Thursday, June 20, 2013

Tears and anger over District Six invasion

Cape Town - As the illegal District Six housing occupation entered its fifth day on Wednesday, the street outside the complex where about 50 people have taken over seven flats became a site of heated debate and emotion for apartheid evictees from the area.

The group occupied vacant flats in Aspelling Street on Saturday.

On Monday, the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform and the District Six Beneficiary and Redevelopment Trust secured an interim high court order for the occupiers to leave, but the order has not been enforced.

The matter is set to be brought before the high court again on Thursday.

Pensioners from Cape Flats neighbourhoods, many who identified themselves as beneficiaries registered with the trust, gathered in Aspelling Street to debate the occupation.

Some beneficiaries jeered the occupiers, calling them “queue jumpers” and “scoundrels”. Others pledged solidarity with them, and vowed to join them amid complaints of a botched handover process.

Some of the units being occupied have been finished, yet unoccupied, since 2011.

“Fifteen years of being told to wait, to fill out forms, to attend meetings, and then more forms. If they occupy these flats, we should join them. Because we are fed up,” said Yasmiena Ismail, 55.

Also coming out in support of the occupiers was Daphne Lambert-Moses, 72, who said that she had been evicted three times under apartheid – from Sea Point, Mowbray and District Six. Her family had owned three properties in District Six, she said.

A stand-off with security saw her being blocked at the housing development’s gates as she vowed to take a group of people in to join the occupation.

After an emotional outburst about the indignity and injustice that her family suffered at the hands of the apartheid state, she broke down and wept uncontrollably.

Other former District Six inhabitants, Ismail’s friends, had an opposing view. Zubeida Fortuin, 62, called the occupiers illegitimate and branded them queue jumpers.

Tania Kleinhans, the occupiers’ representative and co-founder of the Institute for the Restoration of the Aborigines of SA (Irasa), complained that some of the observers had accused the Khoisan of having no legitimate claim to land in District Six.

The invaders justify their claim to the units by citing their ancestry from the Cape’s first Khoisan inhabitants.

These “aboriginal rights to land” underpin a notice of motion issued by Kleinhans and will likely be key in the occupiers’ high court argument against eviction.

Kleinhans has employed the assistance of Legal Aid, which is expected to ask for a postponement in court on Thursday. Kleinhans said international aboriginal rights lawyers were also being petitioned to assist the occupiers.

Wallacedene residents on the rampage

Cape town - Somali shops were looted, tyres were burnt and police and journalists had rocks hurled at them as angry Wallacedene residents went on the rampage over housing and service delivery issues on Wednesday.
Residents said they were angry because they had been waiting for proper housing for years and they claimed that government servants and Somali shop owners were buying and renting RDP houses, allegedly from ward councillor Brenda Hansen.
On Wednesday, about 50 illegal structures were removed from the area by city law enforcement officials, and this seemed to fuel the anger of about 1 000 residents.
Police spokesman Thembinkosi Kinana said police had negotiated with the protesters and five people were arrested.
“On arrival at the scene, the police negotiated with protesters who refused to leave the place,” he said.
“At that moment the police ordered the protesters to disperse. It is estimated that about 15 shops in the area were affected by the violence.”
wallacedene
Residents of Wallacedene took to the streets, barricading roads and throwing stones at police and the media in protests about housing and service delivery issues. Pictures: David Ritchie
Cape Argus
Kinana called on residents to protest peacefully.
“We call upon the people not to use violent acts as a form of resolving their problems. The police respect the rights of the people to protest peacefully. However, where acts of violence which infringe on the rights of people are reported, the police have an obligation to intervene and protect lives and property.”
Hansen said regular meetings had been held with the temporary relocation area (TRA) committee members and were aware that residents were angry about a number of issues, especially housing.
“A meeting was scheduled for Monday at 2pm, as agreed with the TRA committee. However this could not take place as some criminals damaged houses and uprooted trees.”
Earlier in the week, residents protested about the same issues and uprooted trees and burnt tyres before marching to the housing office in Kraaifontein.
Hansen denied the allegations made by protesters, and said she was not aware of RDP houses being sold.
“I would, however, urge anybody with information to please forward that to the SAPS, myself or the mayor.”
Resident Skhumbuzo Mkhize said it was unfair that government employees were able to buy the houses.
“The houses are meant for the poor. Here, if you want a house, you must be able to pay. They cost between R15 000 and R18 000, and that is easy money for a police or a teacher to get.”
Mkhize said they had been living “under uncomfortable circumstances” for more than 15 years and they had had enough, adding that Somali businesses were targeted because their owners were also buying RDP houses.
“Now we are burning stuff and making a mess here in our area, but we will loot in town and even go to Parliament,” he said.
Photographers and journalists were subjected to violence and some damage to property.
A Cape Argus photographer was taken into a shack to hide, after threats from protesters. He escaped with a bruise on his leg.
Another photographer was threatened while walking through the area. Three boys chased him and one pulled out a knife.
Residents intervened and escorted the journalists out of the area.
An SABC cameraman was hit on the back of his head by a brick thrown at him.
Kinana said those arrested would be charged with public violence. A strong police presence would remain in the area.

