Monday, July 8, 2013

Battle lines drawn in ‘poo war’

Cape Town - While nine men remain in custody after human waste was dumped at Cape Town International Airport, a new group have taken up the “poo war” against the City of Cape Town.

The nine in custody face serious charges under the Civil Aviation Act and, if found guilty, up to 30 years in prison.

The new group, comprising 15 members, say they are willing to be arrested for their actions.

The 15, who say they represent the areas “affected” by the fight with the city over toilets, announced on Friday they had established a task team.

They say they are not politically aligned, and will continue protesting and throwing faeces.

The task team’s secretary, Phaphamani Ngcingi, said the protests would continue.

The task team’s spokesman, Sithembele Majova, said the group’s role would be to “interact with the relevant people” and to “lead and co-ordinate” them against the city’s sanitation resolutions.

The group warned that the protests would “be worse”.

It said the protests over the past four weeks had had an impact “even on the most ignorant person”.

“The mere fact that the N2 is packed with metro police every 5km since that Monday morning simply means that the Western Cape government is more worried about the few elite who are fortunate enough to use this route daily,” the task team’s statement read.

The team demanded the protesters in custody be released immediately or the province would be made “ungovernable”.

It said the police were provoking residents by arresting protesters. That ANC councillor Loyiso Nkohla and former councillor Andile Lili remained in custody did not “weaken’’ their “struggle in rejecting portable flush toilets”.

The city has agreed to engage with the group if they are serious about improving services.

The mayoral committee member for human settlements, Ernest Sonnenberg, said the city would engage with any group or organisation that was genuinely interested in improving service delivery.

“However, we cannot engage with organisations that promote breaking the laws of the country to raise their issues,” he added.


Council workers need police protection in CT

Cape Town - The City of Cape Town has had to deploy law enforcement officers to protect council workers who are upgrading housing projects in several areas, including Manenberg and Ottery.

“This year alone, 17 violent disruptions have occurred… most of which were gang-related. Employees of the city’s contractors and city officials have been shot at, threatened and intimidated,” said Thandeka Gqada, mayoral committee member for human settlements.

There have been six cases at the Ottery sites, and nine in Manenberg and Hanover Park. In the latest, on June 28, a worker was attacked and had to be taken by ambulance for treatment, said Gqada.

The city has also had to provide police protection for contractors cleaning toilets in the informal settlements of Barcelona and Kanana, where there have been attacks and a municipal vehicle has been torched.

Gqada said the attacks on municipal staff held up attempts to upgrade community residential units.

City of CT charged for raising tariffs

Cape Town - Criminal charges have been laid against Cape Town mayor Patricia de Lille over higher electricity tariffs that came into effect last week.

National advocacy director of Consumer Fair, Imraahn Ismail-Mukaddam, said charges of corruption and theft had also been brought against mayoral committee member for finance Ian Neilson, and the city manager Achmat Ebrahim. The cases were opened at the Cape Town Central Police Station, he said.

“We believe that these City of Cape Town officials and office-bearers have a case to answer to due to the fact that they increased the electricity tariff for users in the 350 to 600 kWh a month category by 56 percent, which is 500 percent more than the increase allowed by the National Energy Regulator of South Africa (Nersa).”

Responding to the charges, the city’s Priya Reddy said the new tariffs had been approved by Nersa and that Ismail-Mukaddam had not “fully understood the complexity” of the tariff structure and the provision of free basic electricity.

“It should be noted that the tariffs were adopted by the council, and not by the mayor or the city manager or any other individual,” explained Reddy.

The city has two possible tariffs available for domestic consumers, which are applicable whether supplies are metered by credit or prepaid.

There is the domestic tariff, which is applicable to customers who receive more than 450kWh a month on average.

The other is the lifeline tariff, which is highly subsidised and aimed at customers who receive an average of 450kWh or less a month.

Ismail-Mukaddam said Neilson was pushing poor communities to switch to the domestic tariff so that they could subsidise the more affluent higher users.

Reddy said Ismail-Mukaddam’s claims lacked credibility as the tariffs had been fully published in local newspapers and were available on the city’s website.

