air pollution.

"They carry a double burden because firstly they are poor and secondly they are sick."

The poor often live in poorly ventilated areas and use coal fires for heat and cooking.

In addition to this, Lukey said during apartheid times living areas for the poor were often designated in areas downwind from industrial plants as no one else wanted to live there...

- SAPA

Saturday, October 10, 2009

State turns against shack dwellers

THE appellants in the Joe Slovo shack dwellers’ case against Thubelisha Homes might be forgiven for thinking the law is an idiot and an ass (and a bachelor, no doubt) after a recent ruling of the Constitutional Court.

Five Constitutional Court judges unanimously upheld last year’s high court ruling by Judge President John Hlophe that the 20000-strong community be evicted and relocated from the Joe Slovo informal settlement adjoining Langa, Cape Town’s oldest township, to Delft, 34km away.

Last month, a full bench of Constitutional Court judges suspended the court’s order indefinitely following an application by Housing Minister Tokyo Sexwale that expressed “grave concerns” about the “practical, social, financial and legal consequences” of the relocation.


In the context of the lengthy, ongoing struggle of Joe Slovo’s residents against the infamous N2 Gateway Housing Project for which they were to be relocated, it is difficult to see how the earlier decision overlooked such consequences.

N2 Gateway Control
It has become commonplace to compare the government’s relocation of shack dwellers with the forced removal policies of the apartheid government . The difference, however, is the recourse to law that the post-apartheid government has facilitated — which organisations such as the shack dwellers’ movement, Abahlali baseMjondolo, have been using.

One of the movement’s targets is KwaZulu-Natal’s Elimination and Prevention of Re-Emergence of Slums Act of 2007. It allows for a person resisting eviction to be imprisoned for up to 10 years .

In November last year, Abahlali baseMjondolo challenged the act in the Durban High Court. After Judge President Vuka Tshabalala rejected their attempt to have the slums act declared unconstitutional, they took the case to the Constitutional Court.

At the Constitutional Court hearing in May , Adv Wim Trengove, acting for Abahlali baseMjondolo, argued that the slums act seemed to be in conflict with the 1997 National Housing Act, national housing policy and provisions of the 1998 Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act.

This landmark piece of legislation, known as the PIE Act, gives effect to Section 26 (3) of the constitution which states: “No one may be evicted from their home or have their home demolished without an order of court made after considering all the relevant circumstances. No legislation may permit arbitrary evictions.”

The circumstances the act considers are how occupiers came onto the land; how long they have lived there; the needs of its elderly, disabled, children and female- headed households; and the availability of suitable alternative accommodation.

The Constitutional Court judges in the recently reversed Joe Slovo judgment made three humane provisions in line with these circumstances . The state should provide 70% of the low-cost housing to be built in the N2 Gateway Project to former or current Joe Slovo residents who applied and qualified for housing. The residents were to be allowed to take part in a phased process of removal ; and the court ruled that they be relocated to sturdy temporary residential units serviced with tarred roads and communal ablution facilities at Delft or another suitable location.

As the housing minister’s application suggests, these provisions appear less than humane when viewed against the history of the N2 Gateway Project.

Phase 1 of the project was completed in mid-2006, with 705 rental flats. Very few of the 1000 families who were moved from Joe Slovo to Delft to make way for this were accommodated .

Phase 2, the building of bonded houses in the Joe Slovo area and Delft, is out of the financial reach of most of the shack dwellers .

Thubelisha Homes, the now defunct section 21 company appointed in 2006 to implement and manage the N2 Gateway Project, has moved people out of the slum-like conditions at the temporary camp into permanent houses at Delft at a rate of 10 families a year.

In March this year, Abahlali baseMjondolo won a victory in the Durban High Court, which granted eight orders that provided for judicial oversight of the Richmond Farm transit camp to which residents of Siyanda in Durban were being relocated.

They had been promised houses in the Khalula development, but when this fell through as a result of corruption, Bheki Cele, the transport MEC at the time, sought their forced removal to the Richmond Farm transit camp.