Wednesday, June 19, 2013

Cape Town granted toilet interdict

Cape Town - The City of Cape Town has been granted a final interdict against those who interfere with servicing of toilets, mayor Patricia de Lille said on Wednesday.

The Western Cape High Court made the interim interdict final on Tuesday.

She said the order would ensure that affected communities, especially Kosovo, Kanana, and Barcelona, were given essential services without the obstruction of a few individuals.

The city approached the court last month after groups of people disrupted the servicing of container and portable flush toilets (PFTs). At the time, former Sannicare janitors responsible for cleaning communal toilets blocked part of the N2 highway with burning tyres and dumped faeces on the road.

They were protesting against being dismissed after demanding that they be paid the equivalent of a 16-hour work day. Sannicare rejected the demand and said it was against labour legislation.

Some residents of Barcelona and Kanana apparently removed some of the container toilets from the neighbouring informal settlement, Europe, to close down the highway.

An interim interdict was obtained against 89 former Sannicare employees and seven residents of Ward 40, associated with the ANC Youth League (ANCYL).

The interim order prohibited the named individuals from interfering with service delivery, city staff, and property.

It also prevented them from blocking any roads into and surrounding the N2, Borchards Quarry, NY108, the R300, Klipfontein Road, Stock Road, Symphony Way, Sheffield Road, and Vanguard Drive.

A second protest took place in the vicinity about a week after the interdict was granted.

In protests against rolling out the PFTs human waste was thrown on the steps of the Western Cape legislature and at provincial premier Helen Zille's convoy.

De Lille called on those involved not to do anything illegal. She appealed to the ANCYL to prevent its members from doing so.

Last week, ANCYL national task team co-ordinator Magasela Mzobe took a tour of the toilets in the Barcelona and Kanana informal settlements. He explained the political stance on the issue.

“Throughout this saga, the name of the ANCYL has been mentioned and we felt as a task team we must come and summarise the problems of our people and give the necessary support that they need,” he said at the time.

He said the ANCYL distanced itself from faeces throwing, but not from raising poor service delivery.

“We are talking to them that there is a better way that we can employ in raising the plight of our people without having to throw faeces all over the province,” he said.

“If they do not listen to that, we are forced then to look at the internal processes of disciplinary action.” 

- Sapa

Toilets are ‘a temporary arrangement’

Cape Town - Some Hangberg residents who live above the area’s major firebreak say the move by the City of Cape Town to install toilets is a clear indication that they are meant to stay there permanently.

In 2010 there were riots in the part of Hangberg where the 14 new toilets were installed three weeks ago as residents clashed with law enforcement officers wanting to remove them from the area.

The Hangberg Peace Accord was subsequently signed by mayor Patricia De Lille, Premier Helen Zille, Hangberg residents, SanParks and mediator Brian Williams in which it was agreed that the residents needed to move back to the wider Hangberg community.