Seven poo dumpers denied bail

Cape Town - Seven men who allegedly dumped human waste at Cape Town International Airport were denied bail by the Bellville Magistrate's Court on Monday.

Magistrate Jannie Kotze ruled that it was not in the interest of justice to release the men because it was likely they would commit a similar offence again.

The men are Loyiso Nkohla, Andile Lili, Yanga Njingwana, Ben Dyani, Jaji Diniso, Bongile Zanazo, and Thembela Mabanjwa.

The magistrate granted bail of R500 each to the two remaining men, Bantubakhe Mqobodiya and Wandisile Mkapa, on the basis of their medical conditions.

They were ordered not to convene or attend a protest without authorisation, to refrain from threatening, intimidating or interfering with members of the public, and to not damage or interfere with public property.

All the men are charged under the Civil Aviation Act, and face up to 30 years in prison if they are found guilty.

The men allegedly dumped 10 buckets of faeces at the departures terminal of the airport on June 25.

Nkohla, who is an ANC councillor, and Lili, who is a former councillor, were arrested while out on a warning for a similar offence.

They were released on condition they not take part in any protests.

“In spite of this condition, they arranged for faeces to be dumped at the airport which, in fact, has nothing to do with service delivery,” Kotze said.

“They even went and notified the media. The only inference the court can draw from this is that they were not worried about being identified. This shows no respect for the court or legal system.”

The case was postponed until August 5, for the investigation to be completed and for the director of public prosecutions to decide on a trial court.

Supporters packed the benches and shouted as the men were led back to the holding cells.

They became loud and started singing songs in the court, while police officers looked on.

They took their protest outside and sang and danced peacefully in front of the court building in Landros Road. - Sapa

'Shack fires caused by negligence'

CAPE TOWN - Cape Town’s Disaster Risk Management Services at the weekend said most domestic fires are caused by lack of thought or concentration.

Two people died in separate fires in the Western Cape over the past few days.

A 28-year-old man in Khayelitsha was killed and an eight-month-old baby in Bonteheuwel burned to death when her parent’s wendyhouse caught on fire. 

Disaster Management Wilfred Solomons-Johannes said a series of fires at the weekend could have been prevented if residents were more careful. 

"Most of these fires are a result of people leaving open flames unattended."

He said there’s an increase in shack fires during the winter months as residents try to keep warm. 

Meanwhile, fires in the Western Cape have left more than 30 residents in Atlantis, Khayelitsha, Durbanville and Langa, homeless. 

- EWN

Sunday, July 7, 2013

CT shack fires claim lives

CAPE TOWN - Cape Town Disaster Management says nearly 30 people have been left homeless in separate shack fires in the Cape Peninsula this weekend.

On Sunday morning, four people were displaced when a shack was destroyed in Langa.

This follows a series of shack fires that claimed the lives of a 28-year-old man and an eight-month-old baby.

Disaster management's Wilfred Solomons-Johannes says, “A spate of fires occurred across the Cape Peninsula which resulted in people being displaced.”

Meanwhile, a man is in a serious condition in hospital after he lost control of his vehicle and ploughed into shacks in Khayelitsha.

The accident occurred while the driver swerved his vehicle to avoid hitting children who were trying to cross the road on Saturday.

No one else was injured during the crash.

Solomons-Johannes says, “The driver was then rushed to the Tygerberg Hospital.”

The affected households have since received food parcels, blankets and building materials.

- EWN

Motlanthe challenges Zuma to be transparent about Nkandla

DEPUTY President Kgalema Motlanthe has challenged his boss, President Jacob Zuma, to make the Nkandla report public.

DEPUTY President Kgalema Motlanthe has challenged his boss, President Jacob Zuma, to make the Nkandla report public.

Motlanthe was speaking to Tim Modise on new talk radio station Power FM on Thursday night.

When Motlanthe was asked about the government's classification of the Nkandla report as secret, he was unambiguous, albeit in his softly guarded way.

"Of course, you cannot divulge information that would make the occupants of that residence vulnerable, but I would have thought that the scope of the project would be made public.

"Accountability and transparency are sides of the same coin. It is important to be accountable in the public space. Once there's a shroud of secrecy, it gives rise to speculation, suspicion, mistrust.