Residents were offered no guarantees about conditions in the camp, the duration of their stay and where, if anywhere, they would be sent next.

They approached the Durban High Court for protection.

The court ordered that the families moved to the transit camp be given permanent, decent housing within a year.

It asked for a report on the corrupt allocation of houses in Siyanda and, where necessary, that restitution be made to the victims of the corruption.

Then in August, the South Gauteng High Court ruled there could be no evictions at the South Protea settlement in Johannesburg until the possibilities of upgrading the site and relocation to a nearby site had been investigated. It gave the City of Joburg a month to report on the provision of water, sanitation, refuse removal and lighting at Protea South and ordered that “meaningful engagement” be undertaken with the Landless Peoples Movement .

Residents of Protea South had since 2003 been resisting eviction to Doornkop, which they describe as a “human dumping ground” distant from their places of work and their children’s schools .

Despite the importance of residential location to the livelihoods and family structures of slum dwellers, the Joe Slovo ruling stated : “The right (to housing) is a right to adequate housing and not the right to remain in the locality of their choice, namely Joe Slovo.”

In the landmark 2007 Olivia Road case in which more than 400 occupiers of two buildings in the Johannesburg central business district appealed against eviction, the Constitutional Court stated that engagement is a two-way process in which the city and those facing eviction should talk to each other meaningfully.

The Constitutional Court judges in the Joe Slovo case also ordered that residents be allowed full participation in their removal .

However, when eviction is fiercely resisted, and where there has been no evidence of “structured, consistent and careful engagement” in the past, this might seem at worst mischievous and, at best, legal naivety. - BDFM

Friday, October 9, 2009

'Dumping ground' for unwanted people

A man with discoloured skin -- dying alone in a shack of Aids -- speaks volumes about conditions in Blikkiesdorp, described as a "dumping ground" for unwanted people in Cape Town.
Set up in the Cape Flats settlement of Delft, primarily to stifle illegal invasions of newly constructed houses in the N2 Gateway Project, it has seen the resettlement of other people who have been relocated or evicted, including squatters ousted from Salt River's derelict Junction Hotel.

Tensions were stirred when refugees displaced by xenophobic violence and held at the Blue Waters refugee camp were recently moved to the site.

The city's official name for Blikkiesdorp -- named after its 1 300 3m x 6m zinc structures -- is the Symphony Way Temporary Relocation Area. It is a deceptively soothing name for a sink of poverty, crime and disease.

According to city spokesperson Kylie Hatton, it is one of the Cape Town's 223 informal settlements. Costing taxpayers R32-million to construct, Hatton said it is expected to grow to about 1 600 structures with a population of about 5 000.

She strenuously denied that it is a depository for the unwanted, saying "it compares extremely favourably with all the other [settlements] with respect to services, shelter, environment and density".

"It's an emergency area in terms of a national housing programme for people in emergency living conditions."

But Warda Jina, among Blikkiesdorp's first residents, disagrees. "This is just our dumping ground. It was a bad idea to expand the place and it's getting worse.

"The government said it was temporary accommodation and we'd be moved to houses. They're lying. We don't know how long we're going to live here -- maybe 20 years."

Ironically, the shack-dwellers initially faced threats from others who are even less fortunate who wanted to move into their structures.


"The refugees now have what others want. The same thing happened to us. People would bang on our windows and threaten to throw us out."

Jina said the refugees have been moved to a place of "crime and drugs next to the bush of evil" -- a reference to the vast shrub-covered area surrounding Blikkiesdorp, where she and a friend stumbled across a murdered child's body.

Blikkiesdorp resident Samsam Ahmad, a Somali refugee who has two small children, has warned other refugees still living in Blue Waters that Blikkiesdorp is not a safe alternative. She fears death and cannot sleep.

"We were told we're going to get protection but our lives are in danger. Every night people knock on our doors and say they want to burn us. My children's lives are at risk. We don't sleep at night and don't know how long we will stay here," says Ahmad.