When the Cape Argus visited the area this week residents said they saw the new toilets as a sign that the city wanted them to stay above the firebreak.

Erlston Gillian, who lives with his partner, Grechen, and four-month-old daughter Cliché, said he had been living there since 2010. Gillian said when the toilets were installed they were told that three families had to share one toilet. He said this was a sign that the city wanted them to stay because they did not have toilets in the area before.

Auriol Cloete, a resident who lost an eye in the riots, said the number of people living above the firebreak had tripled. “No one knows if the toilets mean they are meant to stay there forever because no one tells us anything.”

Councillor Brett Herron, acting mayoral committee member for Utility Services, said the 14 toilets were meant for the 32 “legal” families who were named in the Hangberg Peace Accord and who would relocate as spaces became available. “The provision of services is thus a temporary arrangement,” he said.

‘Queue-jumpers’ stay put

Cape Town - With the sheriff of the Western Cape High Court missing from the scene of an illegal housing invasion in District Six yesterday, tensions rose between the occupants and the complex’s permanent residents.

Residents accused the invaders of being “queue-jumpers”, while the families who have taken over units in the development in Aspelling Street have rubbished the process by which those residents received houses.

Sixteen beneficiaries were to have received keys to the vacant units this week, said District Six Beneficiary and Redevelopment Trust chairman Anwar Nagia.

One of the beneficiaries who claims to be on the list for this second phase of key handovers is Oesman Begg, whose family were removed from nearby Muir Street in the mid-1970s.

Begg, 63, said he put in a claim with the trust in 2003. He said Rural Development Minister Gugile Nkwinti had told him at a recent meeting that he would not have to pay for the unit.

“I saw the news of this occupation in the press and had to drive here from Mitchells Plain to see for myself. It is heartbreaking,” he said.

“They did not tell me which unit would be mine, so it could be any one of those now being occupied. I have waited patiently and long, now I hear that I will have to wait even longer.

“My dying wish is to return to District Six. These people are trying to jump the queue.”

The group of about 60 invaders claim ancestry from the original Khoisan inhabitants of Table Bay. Some say they were evicted from District Six during apartheid.

They occupied seven units on Saturday and have refused to move - prompting the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform and the trust to petition the high court to bring an application for an interim court eviction order. The order was granted on Monday, and the families were told to move out by 10am yesterday, but by late on Tuesday the sheriff had not arrived to enforce the order.

Throughout the day, members of the Institute for Restoration of the Aborigines of SA performed rituals, sang songs in a Khoisan dialect, and explained their status as descendents of “South Africa’s first peoples” to reporters.

The group claimed the Cochoqua were the first inhabitants of the Cape Flats, but Keith Gottschalk, a University of the Western Cape political scientist, said it was the Gorochoqua and the Goringhaiqua clans who had inhabited the area. Because there were no written documents or birth certificates from that time, it would be interesting to know how the group were going to prove they were who they claimed to be, Gottschalk said.

The occupants are to file opposing papers on Thursday.

Khoi activists to ask for stay of eviction

Cape Times - The group of Khoi activists who occupied several units in a District Six apartment complex on Saturday are to submit papers to the Western Cape High Court on Wednesday morning asking for a stay of an eviction order against them.

The group was meant to be evicted from 11 units on Wednesday morning, but wants a stay until the members are able to dispute the contents of the original eviction order in the Western Cape High Court on Thursday.

Their papers state that the eviction order made by Judge Robert Henney on Monday had not stipulated what time they had to leave the units, and was therefore not applicable.

Tania Kleinhans, head of the Institute for Restoration of the Aborigines of South Africa, has been chosen by the group to put its case to the court tomorrow.

At this stage it is not clear if Kleinhans will be accompanied by a lawyer.

The papers set out how Kleinhans will argue the group’s case, that it be allowed to remain in the units: “We will show that the reclaiming of land process has been bedevilled with problems since inception,” state the papers.

“The voices of the claimants have not been listened to.”