"Once you have those three elements together you can't lead effectively - every word you utter, there are 101 questions and there are doubts because nobody believes [you].

"To be able to lead effectively there shouldn't be doubt; leadership goes side by side with prestige," he said.

Modise probed further: "So, if it were up to you, you wouldn't classify that?"

"There's no need," he answered. "Once there was clamour and an outcry about it, there was no need to shroud it in secrecy.

"There's nothing wrong with giving information on the scope of the project."

The Nkandla report by the Department of Public Works regarding the R203m spent on Zuma's private residence in rural Nkandla, in KwaZulu-Natal, has been classified top secret.

Zuma has ferociously defended himself against the uproar over Nkandla. He told parliament that he and his family paid for the home and that the government had added security features in accordance with his own needs analysis.

Zuma spokesman Mac Maharaj said he had not heard the Power FM interview and could not comment because the Nkandla matter was the subject of an investigation.

Political analyst Somadoda Fikeni said he read into Motlanthe's remarks a cautious, suppressed frustration.

"Motlanthe has always advocated a different approach," Fikeni said. "He even campaigned on it - that things can be handled differently. He has expressed this from time to time."

Asked if he thought that Motlanthe's frustration was so strong that he would walk away from the ANC at the end of the current administration, Fikeni said: "I don't see the deputy president disappearing into the sunset like former president Thabo Mbeki.

"He is a cautious politician. I think that he will feel that he will make more of an impression by going to the political school of the ANC and raising issues and teaching future leaders of the ANC about the things that have caused his frustration."

Man burns to death in shack fire

A man has burnt to death in shack fire in Khayelistsha on Saturday morning, The City of Cape Town's Disaster Risk Management Centre said.

Spokesman Wilfred Solomons-Johannes said the fire broke-out in the early hours of the morning. Ntuthuzelo Matshoba, 28, was believed to have been sleeping when the fire broke-out. .

“It is suspected that a candle was knocked over (and) that could have caused the fire. The preceding events leading up to the incident is unclear,” said Solomons-Johannes. - Sapa

Friday, July 5, 2013

The Nkandla files: Project railroaded from the start

In May 2009, a fortnight after Jacob Zuma's presidential inauguration, a team of officials was dispatched to Nkandla to investigate how best to secure his home.

Led by police, military and intelligence officers, who laid down security requirements, the public works team of professionals put together a detailed "scope of works".

Their extensive recommendations included the upgrading of access roads, perimeter fencing, fire-fighting, sanitation, a heliport, air conditioning with biological filters in a "safe haven" and, puzzlingly, a "revamped" cattle kraal.

The department of public works's chief quantity surveyor, Ron Singh, ran the numbers, reporting that the job would cost just less than R28-million.

Zuma's contractors

The department's national office fired instructions off to its Durban branch, where regional manager Kenneth Khanyile would oversee the procurement of specialists to plan, design and construct the upgrades.

A handwritten note by a member of the budget committee that approved the funding gave an early indication that the project was being railroaded. It read: "Due to the urgent nature of service, service must proceed and funds will be made available periodically, as and when savings materialise from prestige/PWD [public works] budget."

This urgency and a willingness to sweep aside procedures was entrenched that October in 2009, when Khanyile described an agreement with acting director general Solly Malebye in which the Durban office would be given special powers to approve big Nkandla contracts worth more than R20-million.

Meanwhile, the department's procurement processes were in effect leapfrogged to favour Zuma's personal choice of three firms, privately hired for home renovations two years earlier. This was "essential", public works project manager Jean Rindel noted, "to ensure complete integration".

The private quantity surveyors on the project, in turn, handed the department a list of contractors from which it would choose, again deviating from supply chain processes, Khanyile wrote.

By February 2010, the main building, electrical and civil contractors had been chosen. Among these were the major contractors, Bonelena and Moneymine, the latter having been hired earlier by Zuma. Moneymine's appointment by public works was also "essential", Rindel said, because the company "is trusted by the owner of the property [Zuma]".

According to internal records, public works had spent R4.1-million on the project by the end of that financial year, March 31 2010. Yet the first of three project phases had barely begun.