Eddie Swartz, one of 18 members of the community committee, told the Mail & Guardian that at least 2 500 residents that need medical care and "most of them are HIV-positive". Swartz also chairs the health committee.

"Things are very critical. Patients get anti-retroviral drugs from the Delft clinic but they don't have food. We have some help from NGOs but we need a container with 24-hour healthcare. Patients will die if there's no ambulance to fetch them," said Swartz.

"We also have a TB problem. We have only three health volunteers. We know we're not going to get houses but we can't die here. We're not animals."

Charlene May, a Legal Resources Centre attorney, said the LRC was preparing do legal battle with thecity, which is seeking an order to evict about 300 refugees still at Blue Waters.

Moving refugees to Blikkiesdorp had been was part of out-of-court negotiations which were now frozen.

"No one else who was considering moving [to Blikkiesdorp] will move there now," said May.

Hatton said Blikkiesdorp has access to the Delft Community Health Centre 2,5km away. Residents also received TB and child health care.

- M&G

Thursday, October 8, 2009

We’d rather die than move away


UP IN ARMS: About 400 people protest outside the Western Cape high court yesterday against a plan to move them. PHOTO: ANNA MAJAVU
Residents fight bid to relocate them

“WE are prepared to die rather than be moved to the city of Cape Town’s temporary relocation area.”

These are the words of a group of about 400 people who yesterday appeared in the Western Cape high court fighting off a city bid to move them to Blikkiesdorp.

The temporary relocation area with its rows of corrugated iron one-roomed “houses” has been nicknamed Blikkiesdorp, or “Tin Can Town” by the 5000 people who currently live there.

The 400 people living in shacks built along a pavement in Delft, Cape Town, yesterday won a nine- day reprieve from eviction in the Western Cape high court.

They were living in different backyards in Delft until Democratic Alliance councillor Frank Martin unlawfully issued them with a letter authorising them to occupy newly built N2 Gateway national government houses.

A few months later they were evicted by the government, but their backyard shacks had already been rented to other tenants.

While Martin escaped serious punishment from the council, which suspended him for a month, the 500 people were left to set up home on the nearest roadside.

Yesterday local tabloid headlines screamed “Helen Zille’s Blikkiesdorp descends into a lawless hell”.

The leader of residents of Symphony Way, Roger Wicks, told Sowetan: “We are prepared to die rather than go to Blikkiesdorp.”

Wicks backed tabloid reports that Blikkiesdorp was full of drug dealers, alcoholism, and that it lacked any form of safety since police did not patrol there. He condemned Western Cape Premier Helen Zille for “using the coloured people for our votes and making us a lot of false promises about houses”.

Blikkiesdorp resident Willy Heyn said he advised people not to move to Blikkiesdorp, which had neither electricity nor street lighting, and which was 28km from the city centre.

A visit by Sowetan to Blikkiesdorp found the area in total darkness at night, and also found several families forced to share each toilet and tap.

City of Cape Town spokesperson Kylie Hatton confirmed that Eskom would not be installing electricity there until December 21.

The city’s advocate, Rob Stelzner, asked Judge Jake Moloi to hand down an eviction order suspended for nine days. Stelzner said the city was prepared to hold negotiations with Symphony Way residents during that time.

But Judge Moloi ordered the parties to negotiate and then come back to court on October 19 to argue their case in full.

It was revealed in court that the temporary relocation area, with its 1500 structures, cost the city R30million to build.

- Sowetan

Monday, October 5, 2009

Cape Town squatters threaten more protest action

Heavily armed Cape Town metro police officers are patrolling Lansdowne Road in Khayelitsha.

This after residents of the BT squatter camp in Site C threatened to continue protests over service delivery.

They are demanding that the City of Cape Town relocate them to a serviced site. But it appears as if things are returning to normal and traffic is now flowing freely under the watchful eye of the police.

Last week, residents barricaded the road with burning tyres and shipping containers in a bid to gain the attention of city officials.