The group will also argue that the “human dignity of the claimants has been compromised”, as some are homeless and live in backyards without electricity or running water.

Kleinhans will also argue that only a few legitimate claimants have been able to move back to District Six.

The group occupied the units in the housing development on Saturday, claiming the area as “ancestral Khoi land”.

On Monday, Western Cape High Court Judge Henney granted an interim eviction order against the group, saying the claimants had to leave the units on Tuesday.

If the group did not vacate the units, Henney said, the sheriff of the court was entitled to expel them on Wednesday with police aid.

But the group has vowed to stay.

The complex, completed in 2011, includes 115 units earmarked for beneficiaries of a District Six resettlement initiative.

The application to evict the group was brought by The Department of Rural Development and Land Reform, together with the trust that manages the apartment complex.

The department said yesterday that the “legitimate” owners of the units were set to move in on Saturday, but this process had now been put on hold.

Each unit is valued at about R1.2 million.

Khoi-Mac, one of the group’s spokesmen, said if evicted they would move on to an open field opposite the complex.

Group member Arthur Martin said a handful of frail occupiers had left during the night, as they feared being “manhandled” by the police.

Sea Point land claim dreams shattered

Cape Town - Valuable Sea Point land - earmarked for development to benefit the families of those forcibly removed from the area under the Group Areas Act - is to be sold as a vacant lot to settle a R14 million debt.

The sale will mark the end of a 13-year battle to honour a land restitution agreement between the beneficiaries, the City of Cape Town and the Department of Land Affairs that was hailed as “groundbreaking” when it was signed in 2001.

“It is a sad day, that the land restitution claim has come to this,” said mayor Patricia de Lille.

Wednesday marks the centenary of the Natives’ Land Act of 1913, the precursor to legislation that stripped black, coloured and Indian people of their property rights.

As the city celebrates its triumphs in dealing with land claims and commits itself to working with other spheres of government to fast-track other outstanding claims, the mayoral committee has had to accept a decision by the Tramway Trust, established in 1996 to represent those families who were evicted from their homes in the 1960s, to give up their fight for land.

The Tramway Trust has revealed that it owes Investec Bank R14m because it could not honour an agreement to develop the land as an upmarket residential complex.

Mayco member for safety and security JP Smith said the sale was “disappointing after the amount of work that went into (the restitution)”. Smith, who was ward councillor for the area, has been closely involved with the process for more than 10 years.

“We went to great lengths to ensure that the land was made available. This incredibly valuable parcel of land was given to the claimants for free. Now it has all come to nought.”

He said plans to cross-subsidise a development that would have been beneficial to the claimants “never came to fruition because of internal politics”. Smith said only one or two of the original claimants were still alive.

“The rest are punch-drunk from all the bureaucracy involved and they just want to settle.”

Smith said several deals fell through because the greed of some claimants who wanted to wait for a better deal.

People’s Post reported last year that the trust was divided over an alternative deal that involved the land being swopped for two blocks of flats in Muizenberg. It was believed that these buildings were on a wetland and were not an ideal alternative.

Smith said the Tramway Park land would now be sold by the trust for development. He said the city did not have any legal rights over the land since it was handed over in 2001. There are no reversionary clauses in the settlement agreement that prevent the trust from approaching the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform to sell the land.

The Tramway restitution was one of city’s land claim success stories. When Sea Point was proclaimed a whites-only suburb in the 60s, the families were forcibly relocated to the Cape Flats. The city bought the property in 1964 and demolished the cottages.

The trust collectively lodged a land claim, and in 2001, the city gave it a piece of land on the corner of Kings and Tramway roads in Sea Point, at no cost. Seventy one of the claimants accepted compensation of R17 500, while 34 claimants sought to benefit from the development of erf 1225.

The initial plan was to construct 42 single residential erven. As most of the beneficiaries were unable to build their own houses, and the trust was unable to raise the required funds, it sought professional advice to help develop the land. The claimants were bound by their restitution agreement to develop the land within 48 months.