Zuma's deadline

By June 2010, Rindel's project team at public works was ready to hand over the site to contractors for phase one of Nkandla, or "Prestige Project A", but they had not received official sign-off from the defence department or police.

Although Rindel calculated they would need just less than ­R40-million a year for two years to complete Project A, funding had still not been found.

His request was escalated to a national budget committee, recommending that the money be siphoned from two important programmes: inner-city regeneration and the dolomite risk management programme.

The contractors moved on to site that month.

In another supply chain management sidestep, Rindel's team appointed a security consultant without first getting approval from the regional adjudication committee. Justifying this three months later, he said the work had needed to start "immediately", apparently illustrated when the consultant was called "to accompany the [deputy director general] and minister [Geoff Doidge] on visits to the fencing and glass suppliers in order to expedite the work".

By then it was August, and Doidge was clearly coming under pressure from above to fast-track Project A.

In mid-September 2010, he set a "strict deadline" for the completion of phase one. Months later, when Rindel motivated for more funding because of serious cost overruns, he revealed the source of this pressure: "[Doidge] instructed this office to continue with immediate effect, as he was given a deadline by the principal to have the site operational by December 1."

"The principal" refers to Zuma.

Within a week of setting this deadline, Doidge and other senior police, defence and public works officials met at Nkandla, where the minister dished out instructions to get things done.

Justifying the cost overruns, Rindel explained that, at this late stage, the South African Police Service had submitted a "revised" scope of works. This had Rindel rushing to appoint more service providers – for the supply of bullet-resistant glass, a generator and prefabricated structures – with "emergency" permission obtained from Khanyile. Formal permission was again sought months after procurement.

According to Rindel, "the lengthy process" of waiting for approvals "could compromise the security of the principal and would not be ­tolerated. This was made very clear by the top management of the police service and the department of defence."

But the department's chief quantity surveyor, Glenda Pasley, was worried. She wrote to Rindel: "The scope of works and costs have increased substantially on the project over the past few months, giving rise to serious concerns about what control mechanisms and parameters are in place."

She also said there was no clarity on how the enormous cost would be split between Zuma and the state.

Another surveyor, Dumi Gqwaru, lamented the state of the contracts: "If a contractor were to be nasty, she would take us to the cleaners … I could not agree more with [Deputy Minister Hendrietta Bogopane-Zulu] in referring to this project as 'project went wrong'."

Meanwhile, Zuma shuffled his Cabinet at the end of October, sacking Doidge before the deadline could be met.

The replacement minister, Gwen Mahlangu-Nkabinde, enthusiastically grabbed the Nkandla baton. In her first week in office, she submitted a detailed report to the president, reassuring him that everything was on track for December 1.

But the project team missed Zuma's deadline by three weeks. Evidently this caused consternation in high places. In a letter motivating for more fast-track measures, this time for phase two, Rindel said speed was "essential" because "the state already delayed the owner of the property [Zuma], and this caused much embarrassment to the state".

When the state prepared for the phase two contracts, it once again negotiated with Bonelena and Moneymine. As for the latter, this was once again according to Zuma's wishes.

According to a document discussing Moneymine: "[Bogopane-Zulu] confirmed that the principal indicated that he does not want other contractors on site in phase two."

Zuma's second deadline

By the end of the 2011 financial year, Project A had cost R62.3-million.

As phase two got under way, officials reluctantly began to wrestle with the question of how much Zuma would pay.

Meanwhile, Khanyile asked for permission to deviate once again from procurement prescripts for a security detection system. His request revealed another Zuma-driven deadline and a presidential secrecy requirement.

"The instructions of the owner must be respected," said Khanyile. These were that information should be contained and the project had to be completed by October 30 2011 "as per instruction from the principal".

The state quantity surveyors now complained that they had been sidelined. Pasley wrote to Rindel: "We are no longer in touch with the project as you have excluded us." And months later: "We have to date not been briefed by you." She wanted to see financial reports and cost-allocation decisions. "This is of serious concern."

Late in the year, and early in 2012, Rindel submitted another batch of requests to pay contractors extra after further cost overruns.