Residents are demanding to be removed from their current site. They are also complaining that as long as they have lived in the area, they have never seen service delivery.

The residents told Eyewitness News they rely on illegal connections to get electricity.

Friday, October 2, 2009

Duarte and the housing racket

It was supposed to be a flagship housing project. Eleven years later, Thubelisha Homes is the albatross around the neck of Human Settlements Minister Tokyo Sexwale, who inherited the flop from his predecessor, Lindiwe Sisulu, now defence minister.

Read the document

A fortnight ago the Mail & Guardian revealed that housing director general Itumeleng Kotsoane had guaranteed R241,5-million in March to shut down the technically insolvent government housing agent. Although it managed a number of projects countrywide, Thubelisha will infamously be remembered for the disastrous N2 Gateway housing project in Cape Town.

This week the M&G can reveal that:
  • While employed by ­government to wind down Thube­lisha, the agency’s acting chief executive, John Duarte, is proposing that his private company take over state projects in which Thubelisha had invested funds;
  • In the months before shutting down operations, Duarte and his personal assistant, Emelia McNamara, spent tens of thousands of Thubelisha’s rands on domestic business class flights; and
  • Duarte refused the offer of free office space in Johannesburg and rented expensive offices with the shut-down budget.
This week also saw the release of the department’s annual report for 2008-2009, in which the auditor general criticises it for lending R100-million to Thubelisha without complying with the requirements of the Public Finance Management Act.

The department rallied behind Duarte after the M&G established that his company -- PTYtrade 407 -- had proposed to the Mossel Bay municipality that it continue with projects Thubelisha was contracted to do.

Duarte -- husband of Jessie Duarte, the chief operating officer in President Jacob Zuma’s office -- denies wrongdoing and says Sisulu’s closure plan for Thubelisha allowed for a private company to be formed by the agency’s staff.

On Duarte’s version his own private benefit when Thubelisha projects are taken over by his company would be allowed. But even if so, a conflict of interest remains in that he would be torn between closing down projects in a way that is beneficial to government as shareholder or to himself as heir to those projects.

The situation would not be unlike a liquidator buying some of the assets that he is supposed to dispose of at maximum value to creditors. Thubelisha officially closed down operations at the end of July but is still winding down the agency’s interests and administration with the assistance of private consultants Learning Strategies. This process could take months to finalise...

Some of its projects have been taken over by the Housing Development Agency (HDA), established in March by Sisulu to replace Thube­lisha in carrying out government’s objectives of providing low-cost housing to the poor. The HDA is headed by former Johannesburg Housing Company chief executive Taffy Adler.

According to human settlements spokesperson Clarence Tshitereke, the R240-million required to close Thubelisha is an “estimated figure as of December 31 2008. However, this amount has reduced substantially due to transactions that have taken place. This amount would be less by at least R100-million.”

The funding would cover severance packages for Thubelisha’s staffers, leases, cancelled contracts, operating costs and tax claims.

It remains unexplained why Duarte chose to rent expensive offices in Parktown, Johannesburg, from August when Thubelisha had the option of staying on for free at its Killarney office, now occupied by the HDA. This was confirmed to the M&G by two independent sources.

Duarte was appointed acting chief executive two years ago, after the disintegration of the agency’s board and the refusal of the national ­treasury to approve the agency’s budget. At that stage Duarte was already the sole director of PTYtrade 407 -- a dormant company now used to pursue the Mossel Bay deal.

The M&G is in possession of two documents that illustrate Duarte’s attempts to partner with fellow Thubelisha staff in a private venture -- while they are being paid by ­government to finish off Thube­lisha’s work.

The first is an email sent by McNamara -- Duarte’s PA -- to Colin Puren, director of community services at the Mossel Bay municipality, on July 30. This was a day before Thubelisha ceased to exist operationally. McNamara sent the email on behalf of Allistair Cullum, Thubelisha’s manager of projects in Mossel Bay.