According to a report by Pogiso Molapo of the city’s human settlements directorate, the trustees were “ill-advised” about their land and, in 2007, the directorate was informed that a cross-subsidisation model would better suit their needs. It was recommended that the development should be upgraded to 87 units so some of them could be sold.

One of the proposals mooted was for an upmarket residential development, called The Orchards, with 75 luxury apartments priced between R2.5m and R12m. The trust was to have owned 15 units, of which 10 would be sold and the proceeds shared among the claimants. It was hoped that this would serve as a “blueprint” for future restitution developments.

The first sods of this development were turned, with much fanfare, in May 2011. But to date, nothing has been developed on the site.

Molapo said the trust borrowed R200m from Investec for this development plan. But this also flopped, again because some claimants pulled out of the deal in the hopes of securing something better. The trust now owes the bank R14m.

Smith said he was bothered by the “hint of impropriety” that claimants might have missed out on deals because of greed. Although the claimants would have been able to sell their units, if the residential development had got off the ground, the decision to just sell the land outright was “not in the spirit” in which the land was given to them.

* Chairman of the Tramway Road Community Trust, Leonard Lopes, could not be reached for comment.

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

District Six face-off

Cape Town - Tensions were rising in District Six on Tuesday morning, with the Sheriff of the Court due to evict families occupying seven units of a housing development.

The families said they were prepared to stand firm in defiance of a High Court order ordering them to leave.

The Sheriff had not arrived by the 10am deadline set on monday by Judge Robert Henney in his interim order.

Some in the group of around 60 people claim ancestry from the original Khoisan inhabitants of Table Bay, while others say they are land claimants whose families were evicted from District Six under apartheid.

They have been occupying the units since Saturday.

The Department of Rural Development and Land Reform and the trustees of the District Six Beneficiary and Redevelopment Trust brought an application asking the Western Cape High Court for an eviction order.

The occupants are due to return to court on Thursday when they will be allowed to file opposing papers.

Tania Kleinhans, co-founder of the Institute for Restoration of the Aborigines of South Africa (Irasa) and an occupant of one of the units, said they believed the process of land restitution in the area had been fraught with corruption, and that the trust was an illegal body.

The group said they were representing themselves and had not employed a lawyer to file papers on their behalf on Thursday. Kleinhans said they would instead march to the High Court at 2pm and ask for the order to be rescinded.

Asked about the eviction order, the occupants responded emotionally.

“The battle is on. The court will come up against the tongue, heart and spirit of my ancestors if they try to remove me,” said Arthur Martin, who says his family were evicted from District Six when he was 19.

Most of them referred to injustices and “land theft” perpetrated by settlers against the Khoisan as legitimacy for their claims to the units.

“I’m not an infiltrator in this country. There was no agreement between the settlers and the Khoisan.

“I have lost my language, my dignity, my culture at the hands of those settlers. But today I say that I have a legitimate claim to this land,” said Mac Halloway.

Fagmieya Taliep, who said her family owned a number of homes in the area before being forcibly removed to a small house in Heideveld, took issue with the fact that some of the housing units were being leased to foreign tenants.

In court yesterday, advocate Paul Tredoux, representing the applicants, said the group had to be evicted urgently because the flats were earmarked for District Six land claimants who are due to move in on Saturday.

Tredoux said the group was also causing tension at the property because they had vandalised some of the doors by using a crowbar to gain access.

Court evicts ‘Khoisan descendants’ from flats

Cape Town - The Western Cape High Court has given a group of people claiming to be descendants of the Khoisan, who have illegally occupied seven District Six flats since Saturday, until 10am on Tuesday to vacate the properties.

The group consists of 15 families who say they belong to the Cochoqua clan, the original Khoisan people who lived in the area stretching from Table Bay to St Helena Bay.

The Department of Rural Development and Land Reform and the trustees of the District Six Beneficiary and Redevelopment Trust brought an application asking the court for an eviction order.

Advocate Paul Tredoux, representing the applicants, said in court that the group had to be evicted urgently because the flats they occupied were earmarked for District Six land claimants who were due to move in on June 22.