By March 2012, as the financial year came to a close, the state had spent almost R190-million on Project A.

Top secrecy

Throughout 2011, complaints flowed over contractor Bonelena's missed deadlines and, early in 2012, a consultant recommended that the contractor be fired. The company had cash flow trouble and was at the root of serious delays.

This appeared to elicit attention from the highest levels, because in January 2012, newly appointed Public Works Minister Thulas Nxesi met the company's owner, Thandeka Nene, in the first of several personal engagements.

In April that year, steps were taken to terminate Bonelena's contract but the company disputed it. Official memos recommended that an amicable settlement would be best to prevent information leaking out through a court battle.

This softly-softly approach – Nxesi and Nene's personal liaisons included – continued even after Bonelena filed for liquidation in July.

Even the state-owned funder, the Industrial Development Corporation, came to Bonelena's rescue. According to The Mercury, this year, the corporation bailed out Bonelena with R10-million, despite the fact that the company already owed it millions.

In correspondence with the national office, Khanyile put the problem plainly: Zuma's reputation.

"Court cases will result in public scrutiny … This is an unacceptable risk to this office and could result in political fallout that could possibly influence the principal's [Zuma] political position very negatively."

In October, press leaks resulted in a major public outcry and, as phase three of Nkandla began, internal reports projected Zuma's Project  would cost the state as much as R273.8-million – nearly 10 times what had been proposed back in 2009.

- M&G

Zumaville Hangout

Nkandla: DA wants to probe if Zuma misled Parliament

"I have today written to the speaker of the National Assembly Max Sisulu to request that an urgent resolution be placed on the agenda ... which would establish a full-scale investigation into whether ... Zuma misled Parliament," she said in a statement on Friday.

"I will also request that all documentation, including the public works task team report, into ... Zuma's private residence be submitted to the National Assembly without delay to form the basis of this investigation."

Earlier, the Mail & Guardian reported that the public works department released 42 files with over 12 000 pages on the Nkandla upgrade to the newspaper.

They were released following a request for information, under the Promotion of Access to Information Act, about public spending on Zuma's private residence in KwaZulu-Natal.

The request was submitted a year ago and pointed out that the act obliged the department to redact parts of the requested information related to security, while making the rest available.

Bid evaluations
The documents were released to the newspaper two weeks ago, and related to bid evaluations, needs assessments, contracts awarded and their values, and to whether costs were allocated for public or private accounts. 

The public works task team report was declared top secret and closed to public scrutiny. The files provided to the newspaper contained numerous references to documents or annexures which were not disclosed.

The M&G reported that there appeared to be no security-related basis for their redaction.

There was nothing in the Nkandla files that could not have been publicly disclosed, except for how senior officials and politicians "scrambled" to meet deadlines set by Zuma, and how short-cuts were taken in tendering processes.

Money was also shifted from other programmes to accommodate the unbudgeted spending. The M&G reported that the cost of the Nkandla homestead ballooned from R27.8-million in 2009 to a projected total of about R270-million by October 2012.

The official expenditure as of June this year was reportedly R210.5-million.

This did not appear to include bills yet to be paid.

The newspaper further reported that Zuma was expected to pay 5% of the security-related improvements.

Public purse
It said a top-secret March 2011 memorandum split the bill by allocating R203-million to the public purse, and R10.5-million for Zuma's account. 

Mazibuko said the newspaper's report showed that Zuma had omitted important information when questioned by Parliament about the upgrade.

"These reports show that he was not merely a bystander as he claimed in his reply to my parliamentary questions on 15 November 2012," Mazibuko said.

She quoted Zuma as saying in Parliament: "My residence in Nkandla has been paid for by the Zuma family. All the buildings and every room we use in that residence were built by ourselves as a family and not by government.

"I have never asked government to build a house for me, and it has not done so. The government has not built a home for me."

Mazibuko said the magnitude of the newspaper's revelations on Friday brought the office of the president into "massive disrepute".

"Parliament must take urgent action and send the message that corruption at any level will not be tolerated," she said.

Presidency spokesperson Mac Maharaj declined to comment. "You say the request was sent to the speaker. The speaker can respond to that matter. There is no need for us to respond to that matter," he said. 