Thubelisha was appointed as project manager by the munici­pality in 2007 to oversee the construction of 327 low-cost houses in Mandela Park. In April 2008, the Herald reported that little progress had been made with the project and that built houses were already beginning to crack.

In the email to Puren, Cullum wrote: “Thubelisha was employed by the Mosselbay [sic] Municipality to assist them with all the ­housing projects in Mosselbay. The first project that they gave us was for 327 houses and then you extended it to 1 500 houses. Then they employed us to do the block projects in Joe Slovo, Highway Park, Civic Park and Tarka [all Mossel Bay suburbs].

“We as Thubelisha put in allot [sic] of work and submitted all documentation to the Housing Department in the Western Cape. We spent R100 000 to get the geotech reports done as was requested from the Housing Department.

“A further R160 000 was paid to get the boundary pegs done on the erven and 4 houses was built that we never got paid for from the Municipality nor the Housing Department (value of R260 000).”

Cullum then pitches to Puren that Duarte’s company take over the projects. “Thubelisha’s operations will be coming to a close on the 31st of July 2009. Pty Trade 407 gave a proposal to the Municipality which is the same people that works for Thubelisha to complete all projects in Mosselbay. We are looking forward for your speedy response.”

Duarte admits submitting a ­proposal to the Mossel Bay municipality, but says this was done at their request “after they [the municipality] were informed by the [Housing Development Agency] that they [the HDA] would not be taking over the provincial projects ... At no time was the intention to take over uncompleted contracts of Thubelisha. Insofar as the Mossel Bay municipality is concerned the projects discussed were not part of Thubelisha’s projects,” Duarte says.

This, however, contradicts ­Cullum’s clear proposal to Puren: that PTYtrade 407 be appointed to finish the work Thubelisha was appointed for. Duarte also ignores the fact that Thubelisha had already spent R260 000 of government’s money on a project his private company now wants to inherit.

The second document is an email sent by Duarte himself to seven Thubelisha staffers, including Cullum, and one Mandla Gama on August 26. It reads: “I want to set up a domain for our e-mails something line (sic) what we had in our Thubelisha e-mails or one we can use as brand, Regards Johno.”

According to well-placed sources this refers to PTYtrade 407.

Duarte responded: “I sent it to these individuals as I thought they may be interested. The idea was subsequently abandoned as no one responded.”

The M&G is also in possession of Thubelisha’s travel records for May to July, which show that Duarte and McNamara spent R118 824 in this period, mostly on business-class flights. Duarte states that as part of the closure process, “travel would have to be undertaken to the various areas to ensure that the management and finalisation of projects are taken care of and that assets/income of the company is protected”.

Asked to give reasons for each trip, Duarte referred only to Thubelisha projects in Cape Town, Port Elizabeth and East London.

He failed to explain three flights to George during this period, which is the closest airport to Mossel Bay. On two occasions, Thubelisha also paid for non-staffers, Gama and P Cwazibe, to travel to George.

Tshitereke said the department was aware of Duarte’s visits to Thubelisha projects.

Yet another agency
The Housing Development Agency (HDA) was launched in March, four months before the closure of Thubelisha Homes, writes Ilham Rawoot.

But questions have arisen as to whether another housing agency is the answer to solving the housing crisis.

At the HDA launch, director general of housing Itumeleng Kotsoane said the agency would “fast-track housing delivery” and “coordinate the availability of land, support municipalities and provinces in project development and implementation”.

The HDA “has good people, but they are understaffed with an enormous mandate”, says Marie Huchzermeyer, professor of architecture and planning at Wits University. She says “building capacity at local government level” should be the priority, not establishing “yet another agency”.

A number of things need to be done differently this time around, says Dan Smit, adviser to Lindiwe Sisulu when she was housing minister. “The unusual density structure of our cities is really problematic and makes the provision of public transport quite difficult. The people who bear the brunt are the poor.”

Pivotal to eradicating the housing problem are the restructuring of our cities and redesigning financial instruments to make that happen, he says.