Tredoux said the group was also causing tension at the property because they had vandalised some of the doors by using a crowbar to gain access to the flats.

The order was served on the group on Sunday night and on Monday all parties met at the court where Judge Robert Henney granted the applicants an interim order in terms of section 5 of the Prevention of Illegal Eviction From and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998.

In granting the order, Judge Henney said the group had to vacate the property by 10am on Tuesday. They should come back to court on Thursday when they would be allowed to file opposing papers with the help of a lawyer.

“If the respondents do not vacate the property the sheriff of the court should take the necessary steps to effect the order,” he said.

Outside the court, Tania Kleinhans, co-founder of the Institute for the Restoration of the Aborigines of South Africa (Irasa), who is also one of the illegal occupants, said the court order was inhumane.

“Why would you grant an order to say we need to leave by 10am on Tuesday and then say we need to be back in court on Thursday? Why not let us stay until Thursday because we have nowhere to go at the moment? We are just going to have to squat in District Six,” Kleinhans said.

Another member of the group, Mac Halloway, said it was unfair that they were being chased off their ancestral land and not given a fair chance to state their case.

Bishop Gail Lawrence, president of the Aboriginal Council of Churches said she had come to court to support the Khoisan people.

Lawrence said the interim order had worked in favour of the group because they were not asked to vacate the property immediately.

“It worked in their favour that the judge is allowing them to stay there. This will give them enough time to find legal representatives and to organise themselves better and also find time to regroup.”

Monday, June 17, 2013

Three die in CT shack fires

CAPE TOWN – Three people have died in two separate shack fires over the long weekend, Cape Town Disaster Management officials revealed on Monday.

A couple was killed in a blaze in an informal settlement near Eerste River on Sunday, while a woman died in a shack fire in Philippi on Friday.

Two children were also hurt in that blaze and were treated at the Red Cross Children's Hospital in Cape Town.
Disaster Management Spokesperson Wilfred Solomons-Johannes said the fires were caused by overturned candles or negligence.

“At least 50 people were left homeless across the city.”

According to statistics, the Western Cape has recorded the highest number of shack fires in the past year. 

- ewn

Saturday, June 15, 2013

City demolishes informal settlement shacks

Wynberg - Several residents of the Bonnytoun informal settlement in Wynberg were left homeless on Friday after the city evicted them and demolished their structures in what the shack dwellers claim is harassment by law enforcement officers.

They are also furious that the demolition went ahead “without any court order or letter”, and despite a court interdict which says the city should leave them where they are.

Residents on the scene, sitting looking desperate among the remains of their homes, told Weekend Argus

that authorities first arrived last Saturday, “ransacked” their structures, and even set alight one resident’s clothing.

Yesterday, they returned.

Melikhaya Mangqasane, who has lived there for three years, said he heard voices and doors being kicked in.

“We’ve lost our valuables. My ID is gone with some of the stuff they took. They burnt my TV and some of my winter clothes,” he said, alleging that R150 he was given on Friday had also been taken.

“Law enforcers were sharing (out the contents of) my wallet in front of me (yesterday),” he said.

Now he has nowhere to go.

“It’s winter. You try living without a home,” Mangqasane said.

Long-time resident and former community chairman, Willa Esmando, blamed the escalating anger among the residents on lack of communication between community and forum chairwoman Mona Allie.

“Whenever the leader meets the councillor, who never comes by, we never get any feedback over what transpired from the meetings.

“We’re in the dark as to why the process of registering the evicted people has taken so long, because some of them have been here for longer than the chairwoman has been,” he said.

“Law enforcement waltzed in here with bad attitudes towards the people,” he added.

Esmando urged the city to investigate properly.

Community members said they had been living at the site, alongside the Wynberg fire station, for nearly a decade.

“The way they go about things when they take them out of the houses is wrong,” said Nokuthula Gaqavu, another long-time resident.

“The people are not dogs, and should be told to move out in a decent way before the destruction processes take place.”