– Sapa

Baby dies in Wendy house blaze

Cape Town - An eight-month-old girl died in a fire in a Wendy house in Bonteheuwel, the City of the Cape Town said on Friday.

The fire broke out after 10pm on Thursday night, the city's disaster risk management centre spokesman Wilfred Solomons-Johannes said.

“Kauthar Abrahams, who was too young to react by escaping from the devastating blaze, succumbed to her fatal burn wounds,” he said.

The baby's grandmother Aisha Abrahams, 57, tried to rescue her but suffered from smoke inhalation. She was taken to a nearby hospital.

“According to preliminary investigations, it is suspected that the fire was started due to open flames from a lit candle that overturned and ignited the bedding,” Solomons-Johannes said. - Sapa

Poo-dumpers face wrath of ANC

Cape Town - Faeces-flinging ringleaders Loyiso Nkohla and Andile Lili are to be hauled before a party disciplinary committee as soon as they are released from custody, the ANC says.

ANC regional secretary Vuyiso “JJ” Tyhalisisu said on Thursday that charges against the pair had been formulated and would be served as soon as they were granted bail.

He said that apart from bringing the party into disrepute, the pair disobeyed orders from the ANC’s national leadership.

“The national leadership called on them to stop using faeces during their protests, but they ignored this,” Tyhalisisu said.

“As soon as they are out, we will serve the charges. There’s no doubt that action will be taken.”

Nkohla, Lili and seven others are in custody following the dumping of human waste in the departures hall at the Cape Town International Airport last week. They are accused of contravening the Civil Aviation Act.

This came two weeks after Nkohla and Lili led a group of protesters on similar faeces-dumping missions to the provincial legislature and a provincial government building in Greenmarket Square.

Tyhalisisu said the ANC metro region had also written to the party’s provincial executive asking that it suspend Nkohla, a proportional representative councillor, pending the outcome of the disciplinary hearing.

Lili, a former City of Cape Town councillor, was fired last year and expelled from the ANC Youth League.

City Speaker Dirk Smit confirmed on Thursday that Nkohla continued to receive his salary as a councillor.

He said his office had investigated Nkohla’s role in faeces-throwing incidents and the matter had been referred to the city’s disciplinary committee.

“They will schedule hearings and report the findings to council,” Smit said.

“He (Nkohla) can expect anything from a warning to dismissal. Whatever the multiparty disciplinary committee decides will be sent to the local government MEC, who will make a final decision.”

The Nkandla files: Secrecy obsessions betray political sensitivities

From the start, the battle over state spending on President Jacob Zuma's Nkandla security upgrade has been as much about secrecy as about cost.

This is captured in a top-secret memo from Durban regional manager Kenneth Khanyile to his superiors at the public works department.

Dated March 15 2012, the document sets out proposals for managing prestige projects in a different way to other projects.

Scope of works
Khanyile notes: "In order to ensure security, it is essential that the ­project be removed from the 'public eye' due to security reasons."

He says the "scope of works" includes "information that may be used by the enemies of the state to engineer an attack", but adds, "these projects are further targeted by journalists in an attempt to discredit the government in general".

These considerations justify deviating from normal tender processes, he argues. Not only that, special audit procedures need to be adopted.

Special security-cleared personnel should be appointed from the auditor general's office, he says, and he informs the director general of "the intention of the Durban regional office to withhold all project information from auditing until clear directive has been received".

Phillip Masilo, the legal adviser to Public Works Minister Thulas Nxesi, told amaBhungane that Khanyile's policy proposal was never adopted.

Formally, that may be true, but Nxesi's attitude appears consistent with Khanyile's.

Nxesi has defended the top-secret classification given to his own task team's report on Nkandla and has gone as far as to tell Parliament that this rendered him "unable to provide the auditor general and the public protector with copies of the report".

He has since provided the public protector with a copy.

Masilo said the documents released to amaBhungane did not demonstrate that the task team report was incorrectly classified.

"It is … clear that other documents that contain sensitive security information were not released to the Mail & Guardian," he said. "Therefore, your conclusion about the classification of the report based on the documents released is unfounded."

- M&G