Huchzermeyer says the upgrading of informal settlements is also fundamental to success.

“The government spends so much money on security ensuring that people don’t build new shacks. So they move to backyard shacks, which just makes the problem more hidden.”


  • Jessie Duarte told the Mail and Guardian she and John Duarte had been divorced "ten years ago" but remained close friends. However John Duarte told the M&G a fortnight ago that they were married and Jessie has previously told the M&G that they had broken up and reconciled. Senior ANC officials who know the couple described them as married, and according to deeds office records they still co-own a house in Observatory in Johannesburg.
- M&G

Thursday, October 1, 2009

Shoot to kill = anarchy - Nicro

'Allowing police to shoot to kill would lead to anarchy, Nicro said'
Cape Town - Allowing police to shoot to kill would lead to anarchy, Nicro said on Thursday.

It was reacting to President Jacob Zuma's endorsement this week of the shoot-to-kill approach, and his comments on the rights of criminals.

The National Institute for Crime Prevention and the Reintegration of Offenders said it did not deny that crime was out of control in South Africa. Ways clearly had to be found to deal with it effectively.

"But our salvation will be in doing this within the parameters based on the values and principles of our Constitution," the non-governmental organisation said in a statement.

"Shooting to kill can only bring anarchy, and if that is the intention of the shooter, it is tantamount to a law enforcement officer being an investigator, prosecutor and judge, and meting out the death penalty."

It was not clear why, when law enforcement officers' lives were threatened, they should not shoot to disarm. They should be trained to be "sharp shooters".

The group maintained that a shoot-to-kill policy did not deter criminals from committing crime.

It just strengthened their resolve to shoot first, use higher calibre weapons and shoot their victims to avoid identification, Nicro said.

- SAPA

At least the 2000Ad comic book depiction of such law has fail-safes built in:
A Judge's personal gear includes a "Lawgiver" handgun (DNA-coded to recognize his palm-print alone and capable of firing six types of bullets), a daystick, a bootknife, and a uniform with a helmet that obscures all of his face except for his mouth and jaw.

Notorious barricaded road cleared

Council workers were greeted with angry stares yesterday as they cleared a notorious section of Lansdowne Road, previously barricaded by an angry community and forcibly shut for almost a month.

Just after 9am, an army of council vehicles, escorted by the Metro Police, descended on Lansdowne Road adjacent to BT-Section in Site C, Khayelitsha. For months, the area has been the scene of violent riots by residents demanding that the council move them to an alternative, serviced site.

The violence culminated in the brutal beating in August of an off-duty Stellenbosch policeman, who drew his service pistol when he was confronted by a mob. Seven people were subsequently arrested for public violence and two charged with the assault on the policeman, who spent some time in hospital after he was beaten unconscious.

Yesterday's action by the City Council's cleansing and law enforcement departments caught the community off-guard.

For a while a stand-off ensued between residents and police officers. They had just arrested two young women for incitement after they used a loudhailer to call a community meeting in response to the clean-up.

An angry crowd continued to gather, calling for the release of the two as residents refused to disperse; only doing so when their neighbours emerged from a Metro Police minibus.

Thembinkosi Tshweza expressed a similar sentiment when asked about his thoughts on the opening of the road.

"They should've spoken to people about opening the road. (Mayor) Dan Plato promised that we would be moved within three months, but their failure to tell us means that we'll be here for a long time," Tshweza said.

Like many residents, Tshweza said he was not scared of police rubber bullets because his choices were limited.

"If people start protesting, I'll also join them because we're all in this together," said a defiant Tshweza as he watched the council's mechanical street sweepers clearing Lansdowne Road of accumulated dirt which had stuck to its surface.

One of the community's leaders, Mangaliso Simons, said he had to intervene because confrontation would be one-sided in favour of the police.

"I told people that the police have guns, we are unarmed, along with the fact that many people, including children, would've been hurt if they started shooting at us," Simons said.

He said the community was angry at the council's action before it had made a solid undertaking to remove the community by a set date.

- Cape Times