After remonstrating with Esmando, Allie said the evictions were inevitable.

“The city told us further settling was illegal, so it was bound to happen. This is council’s ground,” she said, adding the city was just doing its job.

Allie said some of the shacks were protected by a court interdict dating back eight years, but that many more structures had since been built, prompting the evictions.

The city said it continually found additional structures being erected there illegally.

Tandeka Gqada, mayco member for Human Settlements, said: “It must be borne in mind that these are not structures in the true sense of the word, but more wood and cardboard-type structures.

“The city does not remove any personal belongings, but only the material used for the construction of the illegal structure.”

Gqada said anyone with complaints about possessions being removed should lay charges with the police. 

Friday, June 14, 2013

Members deserve awards for poo protest, says ANCYL

ANCYL will not discipline members who went on a poo flinging exercise and praised them for their ability to connect with communities.

While the league does not approve of the method used in the protest against poor sanitation in Cape Town informal settlements, it said it understands the frustration of those who were involved in the protest.

“Assuming that they didn’t throw faeces, we wouldn’t be here,” coordinator of the ANC youth league national task team, Magasela Mzobe told journalists on Thursday morning.

Another youth league task team member Braam Hanekom said that while the league was clear from the onset it doesn’t agree with the method used, it however needed to be noted that the protestors’ actions led to the sanitation issue, particularly in Kosovo, being on the national agenda.

“While we don’t like the method used and we had condemned it, we are not naïve about the fact that what they did was no small achievement,” said Hanekom.

Mzobe said no member of the league will be taken through a disciplinary process by the national task team because of their role in the matter.

“We have engaged them and are confident that they won’t be doing that thing again. We don’t think disciplining them will resolve the problem, we think that people who should be disciplined are the authorities that are responsible for the cleaning or non-cleaning of the toilets not our members.

Raise concerns
“We told our members that we appreciate their ability to connect with the communities and raise concerns of those communities,” he said.

Mzobe said the task team met with the arrested leaders of the protest and other community leaders in informal settlements and told them to stop dumping human waste in government buildings and find other ways of raising their problems with regard to poor service delivery.

“We went to see the arrested leaders yesterday [Wednesday] and we impressed upon them that the ANC Youth League supports their call for proper sanitation and supports their effort to expose the inability and unwillingness of the DA leadership to resolve the problems.

“We then met the community leaders that were not arrested and impressed upon them that it’s high time they changed their method of protest from that of faeces throwing to a proper but fruitful and assisting method that would not lead them to be arrested,” said Mzobe.

He said after seeing the toilets in the affected areas, the league’s national task team understands what the protestors have been crying about.

Mzobe said the league wants Minister of Human Settlements Tokyo Sexwale to intervene and has begun talks with him to come down and resolve the matter.

“We appreciate that the action by these community members is not so much that they love chaos that they would travel such a long distance with faeces to throw here, but it’s because of such a desperate and dire situation they find themselves in and no human being would act rationally under those difficult conditions.

“They have committed themselves that they take our advice and that they would avoid doing that.”

No cleaning
Mzobe said focus shouldn’t be on these affected community members but the council should answer why the toilets had not been cleaned for over three to four months.

He said the communities had written letters to the council, picketed to submit memoranda, raised the issue though public representatives and had run out of other methods because they did not have the money for court.

“We should be acknowledging them. If we had an award in the youth league for the best community leader within our structures … we should be considering that how do you award youth league members whose lives go beyond youth league meetings and they are connected with the frustrations of the people and embody the frustration.”

Mzobe rejected Western Cape Premier Helen Zille’s assertions that the protests are part of an ANC campaign to make the DA-led Western Cape ungovernable.

“There is no intention to make any part of the country ungovernable, but there is every intention to win back the Western Cape and Cape Town and that we will not hide.

“We will bring volunteers of the youth league from across the country to camp here so that we win the elections, but it can’t be a policy position of the youth league to make any part of the country where there is a democratically elected government ungovernable.”

ANC national executive council member Mcebisi Skwatsha, who is also part of the task team, said the dumping of human waste protest reminded him of the “necklace method” which people used in the 1980s.

“It reminds me of the time when we were fighting apartheid and people employed the necklace method. Comrade OR Tambo was asked in 1986 whether the ANC supports this, he said no, we don’t but we understand why people have reached this situation.”

- M&G

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

‘Ringleader’ arrested over faeces row

Cape Town - ANC proportional councillor and youth league member Loyiso Nkohla was arrested on Tuesday morning at Cape Town police station.

Nkohla joins 184 people who were arrested in Woodstock on their way to the provincial legislature on Monday to dump human waste outside Premier Helen Zille’s office.

All the members of the group arrested on Monday appeared in the Cape Town Magistrate’s Court on Tuesday morning, among them former ANC councillor and suspended ANC Youth League member Andile Lili.

While some were released on Monday evening, Lili and six others remained in custody. They were charged with contravening the Gatherings Act, failing to give notice of a protest, contravening a court order, violating the Health Care Act by transporting hazardous material (human faeces on public transport), and for travelling without a valid train ticket.

Nkohla and former ANC councillor Lili seem to be the ringleaders in the “faeces war” on Zille. The two, armed with tanks full of human waste, led the first group of protesters to the provincial legislature last week to spill the sewage outside her office. A day later, the pair were among the group that flung faeces at Zille’s convoy.

A group from Khayelitsha told the Cape Argus before entering the court that they would “continue to fight until there were no more portaloos or bucket systems” in Cape Town.

Sibusiso Zonke, 23, said the charges against him would not stop him taking part in more “poo protests”.

“Since when is it illegal for us to sing Struggle songs in the train when people can sing religious songs without getting arrested? They (the police) must tell us why they arrested us.”

He also mentioned the fact that mayor Patricia de Lille was wearing protective gear and a face mask during her visit to Barcelona and Kanana on Tuesday to clean toilets.

“Why was De Lille wearing a mask yesterday while we have to smell and live with the smell of s*** in our homes every day? She can’t handle the smell, yet she expects us to live with it.”

4 800 ideas for Gugs street names

Cape Town - More than 4 800 proposals have been put forward for the 91 NY streets in Gugulethu that are expected to be renamed by August.

Many of the names suggested are of ordinary people who have contributed in some way to the community - such as Sophaphazi, the owner of a funeral parlour, and Njunja, after an NY11 resident who shone on the basketball court.

While political figures such as Nelson Mandela and Thabo Mbeki are on the list, there are other suggestions that simply capture the spirit of this neighbourhood.

These include “Luvuyile” to signify that “we are happy and united on this street”, “Buntu” because “the people help each other fight crime” and “Sisonke” because “we help and motivate each other”.

Religious names are also popular, such as “Qabazi” to honour the resident priest of the parish on NY3. Struggle icons are also remembered, with proposals for streets to be named after Archie Gumede, Chris Hani and Robert Sobukwe. Businessmen, community leaders, spiritual figures and even the police who were allocated houses in NY155 may feature when the new names are chosen.

Popular tavern owner Mzoli Ngcawuzele may also be honoured for his contribution to the community.

Mayoral committee member for transport Brett Herron said there was still some debate about the meaning of the NY term, commonly thought to stand for “Native Yard”. However, regardless of its meaning, NY was not a “dignified” moniker for the streets and public places of Gugulethu.

“Over the past nine months, assisted by our service provider Name Your Hood, we have been consulting with the residents of Gugulethu, and in particular the people who live on these 91 streets, and have been encouraging them to submit naming proposals for their streets.”

He said the city’s extensive public consultation process had been very successful.

“We have knocked on doors and spoken to residents at shops, churches, schools and other public places in Gugulethu. We have also run a very modern electronic platform for our Gugs residents to submit naming proposals.”

The 11-person panel, chaired by Shado Twala, will consider the proposals and make recommendations to the city’s naming committee. These will then be referred to the mayor and council for approval.